TweetFollow Us on Twitter




[IMAGE 020-023_Designing_for_PP1.GIF]

The Power Macintosh offers surprises both for users and for developers. Users notice that it's a fully compatible Macintosh and that native applications run blazingly fast. Developers, upon learning how the Power Macintosh differs from a 680x0-based Macintosh, discover that it's still basically a Macintosh. But the Power Macintosh can offer a much richer experience than was possible with previous computers if developers break free of their old assumptions and harness the power of the machine to make software not just faster, but easier and more enjoyable to use.

The Graphing Calculator desk accessory that ships with the Power Macintosh was designed to take advantage of the machine's power to make some challenging mathematical tasks easily accessible -- in particular, algebraic manipulation and 2-D and 3-D graphing. In this column we'll share some lessons we learned when writing the Graphing Calculator. We'll speak about software design rather than programming details because we frequently discovered that our intuition and the standard approaches to many aspects of the application design were no longer appropriate.

In general, we learned that it's time to break free of the idioms developed for the machines of 1984 and begin designing a new generation of software. We're not in Kansas anymore . The lowest common denominator of hardware -- where developers usually aim in order to maintain consistency across all Macintosh models -- has changed. The target has typically been an 8 MHz 68000 processor or, for color applications, perhaps a machine twice as fast. The lowest common denominator for Apple's RISC-based line of machines is a 60 MHz PowerPC 601 processor. This change represents an enormous jump: on some floating-point operations, for example, the Power Macintosh is as much as 20,000 times faster.

In our tests, calculations using the PowerPC processor's single-precision floating-point multiply-add instruction were 20,000 times faster. This means that if we had started a lengthy floating-point calculation in 1984 at the release of the Macintosh, and that calculation were still being worked on by the computer, it would take a Power Macintosh starting now just four hours to catch up.*

Even for developers targeting 680x0-based machines, a new approach to software design can dramatically improve users' experiences. The goal is to maximize use of whatever processing power is available in the design of the user interface.

Here's a summary of the tips we'd like to pass on; we'll look at each one in more detail below.

  1. Tackle expensive computations when they can improve the interface.
  2. Eliminate dialogs and command lines in favor of direct manipulation.
  3. Drop old assumptions and idioms. Use the processing power to explore new interfaces.
  4. Provide a starting point for exploration.
  5. Avoid programming cleverness. Instead, assume a good compiler and write readable code.
  6. Invest development time in user-centered design.
  7. Learn the new rules for performance.
  8. Design tiered functionality: take advantage of whatever hardware you're running on.
  9. Test on real users.


1. Tackle expensive computations when they can improve the interface.

We took a fresh look at how to implement the visual feedback for dragging, scrolling, and zooming. Traditionally, the Macintosh has represented these with XOR animation, which gives the impression of the action without really recalculating the window contents. This is how we first implemented them in the Graphing Calculator as well; redrawing an algebraic equation or 2-D curve, not to mention a 3-D rendered surface, is computationally expensive.

But to try to stress the processor, we tested the direct approach, and we found that the PowerPC processor could easily keep up. So now in the Calculator, when the user drags the axes, not only is the image dragged live but the exposed parts of the function are calculated and drawn as the mouse is moved. When the zoom buttons are clicked, the entire function is recomputed and redrawn several times to animate the zoom. In this way, applications can take advantage of the PowerPC processor to dramatically improve the quality of interaction in ways that are not possible on slower machines.

2. Eliminate dialogs and command lines in favor of direct manipulation.

Since there's processing power to burn in the PowerPC 601, we simplified the user interface by replacing many dialogs with direct manipulation. The Graphing Calculator doesn't have the dialogs typical of graphing programs for specifying the range and precision of a graph (xmin, xmax, ymin, ymax, number of points, and so on). Instead, the user controls the view of a graph through direct manipulation.

