TweetFollow Us on Twitter

FORTRAN Accuracy
Volume Number:8
Issue Number:5
Column Tag:Jörg's Folder

Accuracy & Speed in FORTRAN Compilers

MacFortran II compared with Language Systems Fortran on the Quadra.

By Jörg Langowski, MacTutor Regular Contributing Author

Note: Source code files accompanying article are located on MacTech CD-ROM or source code disks.

Absoft has recently announced MacFORTRAN II version 3.1, which is supposed to run very fast on Quadras. Since I reviewed Language Systems Fortran not long ago, I was curious how big the speed difference between these two compilers really was. So again, I went back to my benchmark programs. Two of them are (in)famous: the Whetstone benchmark, which tests primarily integer arithmetic and depends a lot on the efficiency of subroutine calling, because it works by calling lots of small routines repeatedly from a loop; and the Linpack, which tests the efficiency of floating point matrix operations using a package of linear algebra routines which are quite useful by themselves.

Furthermore, I found a third useful program between the demos included on the LS Fortran diskettes: it is called Paranoia (mentioned already in V8#1), and checks the consistency of the floating point arithmetic. Things are checked like whether 3*4 equals 4*3, 1+0 =1, 1*0 = 0 etc. These may seem trivial to you, but as you will see, they aren’t when you are dealing with Fortran compilers.

Numerical accuracy tests

I’d like to describe the Paranoia benchmark first, and its results on the two Fortran compilers. The program was original written in Basic and then ported to Fortran; the person who was responsible for the version I used is Richard Karpinski at the Computer Center of the University of California (San Francisco, CA 94143-0704). His description of the program follows:

===== PARANOIA =====

A test program that evaluates the quality of a numerics environment. Note that numerics quality depends on the compiler used as well as the underlying system hardware and software.

Paranoia is a rather large program, devised by Prof. Kahan of Berkeley, to explore the floating point system on your computer. These files are being redistributed as encouraged in the note copied below.

Paranoia.f single precision Fortran, 29 Jan. 1986

Dear Fellow Paranoid,

We ask:

1. Please distribute these programs as widely as you like. Be sure to include as much help as possible. Please include these requests as well.

2. Please let me know if you can provide it on other media. Other potential users may be saved from retyping 2500 lines of code if you can provide the programs on a Whizbang 200 disk/tape/notched-stick. It is reasonable to ask money for this.

3. PLEASE let me know about any source changes that you made to make Paranoia work on your system. The exact model/version/date of your system is quite important in order to understand the changes. If you send the new version, please indicate where the changes occur. Machine readable is preferred.

4. Please send me your results. Note which version of Paranoia gave the results and what machine/language model/version etc. they apply to.

5. Suggestions and comments are always welcome.

Thank you for participating in this unique investigation of contemporary floating-point arithmetic. Your help is vital to the project.

Yours truly,

Richard Karpinski

Modula Assured Quality Software, 6521 Raymond Street

Oakland, CA 94609

ps: Send a stamped, self addressed envelope to the above address to get a sheet on the current status of the project at any time.

The program is too long to print here (104 K, enclosed in compressed form on the source code disk). Just to give you a feeling for what it does, here are some typical lines of code:

C... LOOK FOR SOME OBVIOUS MISTAKES
 IF (0.0E0+0.0E0 .EQ. 0.0E0 .AND.
     1     1.0E0-1.0E0 .EQ. 0.0E0 .AND.
     1     1.0E0       .GT. 0.0E0 .AND.
     1     1.0E0+1.0E0 .EQ. 2.0E0) GOTO 930
 FAILS=FAILS+1
 WRITE(OUT,920)
920FORMAT(‘ FAILURE: violation of  0+0=0  or  1-1=0  or  
     1  1>0  or 1+1 = 2.’)

You wouldn’t believe that these expressions could be evaluated the wrong way, but there must be a reason why these tests are done

Less obvious are some other mistakes that are tested by Paranoia. For instance, the basic arithmetic operations should carry some ‘guard digits’, that is, some more digits that are the representation of the floating point number in memory. Also, they should be correctly rounded in a way that doesn’t introduce inconsistencies. It is not trivial to design floating point arithmetic in such a way that roundoff errors do not affect the consistency of the result. This is seen when the Paranoia benchmark is compiled with the Language Systems (v3.0) and Absoft (v3.1.2) compilers, using various settings of the optimizations and other options.

First, the code produced by the Language Systems compiler, at any optimization level, does not produce any error messages at all, so the arithmetic seems to behave in a consistent way. The rounding conforms to the IEEE p754 standard.

