TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Lambda
Volume Number:9
Issue Number:9
Column Tag:Lisp Listener

“The Lambda Lambada: Y Dance?”

Mutual Recursion

By André van Meulebrouck, Chatsworth, California

Note: Source code files accompanying article are located on MacTech CD-ROM or source code disks.

“Mathematics is thought moving in the sphere of complete abstraction from any particular instance of what it is talking about.” - Alfred North Whitehead

Welcome once again to Mutual of Omo Oz Y Old Kingdom (with apologies to the similar named TV series of yesteryears).

In this installment, Lambda, the forbidden (in conventional languages) function, does the lambada-the forbidden (in l-calculus) dance. Film at 11.

In [vanMeule Jun 91] the question was raised as to whether everything needed to create a metacircular interpreter (using combinators) has been given to the reader.

One of the last (if not the last) remaining items not yet presented is mutual recursion, which allows an interpreter’s eval and apply functions to do their curious tango (the “lambda lambada”?!?).

In this article, the derivation of a Y2 function will be shown. Y2 herein will be the sister combinator of Y, to be used for handling mutual recursion (of two functions) in the applicative order. The derivation of Y2 will be done in a similar manner as was done for deriving Y from pass-fact in [vanMeule May 92].

This exercise will hopefully give novel insights into Computer Science and the art of programming. (This is the stuff of Überprogrammers!) This exercise should also give the reader a much deeper understanding of Scheme while developing programming muscles in ways that conventional programming won’t.

Backdrop and motivation

[vanMeule Jun 91] described the minimalist game. The minimalist game is an attempt to program in Scheme using only those features of Scheme that have more or less direct counterparts in l-calculus. The aim of the minimalist game is (among other things):

1) To understand l-calculus and what it has to say about Computer Science.

2) To develop expressive skills. Part of the theory behind the minimalist game is that one’s expressive ability is not so much posited in how many programming constructs one knows, but in how cleverly one wields them. Hence, by deliberately limiting oneself to a restricted set of constructs, one is forced to exercise one’s expressive muscles in ways they would not normally get exercised when one has a large repertoire of constructs to choose from. The maxim here is: “learn few constructs, but learn them well”.

In l-calculus (and hence the minimalist game) there is no recursion. It turns out that recursion is a rather impure contortion in many ways! However, recursion can be simulated by making use of the higher order nature of l-calculus. A higher order function is a function which is either passed as an argument (to another function) or returned as a value. As thrifty as l-calculus is, it does have higher order functions, which is no small thing as very few conventional languages have such a capability, and those that do have it have only a very weak version of it. (This is one of the programming lessons to be learned from playing the minimalist game: The enormous power of higher order functions and the losses conventional languages suffer from not having them.)

Different kinds of recursion

As soon as a language has global functions or procedures and parameter passing provided via a stack discipline, you’ve got recursion! In fact, there is essentially no difference between a procedure calling itself or calling a different function-the same stack machinery that handles the one case will automatically handle the other. (There’s no need for the stack machinery to know nor care whether the user is calling other procedures or the same procedure.)

However, as soon as a language has local procedures, it makes a very big difference if a procedure calls itself! The problem is that when a local procedure sees a call to itself from within itself, by the rules of lexical scoping, it must look for its own definition outside of its own scope! This is because the symbol naming the recursive function is a free variable with respect to the context it occurs in.

; 1
>>> (let ((local-fact 
           (lambda (n)
             (if (zero? n)
                 1
                 (* n (local-fact (1- n)))))))
      (local-fact 5))
ERROR:  Undefined global variable
local-fact

Entering debugger.  Enter ? for help.
debug:> 

This is where letrec comes in.

; 2

>>> (letrec ((local-fact 
              (lambda (n)
                (if (zero? n)
                    1
                    (* n (local-fact (1- n)))))))
      (local-fact 5))
120

To understand what letrec is doing let’s translate it to its semantic equivalent. letrec can be simulated using let and set! [CR 91].

; 3
>>> (let ((local-fact ‘undefined))
      (begin
       (set! local-fact 
             (lambda (n)
               (if (zero? n)
                   1
                   (* n (local-fact (1- n))))))
       (local-fact 5)))
120

Mutual recursion is slightly different from “regular” recursion: instead of a function calling itself, it calls a different function that then calls the original function. For instance, “foo” and “fido” would be mutually recursive if foo called fido, and fido called foo. The letrec trick will work fine for mutual recursion.

