TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Multiple Monitors
Volume Number:10
Issue Number:7
Column Tag:There’s a right way...

Related Info: Window Manager Dialog Manager Standard File
Quickdraw

Multiple Monitors vs. Your Application

Assume one monitor, go to jail...

By Eric Shapiro, Rock Ridge Enterprises

Note: Source code files accompanying article are located on MacTech CD-ROM or source code disks.

About the author

Eric earned fame with his big-hit, glam-hack VideoBeep, first shown at MacHack as a prize-winning entry in the MacHax™ Best Hack contest. When he’s not busy writing his next hack for MacHack, Eric is president of Rock Ridge Enterprises, a Macintosh consulting firm. His other smash hits include Spectator, EzTape, Business Simulator, and (the now illegal) The Grouch.

Eric is currently working on course materials for Apple Developer University’s OpenDoc seminar. He has taught Macintosh Programming Fundamentals and Macintosh Device Drivers seminars for Apple as well. Eric has degrees in both Computer and Electrical Engineering from the University of Michigan and is a past president of MacTechnics Users Group.

You can reach Eric at Shapiro@aol.com

[Eric, otherwise way-too-busy-to-write-an-article, found a reason to sound off. The result? A stream-of-consciousness gripe piece with some useful information. If you’d like to see more of these kinds of articles, please let us know. Better yet, pick your favorite gripe about software done the wrong way, and write up your own “There’s a right way ” article. - Ed stb]

I am writing this article because I’ve recently come across 5 new Mac programs in the last few weeks that don’t support multiple monitors correctly. I’m getting sick of rebooting, and of explaining the various problems to the companies involved, so I’m going to send them a copy of this article instead.

Like many programmers, my main screen is a 2-page b&w display while my second screen is a 13” color display. Several of the programs I’ve been running have problems with all 2 monitor systems. Other programs run properly on some 2 monitor setups, but get confused when the main device has a lower depth than the second one.

Here’s a checklist for writing well-behaved Macintosh software:

Open windows on the proper screen

New document windows should be opened on the same screen as the parent window. If there is no parent window, use the main screen (or, if you want to be really cool, use whichever screen was most recently used for a document).

It is easiest to create windows invisibly, add controls and other items to the window, position and resize it, and then make it visible. A new version of one popular developer tool creates the window visibly first, and then quickly snaps it to its new size/location. This is very disconcerting (and somewhat reminiscent of HyperCard).

The Window Manager in System 7 makes it easy to properly place new windows, as long as they don’t need to be resized dynamically. Simply set the Auto-Position field in a WIND or DLOG resource to Parent window or Parent window’s screen.. If your application contains floating palette windows, you’ll have to hide them before calling GetNewWindow or GetNewDialog for this scheme to work.

The standard file box is a particularly nasty dialog, because it’s difficult to center on the proper monitor. The problem is that the size stored in the DLOG resource is unreliable, especially when using utilities like Norton’s “Directory Assistance”. Generally, though, everything works fine if you assume the standard size and place the dialog on the top portion of the designated screen. You will have to use the CustomGetFile call instead of the easier StandardGetFile call to position the dialog on an arbitrary device.

The color picker also needs to be special cased, because it should probably be placed on the deepest device (although this might not be true for all programs). Under recent System versions, this can be accomplished by passing (-1, -1) for the dialog location. Programs like PhotoShop have their own moveable color pickers that the user can drag to any screen.

Default document size

Don’t assume that new document windows should completely fill the main screen. This is very annoying to owners of large displays. Let the user specify a default document size or write a little code to make sure that the default document isn’t oversized.

Dragging

There are still some programs that don’t allow windows to be dragged to second monitors. While holding down the Cmd/Option keys often overrides this problem, the programs really should be updated. Many programs pass screenBits.bounds to DragWindow as the limit rectangle. This works on multiple monitor systems only because Apple put a kludge in the Window Manager to support old software [It may be a kludge, but Apple would be crazy to change it - Ed stb]. Don’t inset it, just pass screenBits.bounds to DragWindow or use the following “morally correct” code:


/* 1 */
 if ( gHasColorQuickDraw )
 limitR = (**GetGrayRgn()).rgnBBox;
 else
 limitR = screenBits.bounds;

 DragWindow( myWindow, theEvent->where, &limitR );

Reference screenBits.bounds as qd.screenBits.bounds when using either MPW or the universal header files.