Compiling the benchmark with Absoft MacFortran 3.1.2, with and without the basic optimizations, produces a lot of error messages, like these:

(1-u1)-1/2 < 1/2 is false, so this program may malfunction.

Multiplication lacks a guard digit violating 1*x = x .

Division lacks a guard digit violating x/1 = x .

Computed value of 1/1.00...001 is not less than 1 .

The errors are typical of floating point implementations where roundoff is not handled correctly; it seems to be mainly due to the fact that Absoft tries to keep intermediate values in registers as long as possible. These errors are not as serious as they look, since they are mainly deviations of one unit in the last significant digit of the single-precision numbers used in the test. Some of the error messages are actually a consequence of the fact that the program computes the machine precision at the beginning, from the minimum distance of two floating point numbers close to 1.0. The Absoft-optimized code without any further options comes up with a much too small value for this distance, and therefore some later tests, where this machine precision is used, report errors as well.

All these considerations may seem quite academic to you, because we’re really dealing with very small differences between the computed and the ‘true’ result, of the order of 10-8 or so. But problems where the precise computation of a small difference between two large numbers is important are not that rare, and in those cases such errors will quickly blow up. It is for this reason that the IEEE standard for floating point arithmetic has been developed, and that Apple has implemented the SANE package which follows the IEEE proposal.

There is a remedy, however: one can force the Absoft compiler (with the -e option) to use extended precision in all subexpression calculations, and store values to memory from the registers and re-load them after every assignment. That seems to make the Paranoia benchmark work correctly, and - almost - no more errors are reported. Only now, there are some numbers x and y where x*y is not equal to y*x! (See listing - I reprinted the part of the Paranoia benchmark that reported the error). The only way around this error, and the way to make the benchmark run in a fully consistent fashion, is to compile the code non-optimized and with the -e option. In this case, however, Absoft MacFortran loses all its speed advantage over Language Systems Fortran.

Speed tests with Whetstone and Linpack

To compare the speed figures for the Whetstone and Linpack benchmarks, we should therefore use the Absoft compiler at least with the -e option, and maybe also drop the optimizations. Since now both LSF and ABF compilers exist in versions that support 68040 code, I’ve compared the benchmarks both on a Mac IIx and on a Quadra 700. LSF was always run at the highest optimization level, since the arithmetic seems to be OK at that level; for Absoft, I used the basic optimizations (-O) with and without the extended precision option (-e).

Linpack (single precision)

LSF 030/882 code (Mac IIx) 0.12 MFlops

(Quadra 700) 1.32 MFlops

LSF 040 code (Quadra 700) 1.37 MFlops

ABF 030/882 code -O (Quadra 700) 1.30 MFlops

ABF 030/882 code -O -e (Quadra 700) 1.27 MFlops

ABF 040 code -O (Quadra 700) 1.60 MFlops

ABF 040 code -O -e (Quadra 700) 1.58 MFlops

Whetstone (single precision)

LSF 030/882 code (Mac IIx) 974 K

(Quadra 700) 3976 K

LSF 040 code (Quadra 700) 3984 K

ABF 030/882 code -O (Mac IIx) 1215 K

ABF 030/882 code -O -e (Mac IIx) 955 K

ABF 030/882 code -O (Quadra 700) 4051 K

ABF 030/882 code -O -e (Quadra 700) 3829 K

ABF 040 code -O (Quadra 700) 5864 K

ABF 040 code -O -e (Quadra 700) 5381 K

The essence of these figures is that there is no significant execution speed difference between Absoft and Language Systems Fortran on a Mac IIx, if you make sure that both generate arithmetically consistent code. On the Quadra, however, the fact shows up that Language Systems really creates almost the same code for 68030 and 68040 systems; no additional speed is gained using the -68040 option, while Absoft gains 24% on the Linpack benchmark and 40% on the Whetstone benchmark when 68040 code generation is switched on. All in all, Absoft code on the Quadra is 15% faster than LSF code for the Linpack and 35% for the Whetstone benchmark.

If you are running Fortran on anything other than a Quadra, LSF is really the only choice, given its excellent support of the Macintosh user interface, System 7 features such as AppleEvents, 100% VAX compatibility going into such details as the syntax of I/O statements, and its documentation. For pure numeric performance on a Quadra, Absoft still features faster execution. Still, I’d like to see Absoft’s ‘threaded math library’ for the 68040 incorporated into LSF; that would be my dream system.