; 4 

>>> (let ((my-even? ‘undefined)
          (my-odd? ‘undefined))
      (begin
       (set! my-even? 
             (lambda (n)
               (if (zero? n)
                   #t
                   (my-odd? (1- n)))))
       (set! my-odd? 
             (lambda (n)
               (if (zero? n)
                   #f
                   (my-even? (1- n)))))
       (my-even? 80)))
#t

The reason this works is because both functions that had to have mutual knowledge of each other were defined as symbols in a lexical context outside of the context in which the definitions were evaluated.

However, all the above letrec examples rely on being able to modify state. l-calculus doesn’t allow state to be modified. (An aside: since parallel machines have similar problems and restrictions in dealing with state, there is ample motivation for finding non-state oriented solutions to such problems in l-calculus.)

The recursion in local-fact can be ridded by using the Y combinator. However, in the my-even? and my-odd? example the Y trick doesn’t work because in trying to eliminate recursion using Y, the mutual nature of the functions causes us to get into a chicken-before-the-egg dilemma.

It’s clear we need a special kind of Y for this situation. Let’s call it Y2.

The pass-fact trick

[vanMeule May 92] derived the Y combinator in the style of [Gabriel 88] by starting with pass-fact (a version of the factorial function which avoids recursion by passing its own definition as an argument) and massaging it into two parts: a recursionless recursion mechanism and an abstracted version of the factorial function.

Let’s try the same trick for Y2, using my-even? and my-odd? as our starting point.

First, we want to massage my-even? and my-odd? into something that looks like pass-fact. Here’s what our “template” looks like:

; 5 

>>> (define pass-fact 
      (lambda (f n)
        (if (zero? n)
            1 
            (* n (f f (1- n))))))
pass-fact
>>> (pass-fact pass-fact 5)
120

Here’s a version of my-even? and my-odd? modeled after the pass-fact “template”.

; 6 
>>> (define even-odd
      (cons 
       (lambda (function-list)
         (lambda (n)
           (if (zero? n)
               #t
               (((cdr function-list) function-list)
                (1- n)))))
       (lambda (function-list)
         (lambda (n)
           (if (zero? n)
               #f
               (((car function-list) function-list) 
                (1- n)))))))
even-odd
>>> (define pass-even?
      ((car even-odd) even-odd))
pass-even?
>>> (define pass-odd?
      ((cdr even-odd) even-odd))
pass-odd?
>>> (pass-even? 8)
#t

This could derive one crazy!

Now that we know we can use higher order functions to get rid of the mutual recursion in my-even? and my-odd? the next step is to massage out the recursionless mutual recursion mechanism from the definitional parts that came from my-even? and my-odd?. The following is the code of such a derivation, including test cases and comments.

