TweetFollow Us on Twitter

May 93 - Choosing an Object-Oriented Development Toolkit

Choosing an Object-Oriented Development Toolkit

Gary Odom

This article provides suggestions about what to look for when shopping for an object-oriented application development toolkit. The decision is important: you want to make a decision that will be proved right over a period of years. Anything less means a significant loss of investment in both time and money.

Watch Your Language

Choosing an OOP language may seem simple: C++. It does appear that C++ is garnering momentum right now, but rumblings of caution are already appearing from experienced quarters. Mikel Evins at Apple has written (in the Mar/Apr 1993 Frameworks) about experiences with object-oriented languages at Apple's Advanced Technology Group (ATG): "As ATG's ideas and ambitions become more sophisticated, the engineers gradually moved away from Object Pascal and C++. They found themselves... compensating for limitations in expressive power, and working around inappropriate mechanisms for abstraction".

Apple's solution was to develop a new object-oriented dynamic language (OODL), one that incorporated a dynamic object system. What Apple was looking for was "the right combination of OODL features, fast execution, and small object code size".

Object orientation is most often achieved by defining a new object-oriented language, or extending a procedural language to give it object-oriented features. This approach requires a new compiler, and often entails a whole new development environment. A few language extensions have become de facto industry standards as a result of blessing by an ANSI computer languages committee. Among these are C++ and CLOS. Just because it's an industry standard doesn't make it the best: MS-DOS is still the industry-standard operating system. More often, the result is a proprietary language and development environment product bundled together. (Apple's Dylan is a rather unique exception: a language with no product by its creator. Apple seems to have developed a penchant for promoting concepts without product: personal digital assistants (PDAs) are another example.)

An object system can be added to an existing procedural language without changing its syntax. This is done with best effect with languages that have great expressiveness and flexibility, such as Assembly and C (which is really a high-level assembly language). The advantage of an object system that isn't a language (or even a language extension) is that the object system works on any standard compiler for that language, giving a user a choice of development environments.

A dynamic object system allows methods and even inheritance to be defined at run-time. The drawbacks to a dynamic object system have historically been execution speed (necessitated by dynamic definition of inheritance and method attachment) and object code size (from using a memory image as the basis for running an application). Advances in object system design and implementation have resulted in dynamic object systems that can produce fast, tight code.

The right combination of dynamic object-oriented features includes the ability to redefine inheritance chains at run-time, and also define methods to classes, or even objects, at any time during program execution. A thin distinction between classes and objects is also a favorable ingredient. The flexibility of allowing objects to have their own methods and classes to have their own data provides freedom in software design and implementation. The alternative is to have to think of clever ways to do what dynamic definition lets you do in a straightforward way. In other words, if you don't have dynamic definition, you'll eventually be fighting the static language's limitations (although you may not realize it if you don't know any better). As developers gain more experience in working in object-oriented programming, static object systems are increasingly going to look like object-oriented dinosaurs.

A simple example of dynamic inheritance is to read in a dialog item resource for a file, creating dialog item objects, then adding the right class (control, picture, text, etc.) to a dialog item once the item type is discovered (by reading the resource data). This can be done in a static language by not assigning the dialog item type class before reading the dialog item resource definition, but that involves processing in a way dictated by the language's limitations, rather than doing things the way that might first come to mind (which is usually the easiest way) if no constraints were imposed. The flexibility of a dynamic object system brings both small and large benefits.

A major issue with languages is their longevity. You would like to pick a language that is going to be around. Proprietary languages, or languages that are offered only by a single vendor, carry a substantial risk. Large companies abandon products if they don't sell well, or even if they just no longer meet the company's strategic focus. Small companies disappear. There are already some prominent examples of this in the Mac development tools market. There are, no doubt, more to come. If you are considering a proprietary language or environment, consider well the commitment of a vendor to its product (or the company's own long term viability, if you are buying from a small company).

So, besides picking a powerful, flexible object system, you should consider the vendor. Although few vendors offer it, full source code is the only safe bet. That way, you have control over your own development destiny, regardless of its vendor's fortunes or commitment.

Ask vendors you are considering how much source code they offer. If source code is not available, ask whether source code is in escrow ("in the can"), so that customers have access to the source if the company drops the product or goes out of business. That's the worst-case scenario, but if a vendor hasn't considered code in escrow, you know it hasn't really made customer satisfaction a high priority.