Forth news

For the Forth readers of this column, I recently got news from the creators of two of the best public domain Forth development systems for the Macintosh. You read in MacTutor, Vol. 8, No. 4, August 1992 issue about the update of Mops (2.1), the object-oriented Forth implemented by Michael Hore. He now sent me the tutorial that he is distributing together with Mops, a 340K Microsoft Word file.

I’m not going to print the Mops Tutorial here, obviously. But if you need it and don’t find it on any of the obvious sources (ftp from oddjob.uchicago.edu or sumex-aim.stanford.edu), drop me some bytes at langowski@frembl.bitnet and I’ll be happy to mail the file to you.

Another message came from Chris Heilman, who created Pocket Forth:

From: N%”heilman@PC.bitnet”

To: angowski@FREMBL51.bitnet

CC:

Subj: Apple Events in Pocket Forth

Joerg:

Hello again. How have things been going for you? I read your latest article in MacTutor’s June (congrats by the way on getting it back together) about Apple Events in LS fortran. I’ve been working along exactly those lines.

Just two weeks ago I completed and released Pocket Forth 6. While release 5 was capable of handling high-level events, PF6 makes it easy and fun. Two new words, AE: and ;AE are used to define event handlers. Another word, ,S takes a 4 character token from the input stream and puts a 32 bit number on the stack. Use them like this:

  ,s misc ,s dosc AE: blah, blah blah, .... ;AE

This installs the dosc event handler into a list. The dictionary is then saved. The next time the program starts, it handles dosc events. Of course the four required events are handled automatically, but their actions can be changed at any time.

But wait, that’s not all! I’ve added SANE floating point for any numeric token with an ‘E’ or decimal point, new icons, drag&drop file loading and a rewritten manual in TeachText format.

I’d like to send you a copy, so expect a disk soon. I’d email a copy to you, but our system has been choking on loooong mail lately, and I’ve gotten real frustrated sending 200K files 3 or 4 times at 2400 bps.

Later, Chris Heilman

I’m looking forward to seeing the new version of Pocket Forth. Expect some lines in this column when I’ve reviewed it.

Example: check if multiplication commutes

C
Cvery short main program
C
 CALL COMMUT(20)
 PAUSE
 END
C
C
 SUBROUTINE COMMUT( NUMTRY)
C
 Implicit None
 
 INTEGER  DEFECT
 REAL   ULPPLS, ULPMIN

 REAL FP0, FP1, FP2, FP3, HALF
C
 INTEGER NUMTRY
 REAL R9, X, X9, Y, Y9, Z, Z9
 INTEGER I, NN
C

 FP0 = 0
 FP1 = 1
 FP2 = FP1+FP1
 FP3 = FP2+FP1
 HALF = FP1 / FP2
 ULPMIN = 5.96046440E-08
 ULPPLS = 2.0*ULPMIN
 
2920  WRITE(*,2921) NUMTRY
2921  FORMAT(/’ Does multiplication commute?’,
     1   ‘ Testing if  x*y = y*x  for’, I4,’ random pairs:’)
2930  R9 =  SQRT(FP3)
 I = NUMTRY + 1
 X9 = FP0 / FP3
2960  CALL RANDOM (X, Y, X9, R9)
 Y9=X9
 CALL RANDOM (X, Y, X9, R9)
 Z=X9*Y9
 Y=Y9*X9
 Z9=Z-Y
 I=I-1
 IF (I .GT. 0 .AND. Z9 .EQ. FP0) GOTO 2960
2970  IF (I .GT. 0) GOTO 3000
2980  X9=FP0+HALF/FP3
 Y9=(ULPPLS+ULPMIN)+FP0
 Z=X9*Y9
 Y=Y9*X9
 Z9=(FP0+HALF/FP3)*((ULPPLS+ULPMIN)+FP0)
     1 -((ULPPLS+ULPMIN)+FP0)*(FP0+HALF/FP3)
 IF (Z9 .NE. FP0) GOTO 3000
 WRITE(*,2990) NUMTRY
2990  FORMAT(‘ No failure found in ‘,I4,’ randomly chosen pairs.’)
 RETURN
3000  DEFECT=DEFECT+1
 WRITE(*, 3001) X9, Y9
 WRITE(*, 3002) Z, Y, Z9
 NN=NUMTRY-I+1
 WRITE(*, 3003) NN
3001  FORMAT(‘ DEFECT:  x*y = y*x  violated at  x = ‘,E15.7,’, y = ‘,
     1 E15.7)
3002  FORMAT(‘  x*y =’,E15.7,’,  y*x =’,E15.7,’,  x*y-y*x =’,E15.7)
3003  FORMAT(‘    ... pair no.’, I4)
 RETURN
 END
C--
 SUBROUTINE RANDOM (X, Y, X9, R9)
 REAL X, Y, X9, R9
2950  X=X9+R9
 Y=X*X
 Y=Y*Y
 X=X*Y
 Y=X-AINT(X)
 X9=Y+X*.000005
 RETURN
 END

