TweetFollow Us on Twitter

IDE Review 96
Volume Number:12
Issue Number:12
Column Tag:Development Environments

Choosing Your C/C++ IDE

How well do the latest Metrowerks and Symantec C/C++ IDEs stand up to each other?

By Will Iverson, Apple Computer Inc.

This article compares two mainstream Macintosh IDEs, Metrowerks CodeWarrior 10 (CW10) and Symantec C++ for Power Macintosh 8.0 Release 5 (sometimes referred to as SC++ 8.5). A closing section will look at alternative environments such as MPW and VIP-C, but the focus here is on the now “traditional” editor-project-debugger suite of tools made standard by the THINK tools.

The goal is not to instruct the reader as to which tool to buy, but rather to illustrate the strengths and weaknesses of both environments.

Editor

The most striking thing about these two editors is not the differences, but rather the similarities. Even the default colors are nearly identical. Some subtle differences emerge when deeply scratching the editors, but the majority of the differences are minor interface changes. Both environments are scriptable and include a “Scripts” menu that includes several useful scripts (CW contains 7, SC++ contains over 30). However, to get the most of the scripts some knowledge of AppleScript or Frontier would be quite helpful.

Figure 1. CodeWarrior editor.

Figure 2. Symantec Editor.

Both environments support source code highlighting, horizontal and vertical split panes, and “markers” allowing you to mark locations in your code. SC++ tends to be a bit smarter about coloring strings and allowing for multiple fonts, styles and colors, but CW is more flexible about configuring which words to highlight.

A very interesting and rather curious development is the addition of Apple Guide support to both products. Evaluating the effectiveness of these Apple Guides is exceedingly difficult for this (somewhat jaded) writer. The step-by-step walk-through of such things as “how to build a C++ project” is too grating to bear, but the usefulness to new programmers is potentially quite great. I would be interested to hear of the effectiveness of these Apple Guides from new programmers.

Both Find dialogs offer virtually identical functionality, packaged in completely different interfaces. The CW Find dialog supports “sets” that allow you to quickly switch between multiple groups of files. Metrowerks recommends creating a set of library export symbols to quickly figure out which library to import when unresolved link errors arise. They provide the export symbols files to search.

This is not to say that the two environments are identical. Symantec features a KeyBinding utility, which allows you to re-map all keystrokes (such as to match the Emacs suite). Metrowerks allows you to edit errors in the same window in which the message appears. Nice for minor syntax errors. Metrowerks includes a toolbar, which looks whizzy in demos but basically just takes up screen space. Although Metrowerks offers the option of removing it, you then lose status messages during builds and links. [You can remove all the buttons by Command-Control-clicking each one. The toolbar then collapses to only the status bar. - Ed. esg.]

Browsers

As Figures 3, 4 and 5 show, the CodeWarrior browser is much more rich than the browser currently offered by the Symantec C++ environment. This is ironic, since the Symantec browser was available nearly a year prior to the first sluggish CW browser. Symantec’s browser in Café, their Java development environment, offers quite a bit of additional functionality compared to their C++ environment. Symantec insists that there will be a release 6 of SC++ that will bring the C++ browser to parity with the Café browser, although they were unable to specify when.

For those unfamiliar with the class browser, the concept is simple. During a parse phase (combined into the compile for both environments) the project manager builds a database of symbols, including class table information. The environment presents this information in the form of a “browser,” allowing the user to navigate classes and their functions more easily. Browsers are typically more useful for C++ users than C users, although the CodeWarrior environment makes some gesture toward C users with their “catalog” concept.

Perhaps the most interesting element of the CW environment is the integration of the browser into the base editor. Certain words flagged in the browser database are automatically highlighted, and by clicking and holding the mouse on these words it presents the user with a variety of context-sensitive menus. Options include finding the definition, inserting a template, finding (through hierarchical menus) member function declarations and definitions, and finding all implementations of the selected keyword.

Figure 3. CodeWarrior graphical browser.

Figure 4. CodeWarrior class browser.

Figure 5. Symantec class browser.