The Right Environment

Dynamic development environments may be the wave of the future. With their incremental linkers, THINK C and Pascal have satisfied the Macintosh programming masses for years with their quick turnaround. New dynamic development environments take quick turnaround to a new level: allowing code to be modified and tested without having to exit the application being tested. New code is inserted like brain surgery on-the-fly.

Don't be fooled about the distinction between a dynamic environment and a dynamic object system. While a dynamic environment may look slick, it's no substitute for a dynamic object system. Dynamic environments only boost productivity in the code testing cycle; they do not make a static language dynamic. If you feel you have to make a choice between a dynamic object system and a dynamic environment, an dynamic object system is a better long-term bet. A dynamic object system can let you implement complex code in the most straightforward manner, helping to minimize the debugging phase, which is the only thing a dynamic environment helps you with.

As with choosing a language, consider carefully the risk involved with being tied to a proprietary development environment. Code that has to be extruded to another compiler to build a stand-alone application should be a red flag that the development environment is incomplete. How does one fix a problem that shows up only in the stand-alone application version, but not in the development version?

High Class?

A top-flight class library should provide a full set of services in the following areas: user interface, event handling, data management (the closer to an OODB, the better), and document management. A class library that concentrates on user interface hasn't provided the full set of services you'll need to develop an application.

Judging the quality of a class library before using it is difficult. One rule of thumb is the more features in the fewest number of classes, the better. A class library with hundreds of classes may be an indicator of functional splintering caused by design by committee, or simply too many programmers whacking away without proper coordination. Or it may just be the result of poor design at work.

Another rule of thumb is whether implementation has matched conceptual simplicity. Take, for example, the way events are handled. The simple way to handle a mouse selection, for example, is for the window owner/actor to look at the objects in its window's view(s) to see which is selected. (Visually, an actor has a window; the window has one or more views; each view has objects in the view.) A class library that handles events radically different from the visual hierarchy is a sure sign of poor architecture. A class of bureaucrats, and event handling that requires a supervisor, clearly indicates that the library designer(s) didn't take the simplest route. Complex code is like complex machinery: more moving parts means it's harder to get right, and easier to break.

Memory management is one area where a toolkit can be clearly judged. Macintosh and Windows memory managers were not designed for allocating large numbers of small blocks, which is the case with object orientation. The only solution is a pointer-based memory manager designed for tens of thousands of allocations. Any object-oriented class library that does not have its own memory manager puts you at a terrible speed disadvantage.

Applications built with object orientation don't have to be fat and slow. There are object-oriented application frameworks that produce fast, lean applications. Ask vendors for a demo that has a sample application. Check how fast the demo is, and how big the executable.

Managing Complexity

Besides sprouting like mushrooms, application frameworks are becoming increasingly sophisticated. All too often, sophistication implies complexity. Complexity implies hard to learn and use.

As a result of their complexity, early class libraries have given object orientation a bad reputation as being difficult to use. (Why use a code library that's as hard to learn as the Macintosh Toolbox?) Without some way to manage complexity in the application programming interface (API), that reputation is going to grow.

Polymorphic functions to the rescue. By using the same functions for similar functionality, a class library's API can be minimized. Any application framework should take advantage of function polymorphism to simplify the API. A class library with an enforced API has a great start in the battle of managing complexity.

The ideal, enforced way to minimize an API is through generic functions, where a method can be accessed only through a polymorphic function. (Generic functions are called verb functions by one vendor.) With generic (or verb) functions, each function has methods associated with it, in parallel to the idea that a class has methods associated with it. Object-oriented programming can quickly lose its appeal with an alphabet soup of classes and hundreds or thousands of method names to memorize or constantly reference.

There is another important issue related to application framework complexity. Using objects of any single class can be managed easily. But as objects of different classes interact, understanding or having to deal with these sometimes complex interactions can result in the same kinds of maintenance headaches that occur with procedural programming.

Some superstructure that encapsulates behavior on a large scale should be available in an application framework. This superstructure should allow creation, running, and modification of a subsystem of processing that involves interaction among objects of several classes.