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Ember 1.8.3 - Versatile digital scrapboo...
Ember (formerly LittleSnapper) is your digital scrapbook of things that inspire you: websites, photos, apps or other things. Just drag in images that you want to keep, organize them into relevant... Read more
Apple iTunes 12.1 - Manage your music, m...
Apple iTunes lets you organize and play digital music and video on your computer. It can automatically download new music, app, and book purchases across all your devices and computers. And it's a... Read more
LibreOffice 4.4.3 - Free, open-source of...
LibreOffice is an office suite (word processor, spreadsheet, presentations, drawing tool) compatible with other major office suites. The Document Foundation is coordinating development and... Read more
FoldersSynchronizer 4.2.1 - Synchronize...
FoldersSynchronizer is a popular and useful utility that synchronizes and backs-up files, folders, disks and boot disks. On each session you can apply special options like Timers, Multiple Folders,... Read more
Simon 4.0.2 - Monitor changes and crashe...
Simon monitors websites and alerts you of crashes and changes. Select pages to monitor, choose your alert options, and customize your settings. Simon does the rest. Keep a watchful eye on your... Read more
Cocktail 8.1.2 - General maintenance and...
Cocktail is a general purpose utility for OS X that lets you clean, repair and optimize your Mac. It is a powerful digital toolset that helps hundreds of thousands of Mac users around the world get... Read more
Cyberduck 4.6.4 - FTP and SFTP browser....
Cyberduck is a robust FTP/FTP-TLS/SFTP browser for the Mac whose lack of visual clutter and cleverly intuitive features make it easy to use. Support for external editors and system technologies such... Read more
Herald 5.0.2 - Notification plugin for M...
Note: Versions 2.1.3 (for OS X 10.7), 3.0.6 (for OS X 10.8), and 4.0.8 (for OS X 10.9) are no longer supported by the developer. Herald is a notification plugin for Mail.app, Apple's Mac OS X email... Read more
DEVONthink Pro 2.8.3 - Knowledge base, i...
Save 10% with our exclusive coupon code: MACUPDATE10 DEVONthink Pro is your essential assistant for today's world, where almost everything is digital. From shopping receipts to important research... Read more
Boom 2 1.0.1 - System-wide pro audio app...
Boom 2 is a system-wide volume booster and equalizer app that is designed especially for OS X 10.10 Yosemite. It comes with a smart interface, self-calibrates itself according to your Mac, offers... Read more

Storm the Halls of Echo Base in First St...
Storm the Halls of Echo Base in First Star Wars: Galactic Defense Event Posted by Jessica Fisher on January 30th, 2015 [ permalink ] Universal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad | Read more »
Contradiction Review
Contradiction Review By Tre Lawrence on January 30th, 2015 Our Rating: :: SPOT THE LIEiPad Only App - Designed for the iPad Contradiction is a live action point and click adventure that’s pretty engaging.   Developer: Tim Follin... | Read more »
Unlock Sunshine Girl in Ironkill with th...
Unlock Sunshine Girl in Ironkill with this special 148Apps code Posted by Rob Rich on January 29th, 2015 [ permalink ] Robo-fighter Ironkill has been out on iOS a | Read more »
Crossroad Zombies Review
Crossroad Zombies Review By Jordan Minor on January 29th, 2015 Our Rating: :: CROSSWALKING DEADiPad Only App - Designed for the iPad Crossroad Zombies is a rough draft of a cool genre mash-up.   | Read more »
Blood Brothers 2 – Tips, Cheats, and Str...
War is hell: Is it the kind of hell you want to check out? Read our Blood Brothers 2 review to find out! Blood Brothers 2, DeNA’s follow-up to the original Blood Brothers, is an intriguing card collecting / role-playing / strategy hybrid. There’s... | Read more »
Blood Brothers 2 Review
Blood Brothers 2 Review By Nadia Oxford on January 29th, 2015 Our Rating: :: AN AGGRAVATING RELATIVEUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad Blood Brothers 2 is built on a simple, solid foundation, but its free-to-play system... | Read more »
I AM BREAD, the Toast of the Town, is Ro...
Have you ever dreamt of being deliciously gluten-y? Do you feel passionate about Rye and Wheat? The guys at Bossa Studios do and that is why they are bringing I AM BREAD to iOS soon. The loafy app will feature all the new content that is being... | Read more »
Fahrenheit: Indigo Prophecy Remastered R...
Fahrenheit: Indigo Prophecy Remastered Review By Jennifer Allen on January 29th, 2015 Our Rating: Universal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad 10 years after its initial release and Fahrenheit: Indigo Prophecy still feels like a... | Read more »
Evolve: Hunters Quest is a Match-3 That...
Evolve: Hunters Quest is a Match-3 That Has You Hunting Up Some Big Game. Posted by Jessica Fisher on January 29th, 2015 [ permalink ] | Read more »
Destructamundo Review
Destructamundo Review By Jordan Minor on January 29th, 2015 Our Rating: :: WRECKING CREWUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad Destructamundo blows up real good.   | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