Project Management

What the Symantec environment lacks in browser bells, it makes up for in Project Management frills. Both environments include basics such as status, touching files, etc. Both support dropping files from the Finder, but the Symantec environment also allows dragging files out of the environment and into other applications, allowing for convenient drop-launching.

Figure 6. CodeWarrior Project Manager.

Figure 7. Symantec Project Manager.

The Symantec environment supports “untouching” files, useful when you have modified a comment in a header and want to avoid a complete rebuild. The Symantec environment supports nested folders and projects (which can be set to rebuild automatically) and integrated Projector source control, including database creation, mounting, setting, and check in and check out. The Symantec environment allows you to open a text file without a project file being open, and also allows you to open multiple projects. Multiple projects are especially nice when grabbing libraries or synchronizing with another project.

Compilers

As you can see from the numbers below, the CodeWarrior environment is considerably snappier than the Symantec environment for large builds. Part of this is no doubt due to the more sophisticated project management system underlying the Symantec environment. Such features as internal threading - allowing you to continue editing source files during a build, no doubt contributes to the build time.

Build Speed

Build time

CW 12 seconds

Symantec 25 seconds

Time to build and link 13 source files (a mix of C/C++) and five libraries on a 7500/100 (PowerPC 601), 64MB of RAM, 256K L2 cache, with the default memory allocations for each environment, on System 7.5.3 Revision 2. No optimizations, default precompiled MacHeaders, and default Macintosh C++ application project models.

Turnaround Speed

CW 4 seconds

Symantec 4 seconds

Time to make a single, trivial change to a source file, hit run, and be running the application.

It is beyond the scope of this article to cover the quality of code generated by these compilers. You can pick and choose among the dozens of benchmarks available to determine the “best” results. Put another way - if I wanted to show you that my compiler is faster, give me a day and I’ll have a dozen performance tests to show you why it’s the fastest, even if I had to go through three dozen tests to find them.

Generally speaking, the speed and robustness of both compilers are quite reasonable. If you are truly obsessed with speed, you can check out the Motorola compiler and Apple’s MrC, both of which are available as drop-ins to both environments. If you would like to see some in depth coverage on the topic of Macintosh PowerPC compiler code generation, I strongly encourage you to check out back issues of Game Developer Magazine. For more information, check http://www.gdmag.com/, specifically the June/July 1996 issue.

Finally, it is worth mentioning that the CodeWarrior compiler supports Direct-To-SOM. Those of you interested in OpenDoc and component technology should pay attention to further developments in this arena.

Debugging

At first blush, the two debuggers appear quite similar. Both have simple VCR style controls, stack crawl displays with turn down triangles to view variables, and source views with marks to show locations at which to set breakpoints. Beyond the superficial comparison, differences begin to emerge.

Figure 8. CodeWarrior Debugger.

CodeWarrior approaches debugging from a shotgun perspective. Want a feature? It’s here, including memory and register displays, double-clicking a variable to display it in a memory window, a breakpoint summary window, watchpoints, MacsBug dcmds (to switch from MacsBug to the CW Debugger) and more.

Figure 9. Symantec Debugger.

The Symantec debugger offers a much more sparse environment, centered largely on the “Data” view window, which allows a user to enter an expression and have it evaluated on the fly. If you have a need, the Symantec debugger will force you to wrestle with the Data window. The Symantec debugger does have a few nice touches, such as the ability to view the source in the same fonts and styles specified by the editor. Your code looks the same in both places.

Both debuggers are separate applications, requiring the user to wait while they launch for the first time. Symantec has in development a debugger that includes many of the features of the CodeWarrior environment, including memory and register displays. It is scheduled for Release 6 of the environment.

Frameworks

It is beyond the scope of this article to provide an in-depth technical review of the two frameworks, Metrowerks’ PowerPlant and Symantec’s THINK Class Library. PowerPlant includes Constructor, a tool for generating graphical interfaces (driven entirely from a data perspective), and Symantec provides Visual Architect, a similar tool that also generates source code (although only for graphical interfaces - no Delphi here).

