TweetFollow Us on Twitter

X11: A C of Window Systems

Volume Number: 19 (2003)
Issue Number: 3
Column Tag: Section 7

X11: A C of Window Systems

or possibly a Fortran?

by Rich Morin

Taken on its own terms, X11 is a stunning success. As www.x.org/X11.htm proclaims:

    The X Window System, more simply 'X' or 'X11', is judged worldwide to be one of the most successful open source, collaborative technologies developed to date. It is the de facto standard graphical engine for the UNIX and Linux operating systems and provides the only common windowing environment bridging the heterogeneous platforms in today's enterprise computing. The inherent independence of the X Window System from operating system and hardware, its network-transparency, and its support for a wide range of popular desktops are responsible for its continuing and growing popularity.

    All major hardware vendors support the X Window System. Many third parties provide technologies for integrating X Window System applications into network or personal computer environments under DOS, Windows, Windows 9x, and Windows NT, while thousands of independent software developers provide X Window System applications. The worldwide community of users of the X Window System currently exceeds 30 million.

X11 is such a dominant technology in Unix circles that shipping a Unix system without an integral copy of X11 would be like omitting a C compiler or, erm, hiding the command line. Nonetheless, Apple's initial position was fairly plausible: "X11 support is an opportunity for third-party developers".

Several developers, indeed, accepted the challenge. Tenon Intersystems (www.tenon.com) has produced a well-regarded proprietary X11 implementation for OSX. OroborOSX (oroborosx.sf.net), XDarwin (www.xdarwin.org), and XonX (www.mrcla.com/XonX) provide free distributions of X11 for OSX.

Nonetheless, Apple's release of an "official" implementation of X11 is certain to interest many users, including some who have been wary of trying X11. And, indeed, Apple is in a position to make X11 interoperate with Aqua in ways that a third-party vendor might not have been able to duplicate. I would expect, however, to see the third-party developers adopt any enabling technologies that Apple makes available.

The Apple implementation includes "standard X11 display server software, client libraries, and developer toolkits". The intention, as confirmed by an Apple spokesman, is to place X11 at about the same level of OS support as, say, Carbon. That is, better integrated than Classic, but possibly missing some Cocoa functionality.

So, we can expect to see X11 apps appearing commonly on OSX. Despite the best efforts of all concerned, however, it is not clear that the fit will be all that good: the goals, designs, and philosophy of the two systems are wildly different. Let's look at each of these, using OSX as our point of reference.

X VS. X

The goals of X11, as noted above, are "network transparency" and "bridging heterogeneous platforms". An X11 user can access an X11-based application on either the local machine or on any machine which is reachable over the network.

Apple Remote Desktop, SSH, Timbuktu, and VNC all allow remote access, but none of these provides the level of integration and performance that X11 does. In short, if you want network-transparent, cross-platform support for GUI-based apps, X11 is your answer.

X11's design differences reflect its differing goals. An X11 "client" application sets up callback functions and issues UI requests, just as a Cocoa or Carbon app would. In X11, however, everything is translated into a serial stream of data, suitable for sending over the network.

In place of Apple's Cocoa and Carbon APIs, X11 has "widget sets" (e.g., GTK+, Motif, Qt, Xaw). In place of the Finder, X11 has "window managers" (e.g., fvwm, kvm, mwm, sawfish, twm) and "desktop environments" (e.g., CDE, Gnome, KDE).

Making all of this play nicely with Aqua (e.g., supporting drag and drop) isn't going to be an easy job. In fact, some things will simply fail to translate. If X11 has a widget that Aqua doesn't (or vice versa), there isn't much that a "glue layer" can do about it.

X11's basic philosophy is likely to cause the worst dislocations, however. Apple has worked for years to develop, document, and promote the Macintosh "Human Interface Guidelines". As a result, Mac users feel comfortable starting up a new app, knowing that the command keys and menus will all be familiar. No such guidelines are present in X11:

With no central authority specifying policy, no consistent user interface developed. Each of X11's widget sets, window managers, desktop environments, and applications was free to go off in its own direction. The resulting inconsistency will grate on seasoned Mac users.

Porting X11 apps

Now that Apple is providing an X11 development system, porting an X11 app shouldn't be much harder than porting any other Unix-based app. Nonetheless, I'd like to see Apple provide an X11 and Unix analog to the "Carbon Dater" (an analysis tool for Carbonizing Classic apps); this could ease the task of identifying the OSX equivalents to unavailable include files, library calls, system calls, etc.