Apple Becomes World’s Largest Smartphone Vend...
According to the latest research data from Strategy Analytics, as global smartphone shipments grew 31 percent annually to reach a record 380 million units in the fourth quarter of 2014. Apple became... Read more
Cut the Cord: OtterBox Resurgence Power Case...
Dead batteries and broken phones are two of the biggest issues for smartphone users today. Otterbox addresses both with the new Resurgence Power Case for Apple iPhone 6, promising to make those panic... Read more
13-inch Retina MacBook Pros on sale for up to...
B&H Photo has 13″ Retina MacBook Pros on sale for $200 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY sales tax only: - 13″ 2.6GHz/128GB Retina MacBook Pro: $1199.99 save $100 - 13″ 2.6GHz/... Read more
15-inch 2.5GHz Retina MacBook Pro on sale for...
 B&H Photo has the 15″ 2.5GHz Retina MacBook Pro on sale for $2319.99 including free shipping plus NY sales tax only. Their price is $180 off MSRP, and it’s the lowest price available for this... Read more
Back in stock: Refurbished iPod nanos for $99...
The Apple Store has Apple Certified Refurbished 16GB iPod nanos available for $99 including free shipping and Apple’s standard one-year warranty. That’s $50 off the cost of new nanos. Most colors are... Read more
Apple lowers price on refurbished 256GB MacBo...
The Apple Store has lowered prices on Apple Certified Refurbished 2014 MacBook Airs with 256GB SSDs, now available for up to $200 off the cost of new models. An Apple one-year warranty is included... Read more
New Good Management Suite Simplifies Enterpri...
Good Technology has announced the availability of the Good Management Suite, a comprehensive cross-platform solution for organizations getting started with mobile business initiatives. Built on the... Read more
15-inch 2.0GHz Retina MacBook Pro (refurbishe...
The Apple Store has Apple Certified Refurbished previous-generation 15″ 2.0GHz Retina MacBook Pros available for $1489 including free shipping plus Apple’s standard one-year warranty. Their price is... Read more
15-inch 2.5GHz Retina MacBook Pro on sale for...
Amazon has the 15″ 2.5GHz Retina MacBook Pro on sale for $2319.99 including free shipping. Their price is $180 off MSRP, and it’s the lowest price available for this model from any reseller. Read more
iPad Turns Five – The ”Book Mystique
Five years ago this week, the late Steve Jobs took the stage at an Apple special press event to unveil the first Apple iPad — a slab-shaped, hand-holdable device that was to shake the personal... Read more

Jobs Board

At-Home Chat Specialist- *Apple* Online Stor...
**Job Summary** At Apple , we believe in hard work, a fun environment, and the kind of creativity and innovation that only comes about when talented people from diverse Read more
SW QA Engineer - *Apple* TV - Apple (United...
**Job Summary** The Apple TV team is looking for experienced Quality Assurance Engineers with a passion for delivering first in class home entertainment solutions. **Key Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions(US) - Ap...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you re also the Read more
*Apple* Systems Engineer - Pre Sales, Educat...
…is responsible for proactively providing technical expertise to drive sales of Apple solutions into assigned accounts. The SE architects, validates, and assists in Read more
*Apple* Solutions Consultant - Retail Sales...
As an ambassador of the Apple brand, the ASC is accountable for driving sales performance by: Connecting with customers. Discovering customers' needs and values. Showing Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.