; 7
(define my-even?
  (lambda (n)
    (if (zero? n)
        #t
        (my-odd? (1- n)))))
;
(define my-odd?
  (lambda (n)
    (if (zero? n)
        #f
        (my-even? (1- n)))))
;
(my-even? 5)
;
; Get out of global environment-use local environment.
;
(define mutual-even?
  (letrec 
    ((my-even? (lambda (n)
                 (if (zero? n)
                     #t
                     (my-odd? (1- n)))))
     (my-odd? (lambda (n)
                (if (zero? n)
                    #f
                    (my-even? (1- n))))))
    my-even?))
;
(mutual-even? 5)
;
; Get rid of destructive letrec.  Use let instead.
; Make a list of the mutually recursive functions.
;
(define mutual-even?
  (lambda (n)
    (let 
      ((function-list 
        (cons (lambda (functions n) ; even?
                (if (zero? n)
                    #t
                    ((cdr functions) functions 
                                     (1- n))))
              (lambda (functions n) ; odd?
                (if (zero? n)
                    #f
                    ((car functions) functions 
                                     (1- n)))))))
      ((car function-list) function-list n))))
;
(mutual-even? 5)
;
; Curry, and get rid of initial (lambda (n) ...) .
;
(define mutual-even?
  (let 
    ((function-list 
      (cons (lambda (functions) ; even?
              (lambda (n) 
                (if (zero? n)
                    #t
                    (((cdr functions) functions) 
                     (1- n)))))
            (lambda (functions) ; odd?
              (lambda (n) 
                (if (zero? n)
                    #f
                    (((car functions) functions) 
                     (1- n))))))))
    ((car function-list) function-list)))
;
(mutual-even? 5)
;
; Abstract ((cdr functions) functions) out of if, etc..
;
(define mutual-even?
  (let 
    ((function-list 
      (cons (lambda (functions) 
              (lambda (n) 
                ((lambda (f)
                   (if (zero? n)
                       #t
                       (f (1- n))))
                 ((cdr functions) functions))))
            (lambda (functions) 
              (lambda (n) 
                ((lambda (f)
                   (if (zero? n)
                       #f
                       (f (1- n))))
                 ((car functions) functions)))))))
    ((car function-list) function-list)))
;
(mutual-even? 5)
;
; Massage functions into abstracted versions of 
; originals.
;
(define mutual-even?
  (let 
    ((function-list 
      (cons (lambda (functions) 
              (lambda (n) 
                (((lambda (f)
                    (lambda (n)
                      (if (zero? n)
                          #t
                          (f (1- n)))))
                  ((cdr functions) functions))
                 n)))
            (lambda (functions) 
              (lambda (n) 
                (((lambda (f)
                    (lambda (n)
                      (if (zero? n)
                          #f
                          (f (1- n)))))
                  ((car functions) functions))
                 n))))))
    ((car function-list) function-list)))
;
(mutual-even? 5)
;
; Separate abstracted functions out from recursive 
; mechanism.
;
(define mutual-even?
  (let 
    ((abstracted-functions
      (cons (lambda (f)
              (lambda (n)
                (if (zero? n)
                    #t
                    (f (1- n)))))
            (lambda (f)
              (lambda (n)
                (if (zero? n)
                    #f
                    (f (1- n))))))))
    (let 
      ((function-list 
        (cons (lambda (functions) 
                (lambda (n) 
                  (((car abstracted-functions)
                    ((cdr functions) functions))
                   n)))
              (lambda (functions) 
                (lambda (n) 
                  (((cdr abstracted-functions)
                    ((car functions) functions))
                   n))))))
      ((car function-list) function-list))))
;
(mutual-even? 5)
;
; Abstract out variable abstracted-functions in 2nd let.
;
(define mutual-even?
  (let 
    ((abstracted-functions
      (cons (lambda (f)
              (lambda (n)
                (if (zero? n)
                    #t
                    (f (1- n)))))
            (lambda (f)
              (lambda (n)
                (if (zero? n)
                    #f
                    (f (1- n))))))))
    ((lambda (abstracted-functions)
       (let 
         ((function-list 
           (cons (lambda (functions) 
                   (lambda (n) 
                     (((car abstracted-functions)
                       ((cdr functions) functions))
                      n)))
                 (lambda (functions) 
                   (lambda (n) 
                     (((cdr abstracted-functions)
                       ((car functions) functions))
                      n))))))
         ((car function-list) function-list)))
     abstracted-functions)))
;
(mutual-even? 5)
;
; Separate recursion mechanism into separate function.
;
(define y2
  (lambda (abstracted-functions)
    (let 
      ((function-list 
        (cons (lambda (functions) 
                (lambda (n) 
                  (((car abstracted-functions)
                    ((cdr functions) functions))
                   n)))
              (lambda (functions)
                (lambda (n) 
                  (((cdr abstracted-functions)
                    ((car functions) functions))
                   n))))))
      ((car function-list) function-list))))
;
(define mutual-even? 
  (y2
   (cons (lambda (f)
           (lambda (n)
             (if (zero? n)
                 #t
                 (f (1- n)))))
         (lambda (f)
           (lambda (n)
             (if (zero? n)
                 #f
                 (f (1- n))))))))
;
(mutual-even? 5)
;
; y2 has selector built into it-generalize it!
;
(define y2-choose
  (lambda (abstracted-functions)
    (lambda (selector)
      (let 
        ((function-list 
          (cons (lambda (functions) 
                  (lambda (n) 
                    (((car abstracted-functions)
                      ((cdr functions) functions))
                     n)))
                (lambda (functions)
                  (lambda (n) 
                    (((cdr abstracted-functions)
                      ((car functions) functions))
                     n))))))
        ((selector function-list) function-list)))))
;
; Now we can achieve the desired result-defining 
; both mutual-even? and mutual-odd? without recursion.
;
(define mutual-even-odd?
  (y2-choose
   (cons (lambda (f)
           (lambda (n)
             (if (zero? n)
                 #t
                 (f (1- n)))))
         (lambda (f)
           (lambda (n)
             (if (zero? n)
                 #f
                 (f (1- n))))))))
;
(define mutual-even? 
  (mutual-even-odd? car))
;
(define mutual-odd?
  (mutual-even-odd? cdr))  
;
(mutual-even? 5)
(mutual-odd? 5)
(mutual-even? 4)
(mutual-odd? 4)