While I'm fantasizing, I'd also like a way for Aqua apps to be accessible via the X11 protocol and an X11 toolkit that implements the Aqua look and feel. Both technical and legal issues surround these pipe dreams, however, so I'd best get back to reality.

If an app is written for certain X11 toolkits (e.g., GTK+, Qt, Tk), it may be possible to link it to Carbon or Cocoa. This could provide access to useful Cocoa features and/or improvement in appearance and/or performance. Look around for interface libraries, ala:

If the app only needs to run on a single machine, a port to native Cocoa may be appropriate. If the app has a clean separation between its Model and View code, the rework shouldn't be all that hard. Unfortunately, the real problems may not be obvious at the beginning of the effort.

X11, Layer by Layer

I have made some hand-waving claims about the differences between the OSX model and the X11 model. For those that may be interested, here is a (somewhat) detailed discussion of X11's structure.

At the bottom layer, X11 is a communication protocol. The units of discourse are user events (e.g., mouse and keyboard actions) and displayable items (e.g., characters and pixel rectangles, also known as "pixrects"). An X11 "server" runs on the user's desktop, making the screen and input devices available to the "client" application.

The low level of the X protocol limits the amount of processing power that the server can usefully provide. Once items display instantly, extra computing power is irrelevant. Compare this to Aqua, Display PostScript, Java, Javascript, or Sun's ill-fated NeWS, all of which can offload rendering and other processing to a separate processor.

In addition, X11 is not well suited to displaying shapes other than rectangles. Although any shape can be rendered as a set of rectangles, a PDF-based description of an arbitrary shape is likely to be a lot shorter than the pixrect equivalent.

At the next level, programming interfaces, X11 provides only the bare essentials. You can draw characters and pixrects, as implied above, but doing anything else requires "widgets". The good news is that there are a lot of widgets to choose from; the bad news is that there are a lot of widget sets to choose from. The sets all do roughly the same things, but the look, feel, and APIs vary.

Similarly, window management can be performed by any of a few dozen "window managers" (really, special-purpose X11 clients). These are similar to "skins" and "themes", but their influence extends into the feel, as well as the look, of the apps they are presenting.

Moving up to the application level, we see even more diversity. Historically, X11 app designers picked their own "hot keys", menu layouts, and other UI options. As a result, there was little consistency at this level.

Recently, some X11-based "desktop environments" have begun to promote more consistency in widgets, window management, and applications. The good news is that these environments are becoming popular; the bad news is that there are several desktop environments to choose from. Gnome and KDE are the most popular in Open Source circles. CDE is found on many proprietary Unix systems, but Sun intends to transition Solaris and its users to Gnome.

In Summary

The X mantra of "mechanism, not policy" has resulted in a prolific, but anarchic collection of APIs, window managers, and look and feel decisions. Like the many variations of the C programming language (e.g., C, C++, Objective-C), X11 has evolved into a "sea" of window systems, each with its own vagaries.

Apple's frameworks may be appallingly complex, but they are internally consistent, logical, and produce consistent results on the desktop. Where Microsoft Windows is simple (nay, simplistic), consistent, and ugly, X11 is powerful, inconsistent, and ugly.

This inconsistency, appearing at all levels of X11, means that users cannot build reliable habits. Apple's developer community has spent a great deal of time and effort on making sure that OSX apps act in a consistent manner; the X11 developer community has not, and it shows.

Co-existence?

Many OSX users and programmers will be inclined to ignore X11 entirely, but there are reasons why you might wish to consider a co-existence strategy. If you need a particular X11 app or some of the capabilities that X11 provides, you'll have to allow X11 into your world. Another reason might be the plethora of free (both libre and gratis) X11 apps.

Some institutions will find X11 unavoidable, because critically necessary apps are only available under it. The engineering and scientific communities have been using Unix and X11 for decades; OSX and Aqua are still (largely unproven) newcomers. Until the apps you need get ported to Cocoa, there really isn't any alternative to using X11.

There is also the possibility that you will need to create an OS-independent and/or network-capable application. As noted above, Apple has no real solution in this area; Apple Remote Desktop is fine for sharing a remote screen, but it isn't capable of supporting generic, distributed applications.

