TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Deferred Garbage Collection

Volume Number: 13 (1997)
Issue Number: 12
Column Tag: C++ Workshop

Deferred Garbage Collection

by Marc White

Implementing a simple deferred C++ object garbage collection class

Self Deleting Objects

When developing object oriented software using C++ there are certain situations where you may need an object that can delete itself. For instance, you might have a window or dialog class that manages its own mouse clicks and key down events. But what does the dialog object do when it determines that the user has pressed the escape or delete key, or clicked the window's close box? To stay true to the object oriented design, the window should be able to do whatever processing is needed when it determines that it is being closed and then free up the memory allocated for the object by itself.

Delete This

While the C++ syntax delete this is a legal call, it can cause serious problems if the object that makes the call is referenced in any way after the call is made. This could possibly happen while the stack is unwinding after a mouse click or key down event.

The TGarbageCollector Class

The TGarbageCollector class is a simple, drop in utility class that allows any C++ object to be safely deleted at a later time.

Listing 1: The TGarbageCollector Class

The TGarbageCollector class is a non-instance class with two public static methods: Add, and Empty, and one private static member variable: fTrashCan which is pointer to a TGarbage object.

class TGarbageCollector {
friend class TGarbage;
public:
  static void Add      ( void *trash );
  static void Empty    ( void );
  
private:
  static TGarbage      *fTrashCan;
};

TGarbageCollector::Add

The Add method of the TGarbageCollector class simply instantiates a new TGarbage object passing it a pointer to the C++ object to be deleted. Note that the trash pointer is a void pointer.

void TGarbageCollector::Add( void *trash )
{
  // create a new TGarbage object
  new TGarbage( trash );
}

TGarbageCollector::Empty

The Empty method of the TGarbageCollector class deletes all of the TGarbage objects pointed to by the fTrashCan variable. This method should be called periodically at idle time in the application's main event loop. The TGarbage object's destructor maintains the linked list.

void TGarbageCollector::Empty( void )
{
  // delete all of the items in the trash can
  while( TGarbageCollector::fTrashCan )
    delete( TGarbageCollector::fTrashCan );
}

I developed the TGarbageCollector class as a part of an application framework I was designing. The easiest way to design the garbage collection class would have been to have it delete only objects derived from a specific class, perhaps a TTrashableObject class. But, I wanted the garbage collector to be able to delete any C++ object, and I didn't want to have every class in the framework be derived from a single base class.

The TGarbage Class

This is where the TGarbage class comes in. Because the TGarbage class accepts a void pointer as a pointer to the object it will delete, any pointer can be passed into the garbage collection class to be deleted. This means that it is up to the developer (not the compiler) to make sure that the pointer passed in is a pointer to a valid C++ object.

There is one more catch which I will describe in the What's the Catch section, but for now let's take a look at the TGarbage class.

Listing 2: The TGarbage Class

The TGarbage class is a simple self-linking singly linked list class which accepts a void pointer through its constructor. It stores a pointer to the object to delete in the fTrash variable and a pointer to the next TGarbage object in the list in its fNext variable.

class TGarbage {
public:
            TGarbage    ( void *trash );
  virtual    ~TGarbage  ( void );
private:
  void        *fTrash;
  TGarbage    *fNext;
};

TGarbage::TGarbage

The TGarbage constructor stores a pointer to object to delete in its fTrash variable. Next it links itself into the linked list pointed to by the TGarbageCollector's static fTrashCan variable. It can access this private item since the TGarbageCollector has the declared the TGarbage class as a friend.

TGarbage::TGarbage( void *trash ) : fTrash( trash )
{
  // store a pointer to the next item in the chain
  if( TGarbageCollector::fTrashCan )
    this->fNext = TGarbageCollector::fTrashCan;
  else
    this->fNext = nil;
  
  // set this item as the first item in the trash can
  TGarbageCollector::fTrashCan = this;
}

TGarbage::~TGarbage

This is where the real magic happens. When the TGarbage object gets deleted we have no idea what type of object its fTrash variable points to, all that we know is that it is pointing to a C++ object. So just type cast it to a C++ class pointer (in this case a TGarbage pointer) and call the delete operator. The real object's destructor will get called and its memory will be deallocated. It's just that easy!