I suggest that prospective users of either framework do their homework before embarking on a project. Consult the back of this magazine for many books on developing with either framework, and pick up a book on each. Skim through them, and decide for yourself which seems more intuitive.

Requests

Both environments do basically the same things, with subtle differences in the way they operate and their feature sets. Here are some needed features that seemed to be logical evolutionary steps.

• Better error handling. Frequently the error includes a suggestion on how to fix it - why not offer a “just do it” button?

• Smarter linkers/linker errors. If the linker gets an unresolved symbol error, why not offer to search the system path to find and suggest a library with the relevant symbol?

• Better 68K/PowerPC integration. A simple button in the corner should allow me to flip between 68K and PowerPC builds from a single project file.

• Breakpoints in the editor.

• An “Instant” capability allowing me to type in small pieces of code and click an “execute” button.

• Specifically for Metrowerks: support removing the status bar and bringing it back during a build. Both environments could and should offer graphical bars that are visible from a distance (like a Finder copy).

• Collapsible code (a hierarchical outline display of loops, functions, and such).

• Smarter build management - if I’ve only edited a comment in a header do not trigger a complete rebuild.

Alternatives

One of the leading contenders for an “alternative” C development environment is Mainstay’s VIP-C. As you can see from Figure 10, the VIP-C editor offers many innovations. Clicking the black triangle next to the insertion point allows you to select from a palette of functions to embed any number of routines. The box on top of the source code is the function template guide, which allows you to easily tab through the parameters for a function, quite useful for functions with long parameter lists. The mini-windows are not merely summaries - this is where and how they are declared.

Figure 10. VIP-C editor.

The flowcharting feature is quite useful to ensure that the logical flow of a program is correct. Bugs tend to fall into syntax, logical, and functional categories. The compiler typically catches Syntax errors, and VIP-C’s error reporting is not significantly more powerful; although, it does help provide easy mechanisms for defining new variables. The interpreter catches functional bugs, and the flowchart provides the best stab yet at beginning to provide a solution for logical bugs.

Figure 11. VIP-C Project Manager.

The primary difference between VIP-C and the two mainstream vendors is the fundamental difference in their approach to a project. As you can see from Figure 11, VIP-C is based on the concept of routines, not files. This apparently minor difference abstracts from the developer the hassles of dealing with .c and .h files, making for a much more pleasurable development experience.

Unfortunately VIP-C supports only C, not C++, and Mainstay has made clear their plans not to support C++ in the future. Those of you worried about migration paths and performance may be intrigued to know that VIP-C offers an export to CodeWarrior, including all of the source code. VIP-C may not be for everyone, but it provides a very enjoyable alternative with an easy migration path.

There are other alternatives, the most prominent of which is MPW. Macintosh Programmer’s Workshop is Apple’s entry into the field, and it is curiously the least “Mac-like” of all of the environments. A command line tool at heart, MPW will appeal most to UNIX and DOS refugees. It is also quite useful for complex and sophisticated builds; something large houses encountering limitations in other environments should keep in mind. For more information on MPW, MrC, and other Apple favorites such as the vital ResEdit and MacsBug, check out http://www.devtools.apple.com/.

Conclusion

The Macintosh C/C++ market is more fertile than many think. Metrowerks is the current market leader, but time has shown that the market can be fickle. The current suites of tools are adequate, but leave quite a bit of room for improvement. In the estimation of this writer, the larger question is not the battle between environments, but rather between C++ and Java. I would be interested in hearing feedback and the experiences of other developers pursing all of these paths. Drop a note to iverson@aol.com.