Event processing is a good case in point. A rather ridiculous way to handle event processing is to have an event subclass for every event type, where each subclass has one method to handle one event type. Applying classes to subsystem processing in this way results in inappropriate abstraction. A more intelligent way to handle event processing is to have some enumerated event processing agent, where event handling for an event type can be modified by plugging in a function call or method override. It seems more natural to think of an event agent with plug-ins, rather than a glob of event-specific classes.

Connections

One of the major maintenance problems with procedural programming is that poor modularity causes side effects in making changes in code. Object orientation solves that to such a degree that the inverse problem arises.

By definition, classes have a high degree of modularity: so much so that a major design issue is how best to set up and maintain links between objects. Objects are often linked to other objects. A view keeps track of the objects in the view, for example.

Though few products have it, a well-implemented development toolkit should have a simple, robust mechanism for maintaining object links. Garbage collection, another essential feature of a good class library, should be simply part of object link maintenance.

Platform Independence

A cross-platform class library by necessity must lightly use operating system services. A well-designed class library is much like an elaborated operating system, but with a difference. The Macintosh in particular lacks a high degree of modularity. In the Mac Toolbox, text, controls, and lists are dependent upon a particular window. The Mac OS was not designed for flexible object orientation. The more a class library looks like a translation of the Macintosh Toolbox into an object-oriented format, the less flexible and portable it is.

Controls are a case in point. Macintosh controls must appear in a window that has its top-left coordinate at (0,0). If you try to draw a checkbox or radio button into an offscreen port, or not at (0,0), you get a push button. Don't even try putting Macintosh controls into a scrolled view. Windows controls are child windows. There might be a good reason why a control has to be a window, or tightly bound to one, but it clearly isn't modular software design. The only solution for a decent class library is to implement controls from scratch.

At least one well-known class library is "view-happy", requiring that everything in a view is a subview. A view is a presenter of a collection of objects. So, conceptually, it makes no sense that the picture or icon class (objects of which appear in views) should have to be view subclass. Just because something is object-oriented doesn't mean it is thoughtfully modular. While classes by definition are modular, forced relations between objects of different classes can weaken the modularity of a class library as a whole.

An important question to ask vendors is whether files generated using toolkit code can be read on any supported platform. Platform-independent file generation is an important issue if you are going to be offering multiple platform versions of your product.

A solid cross-platform class library has to be designed for platform independence. It's not something that just happens in implementation. Most frameworks vendors proclaim a readiness to deliver a cross-platform version in the coming months. Approach such claims of vaporware with justified skepticism. Ask vendors how many Toolbox Managers have been used in the core class library. If you hear much more than "menus, windows, and drawing primitives", you know that the product isn't going to be cross-platform in the near future (regardless what the vendor claims).

Support for the Future

Technical support and upgrade track record are two important considerations when choosing a vendor. The ideal is to find a vendor that offers unlimited technical support, and has frequent upgrades to its toolkit.

Unlimited technical support is an expression of confidence on the vendor's part that the code is solid and the documentation is good. Frequent upgrades indicate that the vendor is constantly at work on improvements, and helps prove that the toolkit is amenable to rapid progress. Solid code and good documentation minimize the need for technical support, and make it easy for a vendor to give technical support when asked. A company that charges hundreds of dollars for technical support is a red flag that either: a) the company itself believes the toolkit is hard to learn and use, b) the documentation is inadequate, necessitating a heavy load of technical support, or c) the company is run by bean-counters or vulture capitalists interested in milking the cash cow, and you are the cow!

Getting Married

There are a lot of promises, and some promise, in the OOP toolkit market. There is already a fine array of application development toolkits available, and more coming. Not all will be around in a few years; the market provides the winnowing process.

Choosing a development toolkit is like getting married: it leads to either deepening appreciation or divorce. And divorce can waste months and years of the your life. Choosing a good toolkit can save time and frustration, accelerate application development, and may even widen your software development horizons.