TGarbage::~TGarbage( void )
{
  // pull this object out of the linked list
  TGarbageCollector::fTrashCan = this->fNext;
  
  // delete the trash
  delete( (TGarbage *)this->fTrash );
}

Sample Usage

Let's take a look at the TGarbageCollector class in action. Code listing 3 shows the DoKeyDown method of a typical dialog class.

Listing 3: A Dialog Class Method

void FDialog::DoKeyDown( char theKey )
{
  switch( theKey ) {
    case kEscKey:
      // add this object to the trash
      TGarbageCollector::Add( this );
      // hide this dialog
      this->Hide();
      // do any other processing needed here before closing
      break;
    default:
      inherited::DoKeyDown( theKey );
  }
}

Notice that the dialog can add itself to the trash at any time once it determines that it needs to be deleted. The dialog object is still valid until the trash gets collected.

Next we'll take a look at the event loop method of a typical application class. This is where the TGarbageCollector's Empty method gets called and all of the objects added to the trash are deleted.

Listing 4: An Application Class Event Loop Method

void FApplication::EventLoop( void )
{
  EventRecord  theEvent;

  while( this->fQuit == false ) {
    if( WaitNextEvent( everyEvent, &theEvent, 30, nil ) ) {
      switch( theEvent.what ) {
        // handle all normal events here
        default:
          TGarbageCollector::Empty();
          break;
      }
    } else {
      TGarbageCollector::Empty();
    }
  }
}

What's The Catch?

So there has to be a catch, right? Well, of course there is. The catch is that any C++ object added to the trash must be structured in the same way as the object used to type cast the void pointer in the TGarbage object before calling its delete operator.

In simpler terms, any object added to the trash must have a virtual destructor, and its destructor must be the first virtual method of that class. This is because of the way a C++ object is structured from a class.

The TGarbage class typecasts the void pointer to the object it is going to delete into a pointer to a TGarbage object. This instructs the compiler to use the virtual table, or vtbl, of the TGarbage class to find the location of the object's destructor which it calls before deallocating the object's memory.

In the case of the TGarbage class, the destructor is the first virtual method of the class and therefore will be the first entry in the vtbl. As long as any object added to the trash can has its destructor as the first item in the vtbl, it will be properly called when the TGarbage class deletes the object.

What would happen if the object being trashed did not have a virtual destructor, or if the destructor was not the first virtual method? If the object's virtual destructor is not the first virtual method in the class, or it's destructor is not virtual, then before the memory for that object is deallocated the first virtual method of that class will be called. In the case of an object that does not have any virtual methods, the object will not even have a vtbl which means that some random memory location is going be executed as a method. Obviously, neither of these two scenarios are desirable, which is why it is very important that the developer structures the classes for trashable objects properly.

Multiple Inheritance

Can objects that use multiple inheritance be successfully deleted using the TGarbageCollector class? In short, yes, as long as they still adhere to the virtual-destructor-first method like the other classes.

However, there is an exception. Depending upon how the compiler implements multiple inheritance (I am using CodeWarrior for this example), as long as the first class specified in the inheritance chain has a virtual destructor as its first virtual method, the order of the virtual methods of the other superclasses does not matter.

Listing 5: Multiple Inheritance

// destructor is the first virtual method
class A {
public:
              A    ( void );
  virtual      ~A    ( void );
};

// destructor is the second virtual method
class B {
public:
              B    ( void );
  virtual void  Test  ( void );
  virtual      ~B    ( void );
};

// inherit from A first, then B
class C : public A, public B {
public:
              C    ( void );
  virtual      ~C    ( void );
};

// inherit from B first, then A 
class D : public B, public A {
public:
              D    ( void );
  virtual      ~D    ( void );
};

In code listing 5, class A follows the virtual-destructor-first method which would allow any object of class A to be deleted properly by the TGarbageCollector class. Class B, however, has its virtual destructor declared as the second virtual method in the class, and therefore, would not be deleted properly by the TGarbageCollector class. The B object's Test method would actually get called when the TGarbage class deleted it.

Since class C inherits from class A first and class B second, class C objects can successfully be deleted using this method. When the TGarbage class calls the C object's delete operator, the class C destructor will be called first, the class B destructor second, and the A destructor third.