Today's computers are fast enough to allow you to implement direct interaction for complex tasks. Certain time constants play crucial roles in human factors analysis. Recognizing these thresholds can help create a smoother interface. If a task like interacting with an equation takes under one-tenth of a second, users won't be bothered by the delay; if it takes under one-fourth of a second, it's fast enough not to be annoying. Longer delays, however, make users realize that they're waiting. With fast response times, users can ignore the computer and have fun exploring the subject at hand.

By emphasizing direct manipulation, we reduced even algebraic simplification, a task that might seem to require a command-line interface, to the paradigm of MacDraw. Math is traditionally intimidating, and math programs even more so, but we wanted to make mathematics fun. This was really a user-interface challenge, and it required rethinking many fundamental assumptions. Usability was our primary design goal; functionality was second. We were pleased to discover that with direct manipulation, we could simplify the interface without giving up powerful functionality.

Since direct manipulation doesn't require users to learn any new commands or concepts, the manipulations immediately become part of a user's arsenal of tools. A powerful example of this is the drag algebra facility, which strikes many people as the most intriguing feature of the Calculator. The user can select a term of an equation and drag it elsewhere in the equation, just like dragging an object in a drawing program. The Calculator performs the algebraic manipulations necessary to keep the equation consistent. This feature immediately boosts users into a realm where they can confidently and easily manipulate an equation. Just as simple calculators did with multiplication and division, it allows users who understand the essential concepts to immediately move on to more interesting problems.

3. Drop old assumptions and idioms. Use the processing power to explore new interfaces.

On a Power Macintosh, you can handle hundreds or thousands of times more information than before interactively. This might allow rendered 3-D objects to become user-interface components, for example. While the Graphing Calculator flashes its buttons for the usual 8 ticks to indicate that they've been clicked, in that time it could compute and render a 3-D surface with 1000 polygons. Imagine what controls might look like if they really taxed the processing power of the machine.

Because functions are rendered so quickly on a Power Macintosh, we made 3-D surfaces spin by default. This gives users more information about the functions right away. Furthermore, there are no menus or dialogs to control the view of surfaces; just as it does for 2-D graphs, the Calculator lets users change the 3-D view by grabbing the surface with the mouse.

4. Provide a starting point for exploration.

Applications should avoid batch setup operations, such as requiring users to set a lot of dialog options before performing an operation. Instead, provide a starting point for exploration, with reasonable defaults for whatever's necessary to get users to that point.

Perhaps the most unusual aspect of the Graphing Calculator is what it doesn't ask of users. They don't have to set up any graphing options before viewing a curve or a surface; there are no preliminary dialogs or required commands for users to do this. For any equation that can be graphed, the user simply clicks a Graph button to draw it.

We've all had the bewildering experience of trying to use a program only to discover that we don't even know how to begin. One of the toughest problems is to create an interface that makes functionality available and enjoyable for first-time users. But clearly this is where the design effort offers the greatest payoff.

5. Avoid programming cleverness. Instead, assume a good compiler and write readable code.

Cycle-counting and compiler-specific optimizations are favorite pastimes of hackers, and sometimes they're important. But we could never have completed the Graphing Calculator in under six months had we worried about optimizing each routine. Rather, we dealt with speed problems only when they were perceptible to users.

We made no attempt to look at performance bottlenecks or at the compiled code of the Calculator until after running execution profiles. We were surprised where the time was being spent. Most of the time that the Calculator is compute-bound it's either in the math libraries or in QuickDraw. So little time is spent in our code that even compiling it unoptimized didn't slow it down perceptibly. Improving our code's performance meant calling the math libraries less often.

Programmers are often tempted to spend time saving a few bytes or cycles or to fine-tune an algorithm. If the change isn't visible to users, however, the benefits may not extend beyond the programmer's satisfaction. When most of the code in an application is straightforward and readable, maintenance and improvements are easier to make. Those are changes that userswill notice.