Zooming

See develop Magazine #17 for a good article on proper zooming. Windows should zoom out to their current monitor and not the main monitor.

Remember window positions

Window positions should be stored within the document file for document windows or within the application’s “Preferences” file for non-document windows. When a document is opened, return the window to the saved location. Be sure to check that the window and its title bar still overlap the grayRgn, because the monitor setup may have changed. I’ve seen several programs (including some best sellers) that will open a window positioned completely off all monitors. Other programs will open windows with their title bars underneath the menu bar. The window’s size should never be larger than the device, because it may be impossible for the user to reach the growBox. Forcing the entire window onscreen is not unreasonable. Lastly, make sure your calculations don’t choke on negative window coordinates - this will be the case for monitors positioned to the left or above the main device.


/* 2 */
/*
 IsPositionOK
 
 Description:
 Checks to make sure the passed global rectangle is completely contained 
within the gray region. Pass the window’s portRect in global coordinates.

 Notes:
Depends on two regions, gSpareRgn1 and gSpareRgn2, having been allocated 
globally (using NewRgn).
  
 Your application might want to allow partially offscreen windows. 
 
Document windows are assumed to have title heights of 20 pixels. There 
are moredynamic ways of handling this, such as positioning the window 
way offscreen and checking its structure region. 
*/
Boolean IsPositionOK( Rect *globalR, Boolean isDocWindow )
{
 BooleanisOK = false;
 Rect   fullWindowR;
  
 #define kDocWindowHeight 20// pixels
 
 // put the window rect into gSpareRgn1
 fullWindowR = *globalR;
 if ( isDocWindow )
 fullWindowR.top -= kDocWindowHeight;
 RectRgn( gSpareRgn1, &fullWindowR );
 
 // see if the window completely intersects the grayRgn
 SectRgn( GetGrayRgn(), gSpareRgn1, gSpareRgn2 );
 if ( EqualRgn( gSpareRgn1, gSpareRgn2 ) )
 isOK = true;
 
 return( isOK );
}

Games

Games are notorious for not running properly on multiple monitor systems. With my particular setup (a b&w main screen and a color 2nd screen), many games look at the main device and put up an error message complaining about the screen depth.

A little extra checking solves this problem. Let’s say your game requires an 8-bit monitor. (Apple says that programs shouldn’t require specific screen depths, but they don’t write games, either [although there was an entire session and a show of support for games at WWDC this year - Ed stb]). If the main screen supports 8-bits, use it. Apple says you shouldn’t force the monitor to a particular depth, but for games it is probably ok. [You can always ask the user whether that’s ok - Ed stb] Use the HasDepth and SetDepth calls to do this and do not call the video drivers directly. If the main screen doesn’t support 8-bit graphics, scan the device list for a device that does. Using the first device you find that supports 8-bit graphics is reasonable, because very few users have 3 monitor systems. If you want to be really cool, though, let the user choose which monitor to play the game on (or play it across several monitors!).

Many games (and other programs a well) use screenBits.bounds to find the size of the monitor. On systems with Color QuickDraw, use the gdRect field of a GDevice instead.


/* 3 */
/*
 FindDeviceThatSupportsDepth
 
 Returns:
 The GDHandle for a device that supports the passed depth.
 Returns nil if no device found or no color quickdraw.
 
 Notes:
 Requires System 6.05 or later.
*/
GDHandle FindDeviceThatSupportsDepth( short theDepth )
{
 GDHandle aScreen;
 
 if ( !gHasColorQuickDraw )
 return( nil );

 // first check the main screen - it takes precedence
 aScreen = GetMainDevice();
 if ( DoesDeviceSupportDepth( aScreen, theDepth ) )
 return( aScreen );
 
 // step through all the screens
 aScreen = GetDeviceList();
 
 while ( aScreen )
 {
 if ( DoesDeviceSupportDepth( aScreen, theDepth ) )
 return( aScreen );
 aScreen = GetNextDevice( aScreen );
 }

 return( nil );
}

Boolean DoesDeviceSupportDepth( GDHandle theDevice, short theDepth )
{
 if (   IsDeviceActive( theDevice ) && 
 HasDepth( theDevice, theDepth, 0/*whichFlags*/, 0 ) )
 return( true );
 else 
 return( false );
}

