TweetFollow Us on Twitter

File-Based Dataflow

Volume Number: 19 (2003)
Issue Number: 3
Column Tag: Mac OS X

File-Based Dataflow

building robust systems without explicit file locking

by Rich Morin

Last month, I discussed "File Change Watcher", a Perl daemon that wakes up periodically, checks for file-system changes, copies files, and gathers metadata. To save space, I ignored a critical issue: how can another process know that a metadata file is "ready" to be read?

Race Conditions

This question comes up in the design of any system where one process is writing a file and another is accessing it. In this type of "race condition", the reading process can overtake the writing process, arriving prematurely at the end of the data (and ignoring any data the other process may write thereafter).

Alternatively, if two processes try to write the same file at the same time, assorted damage can ensue. Depending on the circumstances, changes might get lost, output could get intermingled, etc.

One way to deal with the problem is to use a "lock file". By common agreement, if the lock file is in place, the file it "locks" isn't available for access. An inquiring process can test for this by trying to create the lock file. If the process fails, it just waits for a while before trying again.

The reason that this test works is that the kernel won't let two processes open the same file with exclusive access (O_EXCL). So, the first attempt succeeds and all others fail (until the first process closes the file). The technique works quite well, as long as everyone plays nicely; the BSD side of OSX contains a number of lock files (e.g., /var/spool/lock).

In the general case, lock files (or some equivalent technique) are necessary. If, for instance, two users want to edit a file, you really don't want them doing it at the same time. So, some Unix editors (e.g., the BSD version of vi) implement file locking.

Unfortunately, lock files add complexity and room for error. All of the processes have to honor the lock files; what if an existing program doesn't want to play? Also, if the system crashes, the lock file has to be explicitly removed when things start up again. And, for all of this pain, they only solve one part (simultaneous access) of the file-based dataflow problem set.

Atomic Actions

Fortunately, there are a number of alternatives to lock files. Most of them are based on some kind of "atomic action"; that is, something that can only be done completely or not at all. BSD provides several atomic actions as system calls, including chmod(2), chown(2), link(2), open(2), and rename(2).

These same facilities are available from Perl, but its chmod and chown are only atomic for single file nodes. Corresponding shell commands are available, albeit with some caveats:

  • chgrp(1), chmod(1), chown(1) of a single file system node

  • link(1), but only for hard links

  • mv(1), to another name on the same file system

So, although you can't assume that a process will finish writing before some other process starts to read the output file, you can safely rename(2) an existing file (or mv(1) it to another name on the same file system) without worrying about race conditions.

Because any hard link to a file is simply a directory entry that points to a common inode(5), both the data and file system metadata are shared among a set of hard links. This lets a single atomic action (e.g., chmod) change the status of any number of links.

Finally, Cocoa's Application Kit Framework's NSFileWrapper class includes methods such as writeToFile:atomically:updateFilenames:. In short, a wealth of solutions is at hand.

Emitters and Consumers

The system I'm building is based on a data-flow model, similar to Unix pipelines, but it uses files instead of pipes. The method is far from new; mail transfer agents and print spoolers use variations of it in OSX. I am simply generalizing the idea into a framework for creating sets of file- and time-based tasks.

By specifying that only one program will ever write to a file, I can eliminate the issue of simultaneous writing. This means that I only need to prevent processes from opening or removing files prematurely and make sure that every file gets processed to completion.

The rules below allow the safe (i.e., no race conditions) use of files by any number of "emitters" and "consumers", without the need for lock files.

  • Files are created and written by emitters, read and deleted by consumers. No modification of files is allowed, including appending or read/write usage.

  • Files are created under temporary names (on the destination file system), then "published" (e.g., renamed) for use by consumers.

  • A file can only be used by one consumer, which removes it just before exiting.

    Note: This restriction applies only to consumers. Other programs (e.g., more) may read published files at any time. Also, the consumer is not required to read the file, just remove it.

  • If an emitter is creating files for multiple consumers, a separate link must be created for each consumer. All of the links must then be published in a single, atomic operation. One method uses a common directory:

    • Create a temporary directory.