Deriving Mutual Satisfaction

Notice that mutual-even? and mutual-odd? could have been defined using y2 instead of y2-choose, however, the definitional bodies of my-even? and my-odd? would have been repeated in defining mutual-even? and mutual-odd?.

Exercises for the Reader

• Herein Y2 was derived from mutual-even?. Try deriving it instead from pass-even?.

• Question for the Überprogrammer: if evaluation were normal order rather than applicative order, could we use the same version of Y for mutually recursive functions that we used for “regular” recursive functions (thus making a Y2 function unnecessary)?

• Another question: Let’s say we have 3 or more functions which are mutually recursive. What do we need to handle this situation when evaluation is applicative order? What about in normal order? (Note: evaluation in l-calculus is normal order.)

Looking Ahead

Creating a “minimalist” (i.e., combinator based) metacircular interpreter might now be possible if we can tackle the problem of manipulating state!

Thanks to:

The local great horned owls that watch over everything from on high; regularly letting fellow “night owls” know that all is well by bellowing their calming, reassuring “Who-w-h-o-o” sounds.

Bugs/infelicities due to: burning too much midnite oil!

Bibliography and References

[CR 91] William Clinger and Jonathan Rees (editors). “Revised4 Report on the Algorithmic Language Scheme”, LISP Pointers, SIGPLAN Special Interest Publication on LISP, Volume IV, Number 3, July-September, 1991. ACM Press.

[Gabriel 88] Richard P. Gabriel. “The Why of Y”, LISP Pointers, Vol. II, Number 2, October-November-December, 1988.

[vanMeule May 91] André van Meulebrouck. “A Calculus for the Algebraic-like Manipulation of Computer Code” (Lambda Calculus), MacTutor, Anaheim, CA, May 1991.

[vanMeule Jun 91] André van Meulebrouck. “Going Back to Church” (Church numerals.), MacTutor, Anaheim, CA, June 1991.

[vanMeule May 92] André van Meulebrouck. “Deriving Miss Daze Y”, (Deriving Y), MacTutor, Los Angeles, CA, April/May 1992.

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Can PokeMatch help you find love with Po...
The unofficial Pokemon GO companion app space has exploded almost as fast as the game itself over the last few weeks. Aspiring app developers, many of them working solo, have given us apps that locate Pokemon, keep track of the server status, and... | Read more »
How to get started with Prisma
If there's one thing people like to do more than taking pictures with their smartphones, it's tinkering with those photos in some way. Numerous apps have sprung up over the last several years that allow you to use filters and special effects to... | Read more »
6 Pokemon GO updates you can expect, acc...
Pokemon GO had a scheduled appearance at this year's San Diego Comic-Con for a while, but it was only relatively close to the show that it was upgraded to a spot in Hall H. That's the biggest venue at SDCC, one usually reserved for the largest... | Read more »
How to evolve Eevee in Pokemon GO
By now, almost everyone should be hip to how to evolve Pokemon in Pokemon GO (and if not, there's a guide for that). Just gather enough candy of the appropriate type, feed them all to the Pokemon, and evolution happens. It's a miracle that would... | Read more »
CSR Racing 2: Guide to all game modes
It might not seem like there are all that many ways to go fast in a straight line, but CSR Racing 2 begs to differ. [Read more] | Read more »
Bulb Boy (Games)
Bulb Boy 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $2.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Multi-award winning 2D point & click horror adventure about a boy with a glowing head. | Read more »
5 top free emoji keyboard apps
If we're not at peak emoji yet as a society, it feels like we definitely should be. The emoji concept has gone far beyond what anyone in Japan could have envisioned when the people there unleashed it on an unsuspecting world, but the West has... | Read more »
How to unlock more characters in Disney...
One of the big charms of Disney Emoji Blitz is seeing a wide variety of beloved Disney and Pixar characters transformed into smiling emojis. Even someone like the sneaky Randall from Monsters Inc., who probably never cracked a smile on film, is... | Read more »
Cubway (Games)
Cubway 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $1.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Cubway is a journey with an abstract story of lifecycle of rebirth, called Samsara. Guide the cube through the long way full of dangers... | Read more »
Colorcube (Games)
Colorcube 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $1.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Turn pieces and blend colours in this minimal yet visually stunning puzzler.Over 200 handcrafted and challenging levels. Features... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