To maximize drawing speed without sacrificing compatibility, the Calculator renders its graphs offscreen in GWorlds and uses CopyBits to transfer them to the screen. See "Drawing in GWorlds for Speed and Versatility" in develop Issue 10 for a discussion of this technique.*

6. Invest development time in user-centered design.

Complex algorithms should be used not for their own sake but to improve the user experience. For example, as the user drags the pane divider in the Calculator window, the application redraws most of the window (offscreen in a GWorld) rather than recalculating exposed areas. The Power Macintosh is fast enough that it wasn't worth spending coding and debugging time to save on runtime calculation, because the savings wouldn't be perceived by the user.

In contrast, when users click on a 2-D curve to read an (x,y) coordinate, some quite sophisticated processing happens. As the user moves the mouse, a numeric root-finding algorithm looks for interesting points such as maxima, minima, and zero-crossings to solve equations numerically. Furthermore, because numerical methods to find maxima and minima are imprecise, we also compute symbolic derivatives of the functions and then look for where the derivative is 0, which locates maxima and minima much more accurately. All this work goes completely unnoticed by the user. But the user does notice the result: simply clicking on the curve tells with great precision what's interesting at that point.

7. Learn the new rules for performance.

You may discover that thereare places where performance tuning would be worthwhile in your application. The rules for performance have changed, and knowing the new rules is essential. Some programming techniques that traditionally improve performance can be counterproductive. In particular, on PowerPC-based systems, avoiding instruction cache misses is far more important than saving instructions.

Getting good performance out of a fast machine doesn't always come without effort. To be able to exploit modern hardware to improve an application, you must have some understanding of the hardware and what allows it to be fast. It's extremely important to understand the processor and memory architecture of your target platform.

The memory system in the Power Macintosh is much faster than the memory system of other Macintosh models. The 64-bit bus allows for substantially improved data transfer. However, the processor is much, much faster than the memory system. An uncached memory reference may take 20 times as long as a cached memory reference. Performance will actually be slowed down dramatically by a speedoptimization that saves floating-point multiply instructions (expensive on some processors, but not on the PowerPC) at the expense of extra memory usage that forces instructions or data out of the cache.

Understanding patterns of memory reference is very important in analyzing algorithms for performance. Stepping through an array across cache lines can quickly flush all lines out of the cache. (Cache lines are discussed in the Balance of Power column in this issue.) This can cripple attempts to walk the data structures typically maintained by interface-intensive applications. The PowerPC 601 has an eight-way set associative cache, which is fairly resilient to degradation from flushing of cache lines. However, the 603 processor has just a two-way set associative cache. Any processor-intensive calculations must avoid cache thrashing if they are to avoid degrading below an acceptable level of user responsiveness.

For additional architecture insights and tuning strategies, see the Balance of Power column in develop Issue 18 and in this issue.*

Because no two platforms will run at the same speed, it's important to design software to work well on a variety of machines. In principle, this means that the same application could run on any Macintosh, while being far more powerful -- and more pleasant to use -- on a Power Macintosh.

8. Design tiered functionality: take advantage of whatever hardware you're running on.

Just as it's frustrating for users of entry-level machines to be unable to run software, it's equally frustrating for users of fast, high-end hardware with plenty of memory to have features execute unnecessarily slowly, or to be constrained by programs that expect and only take advantage of minimal resources.

The Graphing Calculator does assume a Power Macintosh as its base platform; otherwise its expectations are modest. However, its appetite is unbounded. It does all drawing using offscreen buffers in temporary memory when adequate RAM is available, but will scale back to onscreen, QuickDraw-based rendering when temporary memory is limited. System 7 makes this easy with purgeable GWorlds; once LockPixels fails, the Calculator knows that it must work within tighter constraints. Later, when it can reallocate the offscreen buffer, it does so and resumes the fast, smooth graphing effects. When memory is abundant, the Calculator uses many temporary GWorlds to buffer frames of 2-D inequality graphs calculated for varying values ofn , such as the animation of cosn x < 0.