    • For each file with N consumers, make N-1 links in the directory.

    • Rename the temporary file(s) into the directory, as the Nth file link(s).

    • Rename the temporary directory, publishing all of the links.

      Another method, which can only "protect" a single output file, has the advantage that the output links do not have to be in the same directory:

    • Turn off read access (using chmod) on the temporary file.

    • For a file with N consumers, make N-1 links.

    • Rename the temporary file as the Nth link.

    • Make any (and thereby, every) link readable.

Although these rules might complicate the life of programmers, the resulting programs aren't any more complicated. In fact, they tend to be quite simple: discover an input file, process it (writing any output to temporary files); when you're done, publish (e.g., rename) the output files and remove the input file.

Better yet, the file-discovery and -management details can be handed off to a scheduling daemon, allowing most of the "tasks" (working code) to be written as "filters": read from standard input; write to standard output.

A Data Collection System

Let's apply this to a data collection system and see how it plays out. A ps(1)-monitoring task is supposed to run once a minute, writing a report. Another task reads the report, writing a YAML (www.yaml.org) version. Other tasks produce hourly and daily summaries.

This is a fairly complex set of tasks, but it's only a small fraction of the workload for a full-scale operating system monitor. So, the amount of specification for each task should be as simple as possible. Here's a first cut at a configuration file:

# Every minute, collect raw ps(1) data.
{ ps_raw, type: cron, min: every,
  out: 'ps/raw/$time'
}
# Process the raw ps(1) data.
# Create two output links.
{ ps_rare, type: file, patt: 'ps/raw/*',
  out: ['ps/rare/1.$time',
        'ps/rare/2.$time' ]
}
# Every hour, create a summary.
{ ps_hour, type: cron, hour: every,
  out: 'ps/hour/$time'
}
# Every day, create a summary.
{ ps_day, type: cron, day: every,
  out: 'ps/day/$time'
}

This is fairly concise, but there's a lot of repetition. We could "boil it down" by taking advantage of the fact that it describes a tree of processes:

{ ps_raw, type: cron, min: every,
  out: 'ps/raw/$time',
  { ps_rare, type: file, patt: 'ps/raw/*',
    out: ['ps/rare/1.$time',
          'ps/rare/2.$time' ]
    { ps_hour, type: cron, hour: every,
      out: 'ps/hour/$time'
    },
    { ps_day, type: cron, day: every,
      out: 'ps/day/$time'
} } }

But that only kills off two lines (excluding comments), so it's not a huge win. Also, I'm not convinced that it's as easy to read, modify, etc. If we are willing to let the scheduling infrastructure generate file names for us, however, we can get away with "idioms" like:

{ ps_raw,      type: cron, min:  every,
  { ps_rare,   type: file,
    { ps_hour, type: cron, hour: every },
    { ps_day,  type: cron, day:  every }
} }

That brings the overhead back under control. And, if we need to access a file, we can follow standardized naming rules to find it. The output of ps_hour, for instance, would have a name of the form "ps_hour/1.<time>".

So much for theoretical hand-waving and speculative descriptions. Next month, I'll discuss some daemons that can actually make all of this work.


Rich Morin has been using computers since 1970, Unix since 1983, and Mac-based Unix since 1986 (when he helped Apple create A/UX 1.0). When he isn't writing this column, Rich runs Prime Time Freeware (www.ptf.com), a publisher of books and CD-ROMs for the Free and Open Source software community. Feel free to write to Rich at rdm@ptf.com.