 
AAPL
$524.94
Apple Inc.
+5.93
MSFT
$40.01
Microsoft Corpora
-0.39
GOOG
$536.10
Google Inc.
-20.44

MacTech Search:
Community Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Tweetbot 1.5.1 - Popular iOS twitter cli...
Tweetbot is a full-featured OS X Twitter client with a lot of personality. Whether it's the meticulously-crafted interface, sounds and animation, or features like multiple timelines and column views... Read more
Mac DVDRipper Pro 4.1.7 - Copy, backup,...
Mac DVDRipper Pro is the DVD backup solution that lets you protect your DVDs from scratches, save your batteries by reading your movies from your hard disk, manage your collection with just a few... Read more
PDFpenPro 6.2 - Advanced PDF toolkit for...
PDFpenPro allows users to edit PDF's easily. Add text, images and signatures. Fill out PDF forms. Merge or split PDF documents. Reorder and delete pages. Even correct text and edit graphics! Create... Read more
PDFpen 6.2 - Edit and annotate PDFs with...
PDFpen allows users to easily edit PDF's. Add text, images and signatures. Fill out PDF forms. Merge or split PDF documents. Reorder and delete pages. Even correct text and edit graphics! Features... Read more
Monolingual 1.5.9 - Remove unwanted OS X...
Monolingual is a program for removing unnecesary language resources from OS X, in order to reclaim several hundred megabytes of disk space. It requires a 64-bit capable Intel-based Mac and at least... Read more
Maya 2015 - Professional 3D modeling and...
Maya is an award-winning software and powerful, integrated 3D modeling, animation, visual effects, and rendering solution. Because Maya is based on an open architecture, all your work can be scripted... Read more
Starcraft II: Wings of Liberty 1.1.1.180...
Download the patch by launching the Starcraft II game and downloading it through the Battle.net connection within the app. Starcraft II: Wings of Liberty is a strategy game played in real-time. You... Read more
Sibelius 7.5.0 - Music notation solution...
Sibelius is the world's best-selling music notation software for Mac. It is as intuitive to use as a pen, yet so powerful that it does most things in less than the blink of an eye. The demo includes... Read more
Typinator 5.9 - Speedy and reliable text...
Typinator turbo-charges your typing productivity. Type a little. Typinator does the rest. We've all faced projects that require repetitive typing tasks. With Typinator, you can store commonly used... Read more
MYStuff Pro 2.0.16 - Create inventories...
MYStuff Pro is the most flexible way to create detail-rich inventories for your home or small business. Add items to MYStuff by dragging and dropping existing information, uploading new images, or... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Have a Special Dead Trigger 2 Easter Bas...
Have a Special Dead Trigger 2 Easter Basket Full of Goodies, Courtesy of Madfinger Games Posted by Rob Rich on April 18th, 2014 [ permalink ] Dead Trigger 2 | Read more »
Almost All of Playdek’s Library is on Sa...
Almost All of Playdek’s Library is on Sale Right Now, and You Should Check it Out Posted by Rob Rich on April 18th, 2014 [ permalink ] Playdek has released quite a few great iOS ports of board and card games over the years, and now most of them... | Read more »
Zynga Launches Brand New Farmville Exper...
Zynga Launches Brand New Farmville Experience with Farmville 2: Country Escape Posted by Tre Lawrence on April 18th, 2014 [ permalink ] | Read more »
David. Review
David. Review By Cata Modorcea on April 18th, 2014 Our Rating: :: MINIMALISTIC IN A DIFFERENT WAYUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad David is a minimalistic game wrapped inside of a soothing atmosphere in which the hero... | Read more »
Eyefi Unveils New Eyefi Cloud Service Th...
Eyefi Unveils New Eyefi Cloud Service That Allows Users to Share Media Across Personal Devices Posted by Tre Lawrence on April 18th, 2014 [ permalink ] | Read more »
Tales from the Dragon Mountain: The Lair...
Tales from the Dragon Mountain: The Lair Review By Jennifer Allen on April 18th, 2014 Our Rating: :: STEADY ADVENTURINGiPad Only App - Designed for the iPad Treading a safe path, Tales from the Dragon Mountain: The Lair is a... | Read more »
Yahoo Updates Flickr App with Advanced E...
Yahoo Updates Flickr App with Advanced Editing Features and More Posted by Tre Lawrence on April 18th, 2014 [ permalink ] | Read more »
My Incredible Body - A Kid's App to...
My Incredible Body - A Kid's App to Learn about the Human Body 1.1.00 Device: iOS Universal Category: Education Price: $2.99, Version: 1.1.00 (iTunes) Description: Wouldn’t it be cool to look inside yourself and see what was going on... | Read more »
Trials Frontier Review
Trials Frontier Review By Carter Dotson on April 18th, 2014 Our Rating: :: A ROUGH LANDINGUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad Trials Frontier finally brings the famed stunt racing franchise to mobile, but how much does its... | Read more »
Evernote Business Notebook by Moleskin I...
Evernote Business Notebook by Moleskin Introduced – Support Available in Evernote for iOS Posted by Tre Lawrence on April 18th, 2014 [ permalink ] | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