The Graphing Calculator does all 2-D graph computation in 15-tick chunks. For simple curves, this typically renders the entire curve at once. But 2-D inequalities are drawn piece by piece. Once Power Macintosh computers are fast enough that an entire, complex inequality graph can be drawn in a single 15-tick time slice, users will be able to explore inequalities as fluidly as they can now play with simple functions.

To take advantage of faster machines, always base computational units on real time rather than on more arbitrary measures. If the Calculator had recomputed a fixed number of points and then called WaitNextEvent, too much time would have been yielded to other processes, even on graphs simple enough to be recomputed and drawn all at once. Instead, the Calculator calls TickCount and lets that dictate when it needs to yield time. This approach allows for a smooth user interface and cooperative execution regardless of the processor's speed.

Designing tiered functionality means abandoning assumptions about what is and is not practical on the target hardware. For addressing resources, such as available hardware and memory, or when execution can be threaded or time-sliced, the options are usually clear. For matters of raw speed, the proper approach may not be so obvious. It may come down to measuring the execution speed of a particular procedure at run time and basing a decision on that. For example, an animation effect might be suitable if it takes under 8 ticks, or a routine that bypasses QuickDraw for drawing in a GWorld may be worthwhile if it really is faster than its QuickDraw alternative.

For an example of timing graphics speed, see the article "Exploiting Graphics Speed on the Power Macintosh" in develop Issue 18.*

9. Test on real users.

The Graphing Calculator reflects our vision of a new kind of calculator. But user testing was essential for showing us the holes in our vision. For example, elements that were directly manipulable in our eyes were overlooked by users. So we redesigned them to make their functions clearer, and then added a demo mode to point out important controls explicitly.

In tests, the users who looked at the help pages invariably turned first to the page at the end offering "tips." This surprised us, but also made clear where to put the most important information for using the Calculator.

Toward the end of the development of the Graphing Calculator, as the final user tests were being conducted, we saw students using the Calculator effectively within minutes, without instruction. Watching a high school student say "Wow!" as an equation came to life on the screen was probably the most satisfying moment for us as programmers. It was also the one that offered us the greatest hope about the future of personal computing. The Power Macintosh offers us the chance to reach more people while making the experience more enjoyable and easier for users than ever possible on earlier generations of computers. As developers, we have a new world to explore.

GREG ROBBINS began writing educational software on the Apple II as a high school student. Since then, he's picked up computer engineering degrees from U.C. San Diego and the University of Pennsylvania, bagged wild boar in Fiji, and evaded sharks off Australia. When he's not consulting on Macintosh development, Greg gets way off the beaten track as a member of the Bay Area Mountain Rescue Unit. *

RON AVITZUR considered working on the Graphing Calculator to be an exercise in single-minded obsessive behavior -- good training for graduate school in physics. Ron has been writing educational math software since the dawn of the Macintosh. You haven't really seen the Graphing Calculator until Ron has shown it to you; in fact, Stewart Alsop's PC Letter names Ron one of the first Demo Gods. *

Thanks to Arnaud Gourdol, Mike Neil, Don Norman, and Alex Rosenberg for reviewing this column. *


Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

TextSoap 8.4.1 - Automate tedious text d...
TextSoap can automatically remove unwanted characters, fix up messed up carriage returns, and do pretty much anything else that we can think of to text. Save time and effort. Be more productive. Stop... Read more
TextSoap 8.4.1 - Automate tedious text d...
TextSoap can automatically remove unwanted characters, fix up messed up carriage returns, and do pretty much anything else that we can think of to text. Save time and effort. Be more productive. Stop... Read more
Backblaze - Online backup servi...
Backblaze is an online backup service designed from the ground-up for the Mac. With unlimited storage available for $5 per month, as well as a free 15-day trial, peace of mind is within reach with... Read more
Numi 3.15 - Menu-bar calculator supports...
Numi is a calculator that magically combines calculations with text, and allows you to freely share your computations. Numi combines text editor and calculator Support plain English. For example, '5... Read more
EtreCheck 3.3.3 - For troubleshooting yo...
EtreCheck is an app that displays the important details of your system configuration and allow you to copy that information to the Clipboard. It is meant to be used with Apple Support Communities to... Read more
BusyContacts 1.1.8 - Fast, efficient con...
BusyContacts is a contact manager for OS X that makes creating, finding, and managing contacts faster and more efficient. It brings to contact management the same power, flexibility, and sharing... Read more
TunnelBear 3.0.14 - Subscription-based p...
TunnelBear is a subscription-based virtual private network (VPN) service and companion app, enabling you to browse the internet privately and securely. Features Browse privately - Secure your data... Read more
Apple Final Cut Pro X 10.3.4 - Professio...
Apple Final Cut Pro X is a professional video editing solution.Completely redesigned from the ground up, Final Cut Pro adds extraordinary speed, quality, and flexibility to every part of the post-... Read more
Hopper Disassembler 4.2.1- - Binary disa...
Hopper Disassembler is a binary disassembler, decompiler, and debugger for 32-bit and 64-bit executables. It will let you disassemble any binary you want, and provide you all the information about... Read more
Slack 2.6.2 - Collaborative communicatio...
Slack is a collaborative communication app that simplifies real-time messaging, archiving, and search for modern working teams. Version 2.6.2: Fixed Inexplicably, context menus and spell-check... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

The best new games we played this week
We were quite busy this week. A bunch of big mobile games launched over the past few days, alongside a few teeny surprises. There're lots of quality games to load your phone with. We've gone and picked out five of our favorites for the week. [... | Read more »
Magikarp Jump beginner's guide
Magikarp Jump is a mystifying little game. Part Tamagotchi, part idle clicker, there's not a whole lot of video game there, per se, but for some reason we can't help coming back to it again and again. Your goal is to train up a little Magikarp to... | Read more »
Goat Simulator PAYDAY (Games)
Goat Simulator PAYDAY 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $4.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: ** IMPORTANT - SUPPORTED DEVICES **iPhone 4S, iPad 2, iPod Touch 5 or better Goat Simulator: Payday is the most... | Read more »
GRID Autosport delayed until autumn
Sorry mobile racing fans -- GRID Autosport has been delayed a few months. The game is now expected to launch this fall on iOS. Feral Interactive announced that they wanted more time to work on the game's UI and overall performance before launching... | Read more »
Zombie Gunship Survival Beginner's...
The much anticipated Zombie Gunship Survival is here. In this latest entry in the Zombie Gunship franchise, you're tasked with supporting ground troops and protecting your base from the zombie horde. There's a lot of rich base building fun, and... | Read more »
Mordheim: Warband Skirmish (Games)
Mordheim: Warband Skirmish 1.2.2 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $3.99, Version: 1.2.2 (iTunes) Description: Explore the ruins of the City of Mordheim, clash with other scavenging warbands and collect Wyrdstone -... | Read more »
Mordheim: Warband Skirmish brings tablet...
Legendary Games has just launched Mordheim: Warband Skirmish, a new turn-based action game for iOS and Android. | Read more »
Magikarp Jump splashes onto Android worl...
If you're tired ofPokémon GObut still want something to satisfy your mobilePokémon fix,Magikarp Jumpmay just do the trick. It's out now on Android devices the world over. While it looks like a simple arcade jumper, there's quite a bit more to it... | Read more »
Purrfectly charming open-world RPG Cat Q...
Cat Quest, an expansive open-world RPG from former Koei-Tecmo developers, got a new gameplay trailer today. The video showcases the combat and exploration features of this feline-themed RPG. Cat puns abound as you travel across a large map in a... | Read more »
Jaipur: A Card Game of Duels (Games)
Jaipur: A Card Game of Duels 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $1.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: ** WARNING: iPad 2, iPad Mini 1 & iPhone 4S are NOT compatible. ** *** Special Launch Price for a limited... | Read more »