Even if your work doesn't require a specialized app, however, you may be interested in trying out some X11 packages. You can pick these up off the Internet (e.g., via Fink or the GNU-Darwin project), but you'll probably have less trouble with a pre-packaged collection.

BSDMall (www.bsdmall.com) has produced a set of X11-based "Office Applications for Mac OS X". The set includes word processors, spreadsheets, graphics tools, games, and more. You may recognize tools such as AbiWord, Calc, Chimera, Draw, Gaim, Gimp, Impress, Math, and OpenOffice. If you're interested in trying X11, this might be a good starting point.

More generally, for a good list of X11 resources, try Kenton Lee's "Technical X Window System and Motif WWW Sites" page, http://www.rahul.net/kenton/xsites.html. He has done a really fine job of collecting and organizing X11-related links!


Rich Morin has been using computers since 1970, Unix since 1983, and Mac-based Unix since 1986 (when he helped Apple create A/UX 1.0). When he isn't writing this column, Rich runs Prime Time Freeware (www.ptf.com), a publisher of books and CD-ROMs for the Free and Open Source software community. Feel free to write to Rich at rdm@ptf.com.

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Google Earth 7.1.8.3036 - View and contr...
Google Earth gives you a wealth of imagery and geographic information. Explore destinations like Maui and Paris, or browse content from Wikipedia, National Geographic, and more. Google Earth combines... Read more
QuickBooks 16.1.11.1556 R12 - Financial...
QuickBooks helps you manage your business easily and efficiently. Organize your finances all in one place, track money going in and out of your business, and spot areas where you can save. Built for... Read more
Google Earth 7.1.8.3036 - View and contr...
Google Earth gives you a wealth of imagery and geographic information. Explore destinations like Maui and Paris, or browse content from Wikipedia, National Geographic, and more. Google Earth combines... Read more
QuickBooks 16.1.11.1556 R12 - Financial...
QuickBooks helps you manage your business easily and efficiently. Organize your finances all in one place, track money going in and out of your business, and spot areas where you can save. Built for... Read more
FileZilla 3.24.0 - Fast and reliable FTP...
FileZilla (ported from Windows) is a fast and reliable FTP client and server with lots of useful features and an intuitive interface. Version 3.24.0: New The context menu for remote file search... Read more
Bookends 12.7.8 - Reference management a...
Bookends is a full-featured bibliography/reference and information-management system for students and professionals. Bookends uses the cloud to sync reference libraries on all the Macs you use.... Read more
Duplicate Annihilator 5.8.3 - Find and d...
Duplicate Annihilator takes on the time-consuming task of comparing the images in your iPhoto library using effective algorithms to make sure that no duplicate escapes. Duplicate Annihilator detects... Read more
BusyContacts 1.1.6 - Fast, efficient con...
BusyContacts is a contact manager for OS X that makes creating, finding, and managing contacts faster and more efficient. It brings to contact management the same power, flexibility, and sharing... Read more
MarsEdit 3.7.10 - Quick and convenient b...
MarsEdit is a blog editor for OS X that makes editing your blog like writing email, with spell-checking, drafts, multiple windows, and even AppleScript support. It works with with most blog services... Read more
BusyCal 3.1.4 - Powerful calendar app wi...
BusyCal is an award-winning desktop calendar that combines personal productivity features for individuals with powerful calendar sharing capabilities for families and workgroups. Its unique features... Read more

Super Mario Run dashes onto Android in M...
Super Mario Run was one of the biggest mobile launches in 2016 before it was met with a lukewarm response by many. While the game itself plays a treat, it's pretty hard to swallow the steep price for the full game. With that said, Android users... | Read more »
WarFriends Beginner's Guide: How to...
Chillingo's new game, WarFriends, is finally available world wide, and so far it's a refreshing change from common mobile game trends. The game's a mix of tower defense, third person shooter, and collectible card game. There's a lot to unpack here... | Read more »
Super Gridland (Entertainment)
Super Gridland 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Entertainment Price: $1.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Match. Build. Survive. "exquisitely tuned" - Rock Paper Shotgun No in-app purches, and no ads! | Read more »
Red's Kingdom (Games)
Red's Kingdom 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $4.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Mad King Mac has kidnapped your father and stolen your golden nut! Solve puzzles and battle goons as you explore and battle your... | Read more »
Turbo League Guide: How to tame the cont...
| Read more »
Fire Emblem: Heroes coming to Google Pla...
Nintendo gave us our first look at Fire Emblem: Heroes, the upcoming mobile Fire Emblem game the company hinted at last year. Revealed at the Fire Emblem Direct event held today, the game will condense the series' tactical RPG combat into bite-... | Read more »
ReSlice (Music)
ReSlice 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Music Price: $9.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Audio Slice Machine Slice your audio samples with ReSlice and create flexible musical atoms which can be triggered by MIDI notes or... | Read more »
Stickman Surfer rides in with the tide t...
Stickson is back and this time he's taken up yet another extreme sport - surfing. Stickman Surfer is out this Thursday on both iOS and Android, so if you've been following the other Stickman adventures, you might be interested in picking this one... | Read more »
Z-Exemplar (Games)
Z-Exemplar 1.4 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $3.99, Version: 1.4 (iTunes) Description: | Read more »
5 dastardly difficult roguelikes like th...
Edmund McMillen's popular roguelike creation The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth has finally crawled onto mobile devices. It's a grotesque dual-stick shooter that tosses you into an endless, procedurally generated basement as you, the pitiable Isaac,... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