Boolean IsDeviceActive( GDHandle theDevice )
{
 if ( !theDevice )
 return( false );

 /*
 sometimes newly installed video cards show the main device
 as inactive. we’ll make an extra check for this case.
 */
 if ( theDevice == GetMainDevice() )
 return( true ); // main device is always active
 
 if (   TestDeviceAttribute( theDevice, screenDevice ) &&
 TestDeviceAttribute( theDevice, screenActive ) )
 return( true );
 else
 return( false );
}

General drawing

Responding properly to update events on multiple monitor systems is a little tricky. The programs I’ve been using fall under one of the following categories:

1) Work properly on single monitor systems

2) Work properly on multiple monitor systems, as long as windows don’t span 2 screens of different depths

3) Work properly on all systems and window sizes

Your software should fall under category 3, or at least number 2.

Let’s say your program contains 2 versions of all its artwork - one for b&w monitors and one for color monitors (since dithering is so ugly, you don’t want to draw your color pictures on b&w devices). On a single device system, it is easy to choose which picture to display - just look at the main screen’s depth. On a multiple device system, the picture choice must be made by looking at the window’s size and position. If a window spans 2 monitors, you may have to load and draw both the b&w picture and the color picture in response to a single update event.

See develop #13 for an article on the DeviceLoop call and how it will help you handle this problem. For programmers supporting older System versions, it’s not too hard to write your own version of DeviceLoop.

As an example of improper drawing, look at these two screen dumps from America Online. The top one indicates how the b&w artwork should look. The bottom one shows what happens when the color artwork is displayed on a b&w screen.

Screen depth change

Except for games, programs should be able to run at any screen depth. Users can change the depth at will - you should check the monitor depth during update events to see if it has changed. If you keep offscreen buffers, you may have to change their size and depth as well. This can present a problem if the user increases the screen depth and you don’t have enough memory for your offscreen buffers. In that case, consider drawing the window contents without the buffers.

Even games shouldn’t crash if the user changes screen depths. I suggest pausing the game and opening a moveable error dialog explaining the situation.

Minimizing the amount of RAM required for update events is always a good idea. You can spool picture resources instead of loading them completely into RAM. Unfortunately, there’s no simple “DrawSpooledPictureResource” call, so you’ll have to write the spooling code yourself.

“This model’s so fast we had to put speedbumps on the hard drive!”

Use GWorlds and not offscreen CGrafPorts.

In order to draw properly offscreen, you should use either GWorlds or CGrafPort/GDevice combinations. Creating only a CGrafPort is not enough, because QuickDraw will use the current GDevice’s inverse table when drawing to the offscreen buffer. On my machine, the default GDevice is a 1-bit device, so its inverse table is pretty useless (it actually is filled with 0x01). If your graphics appear in a light yellow color on secondary screens, this is likely the cause.

Window PixMaps

Some sample code I recently looked at chose the depth of its offscreen buffers by looking at the portPixMap field within a CWindowRecord. This PixMap always represents the main device, even when a window is on another screen. Color QuickDraw “notices” this when drawing and special cases its drawing calls to work across multiple devices.

To find the desired depth and color table for an offscreen copy of a window’s contents, use a routine like:

 
/* 4 */
short FindWindowDepth( WindowPtr myWindow )
{
 Rect   r;
 GDHandle theDevice;
 short  theDepth;
 GrafPtroldPort;

 if ( !gHasColorQuickDraw )
 return( 1 );    // 1-bit if no color quickdraw

 GetPort( &oldPort );// save old port
 SetPort( myWindow );
 
 // get the window’s content rect in global coords
 r = myWindow->portRect;  
 LocalToGlobal( (Point*) &r );
 LocalToGlobal( 1 + (Point*) &r );

 // find the deepest device intersecting the window
 theDevice = GetMaxDevice( &r );
 theDepth = theDevice ? (**(**theDevice).gdPMap).pixelSize : 1;

 // color table is at: (**(**theDevice).gdPMap).pmTable

 SetPort( oldPort ); // restore port
 return( theDepth );
}

Hiding the menu bar

Most programs shouldn’t hide the menu bar, but it’s a necessary evil for games, slide shows, and multimedia demos. Be sure to hide the menu bar only if your presentation is running on the main device. Be sure to save/restore the menu bar area on switch events because it will be changed while you are in the background. Many programs incorrectly assume that users won’t be able to “switch out” of their applications because they create windows the same size as the screen. On multi-monitor systems, switching out is as easy as clicking on the desktop on the second monitor. (If you really must prevent switching out, your best bet is to never call GetNextEvent or WaitNextEvent).