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Sketch 47.1 - Design app for UX/UI for i...
Sketch is an innovative and fresh look at vector drawing. Its intentionally minimalist design is based upon a drawing space of unlimited size and layers, free of palettes, panels, menus, windows, and... Read more
Cocktail 11.0.1 - General maintenance an...
Cocktail is a general purpose utility for macOS that lets you clean, repair and optimize your Mac. It is a powerful digital toolset that helps hundreds of thousands of Mac users around the world get... Read more
Path Finder 7.6.1 - Powerful, award-winn...
Path Finder makes you a master of file management. Take full control over your file system. Save your time: compare and synchronize folders, view hidden files, use Dual Pane and full keyboard... Read more
Slack 2.8.2 - Collaborative communicatio...
Slack is a collaborative communication app that simplifies real-time messaging, archiving, and search for modern working teams. Version 2.8.2: A small release containing nothing but another Electron... Read more
Smultron 10.0.2 - Easy-to-use, powerful...
Smultron 10 is an elegant and powerful text editor that is easy to use. You can use Smultron 10 to create or edit any text document. Everything from a web page, a note or a script to any single piece... Read more
Capto 1.2.5 - $29.99
Capto (was Voila) is an easy-to-use app that takes capturing, recording, video and image editing to the next level. With an intelligent file manager and quick sharing options, Capto is perfect for... Read more
ScreenFlow 7.1.1 - Create screen recordi...
ScreenFlow is powerful, easy-to-use screencasting software for the Mac. With ScreenFlow you can record the contents of your entire monitor while also capturing your video camera, microphone and your... Read more
Xcode 9.0.1 - Integrated development env...
Xcode includes everything developers need to create great applications for Mac, iPhone, iPad, and Apple Watch. Xcode provides developers a unified workflow for user interface design, coding, testing... Read more
TotalFinder 1.10.2 - Adds tabs, hotkeys,...
TotalFinder is a universally acclaimed navigational companion for your Mac. Enhance your Mac's Finder with features so smart and convenient, you won't believe you ever lived without them. Features... Read more
Adobe Flash Player 27.0.0.170 - Plug-in...
Adobe Flash Player is a cross-platform, browser-based application runtime that provides uncompromised viewing of expressive applications, content, and videos across browsers and operating systems.... Read more

Dune! guide - how to toe the line and ge...
Publisher Voodoo is at it again with an all new high score chaser -- Dune! In this fast-paced arcade game, you have to propel yourself along sand dunes, gaining enough momentum to jump above the line to score points, while making sure you have... | Read more »
The best deals on the App Store this wee...
Happy Tuesday, dear readers. Your favorite part of the week as officially arrived. It's time to take a look at the best deals in games. Things are admittedly a bit sparse, but there are a few diamonds in the rough to see you through if you're... | Read more »
Be the last person standing in Legacy of...
Yoozoo Games’ popular action MMO Legacy of Discord is getting a huge new update to celebrate its first anniversary. Perhaps the biggest change is the addition of an exciting survival mode titled Last Guardian. This new survival mode will pit you... | Read more »
Home Street guide - how to make friends...
From the creators of Food Street comes Home Street, a new simulation game that tasks you with building a social network and designing a beautiful home. It's a bit like The Sims, but you won't have to worry about the daily chores involved (feeding,... | Read more »
Color Ballz guide - how to bounce to the...
Color Ballz is an addictive new arcade title from Ketchapp Studios. It takes old school mechanics from games like Brickles and puts a fun twist on it. Your job? To catch balls with a paddle and send them back into a chute to be carried back to... | Read more »
Q&A: A-33 Studio explains why Combat...
When it comes to mobile FPS, it’s often tricky to get the fundamentals right on a platform lacking a physical controller, large display and hefty RAM. With Combat Squad: Project Wednesday, A-33 Studio bravely took on the challenge of making a... | Read more »
Taichi Panda 3: Dragon Hunter guide - ti...
Taichi Panda 3: Dragon Hunter launched this week to players all over the world. It's a beautiful mobile MMORPG that blends elements of Eastern and Western fantasy. It reminds us of a mix between World of Warcraft and Jade Empire. MMO's can have a... | Read more »
The best new games we played this week -...
Phew. It has been a week, but now it's time to relax, put your feet up, and enjoy some brand new mobile games. It was a bit of slow week, but there's still plenty of new titles to add to your collection. Here are four of our favorites. [Read... | Read more »
Yoink - Improved Drag and Drop (Product...
Yoink - Improved Drag and Drop 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Productivity Price: $2.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Yoink for iPad and iPhone lets you easily and quickly store items you drag, copy or share, for later use... | Read more »
Cottage Garden (Games)
Cottage Garden 1.11 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $4.99, Version: 1.11 (iTunes) Description: | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