Twelve South Releases RelaxedLeather Cases fo...
Inspired by the laid-back luxury of burnished leather boots and crafted in rich tones of taupe, herb and marsala, RelaxedLeather cases deliver smart, easy protection for the iPhone 7. Each genuine... Read more
Week’s Best Deal: New 2016 13-inch 2.0GHz Mac...
Amazon has the new 2016 13″ 2.0GHz non-Touch Bar MacBook Pros on sale for a limited time for $225 off MSRP including free shipping: - 13″ 2.0GHz MacBook Pro, Space Gray (MLL42LL/A): $1274.99 $225 off... Read more
Back in stock: Apple refurbished Mac minis fr...
Apple has Certified Refurbished Mac minis available starting at $419. Apple’s one-year warranty is included with each mini, and shipping is free: - 1.4GHz Mac mini: $419 $80 off MSRP - 2.6GHz Mac... Read more
Apple Ranked ‘Most Intimate Brand’
The top ranked ‘”intimate” brands continued to outperform the S&P and Fortune 500 indices in revenue and profit over the past 10 years, according to MBLM’s Brand Intimacy 2017 Report, the largest... Read more
B-Eng introduces SSD Health Check for Mac OS
Fehraltorf, Switzerland based independant Swiss company- B-Eng has announced the release and immediate availability of SSD Health Check 1.0, the company’s new hard drive utility for Mac OS X. As the... Read more
Apple’s Education discount saves up to $300 o...
Purchase a new Mac or iPad using Apple’s Education Store and take up to $300 off MSRP. All teachers, students, and staff of any educational institution qualify for the discount. Shipping is free: -... Read more
4-core 3.7GHz Mac Pro on sale for $2290, save...
Guitar Center has the 3.7GHz 4-core Mac Pro (MD253LL/A) on sale for $2289.97 including free shipping or free local store pickup (if available). Their price is a $710 savings over standard MSRP for... Read more
128GB Apple iPad Air 2, refurbished, availabl...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 128GB iPad Air 2s WiFis available for $419 including free shipping. That’s an $80 savings over standard MSRP for this model. A standard Apple one-year warranty is... Read more
13-inch 2.7GHz Retina MacBook Pro on sale for...
B&H Photo has the 2015 13″ 2.7GHz/128GB Retina Apple MacBook Pro on sale for $100 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY tax only: - 13″ 2.7GHz/128GB Retina MacBook Pro (MF839LL/A): $... Read more
Laptop Market – Flight To Quality? – The ‘Boo...
Preliminary quarterly PC shipments data released by Gartner Inc. last week reveal an interesting disparity between sales performance of major name PC vendors as opposed to that of less well-known... Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* macOS Systems Integration Administra...
…most exceptional support available in the industry. SCI is seeking an Junior Apple macOS systems integration administrator that will be responsible for providing Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions- Deer Pa...
Job Description: Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions - Apple,...
Job Description: Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, Read more
*Apple* Technician - nfrastructure (United S...
Let’s Work Together Apple Technician This position is based in Portland, ME Life at nfrastructure At nfrastructure, we understand that our success results from our Read more
*Apple* Mobile Master - Best Buy (United Sta...
**467692BR** **Job Title:** Apple Mobile Master **Location Number:** 000602-Columbia MO-Store **Job Description:** **What does a Best Buy Apple Mobile Master Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.