Summary

If you follow these suggestions, your programs should be multi-monitor friendly. While it may not be trivial to support multiple monitors properly, annoying users is the only alternative. Remember that most PowerMacs have built-in support for 2 monitors, so this issue is more important now than ever.

Besides, this might just be the way to convince your boss to buy you a second screen.

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Google Earth 7.1.7.2602 - View and contr...
Google Earth gives you a wealth of imagery and geographic information. Explore destinations like Maui and Paris, or browse content from Wikipedia, National Geographic, and more. Google Earth combines... Read more
ClamXav 2.10 - Virus checker based on Cl...
ClamXav is a popular virus checker for OS X. I have been working on ClamXav for more than 10 years now, and over those years, I have invested a huge amount of my own time and energy into bringing... Read more
Tweetbot 2.4.4 - Popular Twitter client.
Tweetbot is a full-featured OS X Twitter client with a lot of personality. Whether it's the meticulously-crafted interface, sounds and animation, or features like multiple timelines and column views... Read more
Sierra Cache Cleaner 11.0.1 - Clear cach...
Sierra Cache Cleaner is an award-winning general purpose tool for macOS X. SCC makes system maintenance simple with an easy point-and-click interface to many macOS X functions. Novice and expert... Read more
Things 2.8.8 - Elegant personal task man...
Things is a task management solution that helps to organize your tasks in an elegant and intuitive way. Things combines powerful features with simplicity through the use of tags and its intelligent... Read more
Remotix 4.1 - Access all your computers...
Remotix is a fast and powerful application to easily access multiple Macs (and PCs) from your own Mac. Features Complete Apple Screen Sharing support - including Mac OS X login, clipboard... Read more
Airfoil 5.1.2 - Send audio from any app...
Airfoil allows you to send any audio to AirPort Express units, Apple TVs, and even other Macs and PCs, all in sync! It's your audio - everywhere. With Airfoil you can take audio from any... Read more
Firefox 49.0.1 - Fast, safe Web browser.
Firefox offers a fast, safe Web browsing experience. Browse quickly, securely, and effortlessly. With its industry-leading features, Firefox is the choice of Web development professionals and casual... Read more
Default Folder X 5.0.7 - Enhances Open a...
Default Folder X attaches a toolbar to the right side of the Open and Save dialogs in any OS X-native application. The toolbar gives you fast access to various folders and commands. You just click on... Read more
Safari Technology Preview 10.1 - The new...
Safari Technology Preview contains the most recent additions and improvements to WebKit and the latest advances in Safari web technologies. And once installed, you will receive notifications of... Read more

3 apps to boost your focus
As someone who works from home, my workspace is a minefield of distraction. Cats, tasty snacks, the wind blowing past my window, that cleaning that I suddenly can’t put off any longer. If I let distraction takes its course, I find that soon half... | Read more »
4 games like Burly Men at Sea to inspire...
Burly Men at Sea is out today and it looks a treat. It tells the tale of three Scandinavian fishermen who leave the humdrum of their daily lives to go exploring. It’s a beautiful folksy story that unfurls as you interact with the environment... | Read more »
3 reasons you need to play Kingdom: New...
Developed by a tag team of indie developers - Thomas "Noio" van den Berg and Marco "Licorice" Bancale - Kingdom is a vibrant medieval fantasy adventure that casts players as a king or queen who must expand their empire by exploring the vasts lands... | Read more »
JoyCity have launched a brand new King o...
Great news for all of you Game of Dice fans out there - JoyCity have just released a brand new limited edition pack with a really cool twist. The premise of Game of Dice is fairly straightforward, asking you to roll dice to navigate your way around... | Read more »
Burly Men at Sea (Games)
Burly Men at Sea 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $4.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Burly Men at Sea is a folktale about a trio of large, bearded fishermen who step away from the ordinary to seek adventure. | Read more »
3 tips for catching the gnarliest waves...
Like a wave breaking on the shore, Tidal Rider swept its way onto the App Store charts this week settling firmly in the top 10. It’s a one-touch high score-chaser in which you pull surfing stunts while dodging seagulls and collecting coins. The... | Read more »
The beginner's guide to destroying...
Age of Heroes: Conquest is 5th Planet Games’ all new turn-based multiplayer RPG, full of fantasy exploration, guild building, and treasure hunting. It’s pretty user-friendly as far as these games go, but when you really get down to it, you’ll find... | Read more »
Infinite Tanks (Games)
Infinite Tanks 1.0.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $4.99, Version: 1.0.0 (iTunes) Description: | Read more »
Agatha Christie - The ABC Murders (FULL)...
Agatha Christie - The ABC Murders (FULL) 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $6.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Agatha Christie: The ABC Murders Your weapon is your knowledge. Your wits will be put to the ultimate... | Read more »
HeadlessD (Games)
HeadlessD 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: HeadlessD is hand-painted dungeon crawler with intuitive touch controls and NO in-app purchases. | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