13″ MacBook Pros on sale for up to $120 off M...
B&H Photo has 2017 13″ MacBook Pros in stock today and on sale for up to $120 off MSRP, each including free shipping plus NY & NJ sales tax only: – 13-inch 2.3GHz/128GB Space Gray MacBook... Read more
15″ MacBook Pros on sale for up to $200 off M...
B&H Photo has 15″ MacBook Pros on sale for up to $200 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges sales tax in NY & NJ only: – 15″ 2.8GHz MacBook Pro Space Gray (MPTR2LL/A): $2249, $150... Read more
Roundup of Apple Certified Refurbished iMacs,...
Apple has a full line of Certified Refurbished 2017 21″ and 27″ iMacs available starting at $1019 and ranging up to $350 off original MSRP. Apple’s one-year warranty is standard, and shipping is free... Read more
Sale! 27″ 3.8GHz 5K iMac for $2098, save $201...
Amazon has the 27″ 3.8GHz 5K iMac (MNED2LL/A) on sale today for $2098 including free shipping. Their price is $201 off MSRP, and it’s the lowest price available for this model (Apple’s $1949... Read more
Sale! 10″ Apple WiFi iPad Pros for up to $100...
B&H Photo has 10.5″ WiFi iPad Pros in stock today and on sale for $50-$100 off MSRP. Each iPad includes free shipping, and B&H charges sales tax in NY & NJ only: – 10.5″ 64GB iPad Pro: $... Read more
Apple iMacs on sale for up to $130 off MSRP w...
B&H Photo has 21-inch and 27-inch iMacs in stock and on sale for up to $130 off MSRP including free shipping. B&H charges sales tax in NY & NJ only: – 27″ 3.8GHz iMac (MNED2LL/A): $2179 $... Read more
2017 3.5GHz 6-Core Mac Pro on sale for $2799,...
B&H Photo has the 2017 3.5GHz 6-Core Mac Pro (MD878LL/A) on sale today for $2799 including free shipping plus NY & NJ sales tax only . Their price is $200 off MSRP. Read more
12″ 1.2GHz Space Gray MacBook on sale for $11...
Amazon has the 2017 12″ 1.2GHz Space Gray Retina MacBook on sale for $100 off MSRP. Shipping is free: 12″ 1.2GHz Space Gray MacBook: $1199.99 $100 off MSRP Read more
Bare Bones Software Releases macOS High Sierr...
Bare Bones Software has announced the release and immediate availability of BBEdit 12.0, a significant upgrade to its professional strength text and code editor. BBEdit 12 introduces a new foundation... Read more
Yale Announces Availability of Apple HomeKit-...
Yale Locks & Hardware has announced that Apple HomeKit support for its Assure Lock family is available this month. The new Yale iM1 Network Module, which provides support for the Apple Home app... Read more

Jobs Board

Fraud Analyst, *Apple* Advertising Platform...
Job Summary Apple Ad Platforms has an opportunity to redefine advertising on mobile devices. Apple reaches hundreds of millions of iPhone, iPod touch, and iPad Read more
*Apple* Information Security - Security Data...
Job Summary This role is responsible for helping to strengthen Apple 's information security posture through the identification and curation of security event data. Read more
Lead *Apple* Solution Consultant - Apple In...
…develop a team of diverse partner employees focusing on excellence to deliver the Apple story. Even when you're not present, you will maintain a consistent influence Read more
watchOS Frameworks Engineering Manager, *App...
Job Summary Join the team that is shaping the future of software development for Apple Watch! Apple is looking for an exceptional software engineering leader to Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions - Apple,...
Job Description:SalesSpecialist - Retail Customer Service and SalesTransform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.