13-inch 2.4GHz Retina MacBook Pro available f...
Abt has the 13″ 2.4GHz 128GB Retina MacBook Pro available for $1229 including free shipping. Their price is $70 off MSRP. Read more
iMacs on sale for up to $160 off MSRP this we...
Best Buy has iMacs on sale for up to $160 off MSRP for a limited time. Choose free home shipping or free instant local store pickup (if available). Prices are valid for online orders only, in-store... Read more
iPad Airs on sale this weekend for up to $100...
Best Buy has WiFi iPad Airs on sale for $50 off MSRP and WiFi + Cellular iPad Airs on sale for $100 off MSRP on their online store for a limited time, with prices now starting at $449. Choose free... Read more
Apple restocks refurbished Mac minis starting...
The Apple Store has restocked Apple Certified Refurbished Mac minis for up to $150 off the cost of new models. Apple’s one-year warranty is included with each mini, and shipping is free: - 2.5GHz Mac... Read more
Hyundai Brings Apple CarPlay To The 2015 Sona...
Hyundai Motor America has announced it will bring Apple CarPlay functionality to the 2015 Sonata. CarPlay is pitched as a smarter, safer and easier way to use iPhone in the car and gives iPhone users... Read more
Updated iPads Coming Sooner Than We Had Thoug...
MacRumors, cites KGI securities analyst Ming Chi Kuo, well-respected as an Apple product prognisticator, saying that Apple will introduce an upgraded iPad Air and iPad mini in 2014/Q3, meaning the... Read more
Toshiba Unveils New High And Low End Laptop M...
Toshiba has announced new laptop models covering both the high-end and low-end of the notebook computer spectrum. Toshiba 4K Ultra HD Laptop Toshiba’s new Satellite P55t features one of the world’s... Read more
Save up to $270 with Apple refurbished 13-inc...
The Apple Store has Apple Certified Refurbished October 2013 13″ Retina MacBook Pros available starting at $1099, with models up to $270 off MSRP. Apple’s one-year warranty is standard, and shipping... Read more
Apple now offering refurbished iPad mini with...
The Apple Store has Certified Refurbished 2nd generation iPad minis with Retina Displays now available starting at $339. Apple’s one-year warranty is included with each model, and shipping is free.... Read more
Microsoft Blinks – Drops Microsoft Office 365...
Microsoft has dropped the annual subscription fee for Microsoft Office 365 Personal – which is needed in order to create and edit documents in Microsoft Office for iPad. However, Apple’s iOS and OS X... Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* Automotive Parts Department position...
Apple Automotive is one of the fastest growing dealer…and it shows. Consider making the switch to the Apple Automotive Group today! At Apple Automotive, we Read more
*Apple* Solutions Consultant (ASC) - Apple (...
**Job Summary** The ASC is an Apple employee who serves as an Apple brand ambassador and influencer in a Reseller's store. The ASC's role is to grow Apple Read more
*Apple* Retail - Manager - Holyoke - Apple I...
Job Summary Keeping an Apple Store thriving requires a diverse set of leadership skills, and as a Manager, you’re a master of them all. In the store’s fast-paced, Read more
*Apple* Retail - Manager - Apple (United Sta...
Job SummaryKeeping an Apple Store thriving requires a diverse set of leadership skills, and as a Manager, you're a master of them all. In the store's fast-paced, dynamic Read more
*Apple* Solutions Consultant (ASC) - Apple (...
**Job Summary** The ASC is an Apple employee who serves as an Apple brand ambassador and influencer in a Reseller's store. The ASC's role is to grow Apple Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.