Apple refurbished 2015 13-inch MacBook Airs a...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 2015 13″ MacBook Airs available starting at $759. An Apple one-year warranty is included with each MacBook, and shipping is free: - 2015 13″ 1.6GHz/4GB/128GB MacBook... Read more
MacBook Airs on sale for up to $100 off MSRP
B&H Photo has 13″ and 11″ MacBook Airs on sale for up to $100 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY sales tax only: - 11″ 1.6GHz/128GB MacBook Air: $799 $100 MSRP - 11″ 1.6GHz/256GB... Read more
Apple refurbished 12-inch 128GB iPad Pros ava...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 12″ Apple iPad Pros available for up to $160 off the cost of new iPads. An Apple one-year warranty is included with each model, and shipping is free: - 32GB 12″ iPad... Read more
Phone2Action Unveils New Voter Turnout Techno...
Phone2Action, a leading digital advocacy platform, today launched its Tech to Vote Civic Action Center digital advocacy and communications platform on National Voter Registration Day September 27.... Read more
Apple & Deloitte Team Up to Help Business...
Apple and international professional services firm Deloitte have announced a partnership to help companies quickly and easily transform their workflow dynamics by maximizing the power, ease-of-use,... Read more
Chop Commute – See Traffic and Drive Times on...
Shrewsbury, Massachusetts based Indie developer, InchWest has released Chop Commute 1.61, a Mac app that takes the guesswork out of daily commute by showing real-time traffic and drive times right on... Read more
12-inch 32GB WiFi iPad Pros on sale for $50 o...
B&H Photo has 12″ 32GB WiFi Apple iPad Pros on sale for $50 off MSRP, each including free shipping. B&H charges sales tax in NY only: - 12″ Space Gray 32GB WiFi iPad Pro: $749 $50 off MSRP -... Read more
Recent price drops on refurbished iPad minis...
Apple recently dropped prices on several Certified Refurbished iPad mini 4s and 2s as well as iPad Air 2s. An Apple one-year warranty is included with each model, and shipping is free: - 16GB iPad... Read more
Apple refurbished Mac minis available startin...
Apple has Certified Refurbished Mac minis available starting at $419. Apple’s one-year warranty is included with each mini, and shipping is free: - 1.4GHz Mac mini: $419 $80 off MSRP - 2.6GHz Mac... Read more
13-inch 2.5GHz MacBook Pro available for $928...
Overstock has the 13″ 2.5GHz MacBook Pro available for $927.99 including free shipping. Their price is $171 off MSRP. Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
Restaurant Manager (Neighborhood Captain) - A...
…in every aspect of daily operation. WHY YOU'LL LIKE IT: You'll be the Big Apple . You'll solve problems. You'll get to show your ability to handle the stress and Read more
*Apple* Wireless Lead - T-ROC - The Retail O...
…wealth of knowledge in wireless sales and activations to the Beautiful and NEW APPLE Experience store within MACYS.. THIS role, APPLE Wireless Lead, isbrandnewas Read more
Lead *Apple* Advocate - T-ROC - The Retail...
…Company, is proud of its unprecedented relationship with our partner and client, APPLE ,in bringing amazing" APPLE ADVOCATES"to "non" Apple store locations. Read more
*Apple* Advocate - T-ROC - The Retail Outsou...
…Company, is proud of its unprecedented relationship with our partner and client, APPLE ,in bringing amazing" APPLE ADVOCATES"to "non" Apple store locations. Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.