External Keyboard Innovations For iPad Pro (1...
I’m an input device aficionado. With non-touchscreen computers, which includes all Macs, the keyboard and mouse or trackpad are the tactile points of interface between user and machine, and the... Read more
GSK Rheumatoid Arthritis Study Leverages iPho...
Global healthcare products company GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) says that since 2014 they have begun transforming the way they conduct research, by leveraging state-of-the-art digital technologies — a... Read more
Clearance 12-inch Retina MacBooks, Apple refu...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 2015 12″ Retina MacBooks available starting at $929. Apple will include a standard one-year warranty with each MacBook, and shipping is free. The following... Read more
13-inch Retina MacBook Pros on sale for up to...
B&H Photo has 13″ Retina MacBook Pros on sale for up to $150 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY tax only: - 13″ 2.7GHz/128GB Retina MacBook Pro: $1199 $100 off MSRP - 13″ 2.7GHz/... Read more
13-inch 1.6GHz/128GB MacBook Air on sale for...
Amazon has the 13″ 1.6GHz/128GB MacBook Air on sale for $200 off MSRP for a limited time. Shipping is free: - 13″ 1.6GHz/128GB MacBook Air (sku MMGF2LL/A): $799.99 $200 off MSRP Their price is the... Read more
13-inch 1.6GHz/256GB MacBook Air on sale for...
Amazon has the 13″ 1.6GHz/256GB MacBook Air on sale for $200 off MSRP for a limited time. Shipping is free: - 13″ 1.6GHz/256GB MacBook Air (sku MMGG2LL/A): $999.99 $200 off MSRP Their price is the... Read more
Free iOS Business App notably* Helps Service...
PayStudio Inc. has introduced their new business app notably* 1.0, developed for iPhone and iPod touch. notably* was specifically developed to help service and trade professionals go digital and... Read more
27-inch iMacs on sale for $200 off MSRP
Amazon has 27″ iMacs on sale for $200 off MSRP including free shipping: - 27″ 3.3GHz iMac 5K: $2099 $200 off MSRP - 27″ 3.2GHz/1TB Fusion iMac 5K: $1799.99 $200 off MSRP - 27″ 3.2GHz/1TB HD iMac 5K... Read more
Mac Pros on sale for $200 off MSRP
B&H Photo has Mac Pros on sale for $200 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges sales tax in NY only: - 3.7GHz 4-core Mac Pro: $2799, $200 off MSRP - 3.5GHz 6-core Mac Pro: $3799, $200... Read more
Save up to $600 with Apple refurbished Mac Pr...
Apple has Certified Refurbished Mac Pros available for up to $600 off the cost of new models. An Apple one-year warranty is included with each Mac Pro, and shipping is free. The following... Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions, Willow...
Job Description:SalesSpecialist - Retail Customer Service and SalesTransform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, Read more
*Apple* Evangelist - JAMF Software (United S...
The Apple Evangelist is responsible for building and cultivating strategic relationships with Apple 's small and mid-market business development field teams. This Read more
*Apple* Solutions Consultant - APPLE (United...
Job Summary As an Apple Solutions Consultant, you'll be the link between our future customers and our products. You'll showcase your entrepreneurial spirit as you Read more
*Apple* Professional Learning Specialist - A...
Job Summary The Apple Professional Learning Specialist is a full-time position for one year with Apple in the Phoenix, AZ area. This position requires a high Read more
*Apple* Picker - Apple Hill Orchard (United...
Apple Hill Orchard, Co. Rte. 21,Whitehall, NY 9/7/16-10/228/16. Pick fresh market or processing apples Productivity of 60 boxes and 80 boxes processing fruit per Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.