Class D, however, inherits from the B class first, which means that it will behave exactly like a B object would when being deleted by the TGarbageCollector, the inherited B object's Test method will get called.

So, even though there is an exception to the virtual-destructor-first rule in the case of multiple inheritance, it is much safer to make sure that any object that might be deleted by the TGarbageCollector have its virtual destructor declared before any other virtual methods.

Summary

The TGarbageCollector class provides a simple means of adding deferred object deletion to any C++ application. However, the developer must make certain that the classes of objects which will be deleted in this manner are structured according to the virtual-destructor-first rule.


Marc White is a Macintosh programmer at US WEST Dex, Inc., where he develops client/server software used to paginate the US WEST phone directories. He can be reached at mwhite@eagle.mrg.uswest.com.

 
AAPL
$100.86
Apple Inc.
-0.77
MSFT
$46.76
Microsoft Corpora
+0.52
GOOG
$579.95
Google Inc.
+6.85

MacTech Search:
Community Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Transmit 4.4.7 - Excellent FTP/SFTP clie...
Transmit is an excellent FTP (file transfer protocol), SFTP, S3 (Amazon.com file hosting) and iDisk/WebDAV client that allows you to upload, download, and delete files over the internet. With the... Read more
Macgo Blu-ray Player 2.10.8.1715 - Blu-r...
Macgo Mac Blu-ray Player can bring you the most unforgettable Blu-ray experience on your Mac. Overview Macgo Mac Blu-ray Player can satisfy just about every need you could possibly have in a Blu-ray... Read more
Capture One Pro 8.0.0.433 - RAW workflow...
Capture One Pro 8 is a professional RAW converter offering you ultimate image quality with accurate colors and incredible detail from more than 300 high-end cameras -- straight out of the box. It... Read more
Adobe Acrobat Pro 11.0.09 - Powerful PDF...
Adobe Acrobat allows users to communicate and collaborate more effectively and securely. Unify a wide range of content in a single organized PDF Portfolio. Collaborate through electronic document... Read more
Adobe Reader 11.0.09 - View PDF document...
Adobe Reader allows users to view PDF documents. You may not know what a PDF file is, but you've probably come across one at some point. PDF files are used by companies and even the IRS to... Read more
iFFmpeg 4.6.1 - Convert multimedia files...
iFFmpeg is a graphical front-end for FFmpeg, a command-line tool used to convert multimedia files between formats. The command line instructions can be very hard to master/understand, so iFFmpeg does... Read more
NTFS 11.3.62 - Provides full read and wr...
Paragon NTFS breaks down the barriers between Windows and OS X. Paragon NTFS effectively solves the communication problems between the Mac system and NTFS, providing full read and write access to... Read more
OS X Yosemite 10.10 DP8 - Developer Prev...
Note: This is a Developer Preview. You must be a registered Apple Mac Developer to download this update. You can also sign up for the free OS X Beta Program to download and preview public beta... Read more
FotoMagico 4.5 - Powerful slideshow crea...
FotoMagico lets you create professional slideshows from your photos and music with just a few, simple mouse clicks. It sports a very clean and intuitive yet powerful user interface. High image... Read more
Screenshot Path 1.2.1 - Change the defau...
Screenshot Path lets you change the folder where OS X saves screenshots. Screenshots are saved by default to the user’s desktop. This is handy for the occasional screenshot but those looking to take... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Zynga Unveils First Look at Looney Tunes...
Zynga Unveils First Look at Looney Tunes Dash! Posted by Ellis Spice on September 16th, 2014 [ permalink ] Be vewy, vewy qwiet. I’m hunting wunners featuwing wabbits, and luckily, it’s duck season wunner season. | Read more »
Guardians on the Go – How to Connect to...
At this point I’m relatively certain most of the country is familiar with Destiny. And for those looking to augment their game a bit, Bungie has changed their Bungie Mobile Companion App to Destiny Companion. | Read more »
Kunin Review
Kunin Review By Jordan Minor on September 16th, 2014 Our Rating: :: SHURIKEN DO ITUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad Kunin is a nervous test of ninja reflexes.   Developer: Dodreams Price: FREE Version Reviewed: 1.0.1... | Read more »
4 KEMCO Titles are Just $0.99 for a Limi...
4 KEMCO Titles are Just $0.99 for a Limited Time Posted by Jessica Fisher on September 16th, 2014 [ permalink ] KEMCO RPGs Destiny Fantasia, Infinite Dunamis, Bonds of the Sk | Read more »
Introducing Flash, the Latest Wearable F...
Introducing Flash, the Latest Wearable Fitness Monitor from Misfit Posted by Jessica Fisher on September 16th, 2014 [ permalink ] The Misfit Flash is the newly-released fitness and sleep monitor from | Read more »
Hyper Trip Review
Hyper Trip Review By Jennifer Allen on September 16th, 2014 Our Rating: :: HYPER TWITCHYUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad Tough and unforgiving, Hyper Trip is a bit like Snake – if Snake was really harsh.   | Read more »
Collectible Card Game Earthcore: Shatter...
Collectible Card Game Earthcore: Shattered Elements is Set to Arrive on iOS in 2015 Posted by Ellis Spice on September 16th, 2014 [ permalink ] Polish developers | Read more »
Boogey Boy Review
Boogey Boy Review By Jennifer Allen on September 16th, 2014 Our Rating: :: PRETTY BUT BASICUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad It looks delightful but lack of Game Center support and more variety really affects the fun... | Read more »
Vizzywig 4K (Photography)
Vizzywig 4K 1.0 Device: iOS iPhone Category: Photography Price: $999.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: REQUIRES: iOS 7 on iPhone 5S with 32GB or 64GB. (Do not use iOS 8)The world's FIRST mobile 4K video capture, editing and... | Read more »
The Sleeping Prince Review
The Sleeping Prince Review By Jennifer Allen on September 15th, 2014 Our Rating: :: RESTRICTIVE KINGDOM SAVINGUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad The Sleeping Prince looks and feels great to play, but its lack of peril and... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