Price Scanner via

Memorial Day savings: 13-inch Touch Bar MacBo...
B&H Photo has the 2016 Apple 13″ Touch Bar MacBook Pros in stock today and on sale for up to $150 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY & NJ sales tax only: - 13″ 2.9GHz/512GB... Read more
Apple refurbished 13-inch MacBook Airs availa...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 2016 13″ MacBook Airs available starting at $849. An Apple one-year warranty is included with each MacBook, and shipping is free: - 13″ 1.6GHz/8GB/128GB MacBook Air: $... Read more
Apple restocks refurbished 11-inch MacBook Ai...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 11″ MacBook Airs (the latest models recently discontinued by Apple), available for up to $170 off original MSRP. An Apple one-year warranty is included with each... Read more
12-inch 1.2GHz Retina MacBooks on sale for up...
B&H has 12″ 1.2GHz Retina MacBooks on sale for up to $150 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY & NJ sales tax only: - 12″ 1.2GHz Space Gray Retina MacBook: $1449.99 $150 off... Read more
15-inch 2.7GHz Silver Touch Bar MacBook Pro o...
MacMall has the 15-inch 2.7GHz Silver Touch Bar MacBook Pro (MLW82LL/A) on sale for $2569 as part of their Memorial Day sale. Shipping is free. Their price is $230 off MSRP. Read more
Free Tread Wisely Mobile App Endorsed By Fath...
Just in time for the summer driving season, Cooper Tire & Rubber Company has announced the launch of a new Tread Wisely mobile app. Designed to promote tire and vehicle safety among teens and... Read more
Commercial Notebooks And Detachable Tablets W...
Worldwide shipments of personal computing devices (PCDs), comprised of traditional PCs (a combination of desktop, notebook, and workstations) and tablets (slates and detachables), are forecast to... Read more
Best value this Memorial Day weekend: Touch B...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 2016 15″ and 13″ MacBook Pros available for $230 to $420 off original MSRP. An Apple one-year warranty is included with each model, and shipping is free: - 15″ 2.6GHz... Read more
13-inch MacBook Airs on sale for up to $130 o... has 13″ MacBook Airs on sale for up to $130 off MSRP including free shipping: - 13″ 1.6GHz/128GB MacBook Air (sku MMGF2LL/A): $869.99 $130 off MSRP - 13″ 1.6GHz/256GB MacBook Air (sku... Read more
2.8GHz Mac mini available for $973 with free...
Adorama has the 2.8GHz Mac mini available for $973, $16 off MSRP, including a free copy of Apple’s 3-Year AppleCare Protection Plan. Shipping is free, and Adorama charges sales tax in NY & NJ... Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* Media Products - Commerce Engineerin...
Apple Media Products - Commerce Engineering Manager Job Number: 57037480 Santa Clara Valley, California, United States Posted: Apr. 18, 2017 Weekly Hours: 40.00 Job Read more
Best Buy *Apple* Computing Master - Best Bu...
**509643BR** **Job Title:** Best Buy Apple Computing Master **Location Number:** 001482- Apple Valley-Store **Job Description:** **What does a Best Buy Apple Read more
*Apple* Media Products - Commerce Engineerin...
Apple Media Products - Commerce Engineering Manager Job Number: 57037480 Santa Clara Valley, California, United States Posted: Apr. 18, 2017 Weekly Hours: 40.00 Job Read more
*Apple* Mac and Mobility Engineer - Infogrou...
Title: Apple Mac and Mobility Engineer Location: Portland, OR Area Type: 12 month contract Job: 17412 Here's a chance to take your skills to the limit, learn new Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions, White P...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.