Sprint offers 16GB iPad mini for $199.99 with...
Sprint is offering 1st generation 16GB iPad minis for $199.99 with a 2-year service agreement. Standard MSRP for this iPad is $429. Their price is the lowest available for this model. Read more
2.5GHz Mac mini remains on sale for $549, sav...
B&H Photo has the 2.5GHz Mac mini on sale for $549.99 including free shipping. That’s $50 off MSRP, and B&H will also include a free copy of Parallels Desktop software. NY sales tax only. Read more
Apple refurbished iMacs available for up to $...
The Apple Store has Apple Certified Refurbished iMacs available for up to $300 off the cost of new models. Apple’s one-year warranty is standard, and shipping is free. These are the best prices on... Read more
13″ 2.5GHz MacBook Pro offered for $100 off M...
B&H Photo has the 13″ 2.5GHz MacBook Pro on sale for $999.99 including free shipping plus NY sales tax only. Their price is $100 off MSRP. Read more
Free GIMP Professional Grade Graphics App Ver...
The latest 2.8.14 version of the oddly-named GIMP (acronym for: GNU Image Manipulation Program) open source, high-end image editing and creation alternative to Adobe’s Photoshop and refuge from... Read more
Apple Announces Record Pre-orders for iPhone...
Apple has released metrics showing a record number of first day pre-orders of iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus, with over four million sold in the first 24 hours. Demand for the new iPhones exceeds the... Read more
10% off iPhone 6 and 6 Plus Otterbox cases
Get 10% off on popular Otterbox iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus cases at MacMall through September 19th. Use code OTTERBOX10 to see the discount. Read more
15-inch MacBook Pros on sale for up to $125 o...
Amazon has the new 2014 15″ Retina MacBook Pros on sale for up to $125 off MSRP including free shipping: - 15″ 2.2GHz Retina MacBook Pro: $1899.99 save $100 - 15″ 2.5GHz Retina MacBook Pro: $2374... Read more
27-inch 3.2GHz iMac on sale for $1698, $101 o...
Abt has the 27″ 3.2GHz iMac on sale for $1698 including free shipping. Their price is $101 off MSRP. Read more
More To Making A Larger iPad Than Expanded Sc...
CNET’s Ross Rubin has posted a thoughtful analysis of prospects for a larger display iPad Pro, noting that Microsoft and Samsung currently have the large-display touchscreen tablet category to... Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.