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Path Finder 7.5 - Powerful, award-winnin...
Path Finder makes you a master of file management. Take full control over your file system. Save your time: compare and synchronize folders, view hidden files, use Dual Pane and full keyboard... Read more
Merlin Project 4.2.3 - $349.00
Merlin Project is the leading professional project management software for OS X. If you plan complex projects on your Mac, you won’t get far with a simple list of tasks. Good planning raises... Read more
TextSoap 8.4 - Automate tedious text doc...
TextSoap can automatically remove unwanted characters, fix up messed up carriage returns, and do pretty much anything else that we can think of to text. Save time and effort. Be more productive. Stop... Read more
Smultron 9.4 - Easy-to-use, powerful tex...
Smultron 9 is an elegant and powerful text editor that is easy to use. Use it to create or edit any text document. Everything from a web page, a note or a script to any single piece of text or code.... Read more
QuarkXPress 13.0.0.0 - Desktop publishin...
QuarkXPress 2017 is the new version that raises the bar for design and productivity. With non-destructive graphics and image editing directly within your layout, you no longer have to choose between... Read more
Brackets 1.9.0 - Open Source Web design...
Brackets is an Open-Source editor for Web design and development built on top of Web technologies such as HTML, CSS, and JavaScript. The project was created and is maintained by Adobe, and is... Read more
Audio Hijack 3.3.4 - Record and enhance...
Audio Hijack (was Audio Hijack Pro) drastically changes the way you use audio on your computer, giving you the freedom to listen to audio when you want and how you want. Record and enhance any audio... Read more
Tunnelblick 3.7.1a - GUI for OpenVPN.
Tunnelblick is a free, open source graphic user interface for OpenVPN on OS X. It provides easy control of OpenVPN client and/or server connections. It comes as a ready-to-use application with all... Read more
Amazon Chime 4.3.5721 - Amazon-based com...
Amazon Chime is a communications service that transforms online meetings with a secure, easy-to-use application that you can trust. Amazon Chime works seamlessly across your devices so that you can... Read more
BBEdit 11.6.6 - Powerful text and HTML e...
BBEdit is the leading professional HTML and text editor for the Mac. Specifically crafted in response to the needs of Web authors and software developers, this award-winning product provides a... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Jaipur: A Card Game of Duels (Games)
Jaipur: A Card Game of Duels 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $1.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: ** WARNING: iPad 2, iPad Mini 1 & iPhone 4S are NOT compatible. ** *** Special Launch Price for a limited... | Read more »
Subdivision Infinity (Games)
Subdivision Infinity 1.03 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $2.99, Version: 1.03 (iTunes) Description: Launch sale! 40% Off! Subdivision Infinity is an immersive and pulse pounding sci-fi 3D space shooter. https://www.... | Read more »
Clash of Clans' gets a huge new upd...
Clash of Clans just got a massive new update, and that's not hyperbole. The update easily tacks on a whole new game's worth of content to the hit base building game. In the update, that mysterious boat on the edge of the map has been repaired and... | Read more »
Thimbleweed Park officially headed to iO...
Welp, it's official. Thimbleweed Park will be getting a mobile version. After lots of wondering and speculation, the developers confirmed it today. Thimbleweed Park will be available on both iOS and Android sometime in the near future. There's no... | Read more »
Pokémon GO might be getting legendaries...
The long-awaited legendary Pokémon may soon be coming to Pokémon GO at long last. Data miners have already discovered that the legendary birds, Articuno, Moltres, and Zapdos are already in the game, it’s just a matter of time. [Read more] | Read more »
The best deals on the App Store this wee...
If you’ve got the Monday blues we have just the thing to cheer you up. The week is shaping up to be a spectacular one for sales. We’ve got a bunch of well-loved indie games at discounted prices this week along with a few that are a little more... | Read more »
Honor 8 Pro, a great choice for gamers
Honor is making strides to bring its brand to the forefront of mobile gaming with its latest phone, the Honor 8 Pro. The Pro sets itself apart from its predecessor, the Honor 8, with a host of premium updates that boost the device’s graphical and... | Read more »
The 4 best outdoor adventure apps
Now that we're well into the pleasant, warmer months, it's time to start making the most of the great outdoors. Spring and summer are ideal times for a bit of trekking or exploration. You don't have to go it alone, though. There are plenty of... | Read more »
Things 3 (Productivity)
Things 3 3.0.1 Device: iOS iPhone Category: Productivity Price: $7.99, Version: 3.0.1 (iTunes) Description: Meet the all-new Things! A complete rethinking of the original, award-winning task manager – with a perfect balance between... | Read more »
Oddball mash-up Arkanoid vs Space Invade...
In a move no one was really expecting, Square Enix has put forth an Arkanoid/Space Invaders mash-up aptly titled Arkanoid vs Space Invaders. The game launched today on both iOS and Android and the reviews are actually quite good. [Read more] | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

A Kaby Lake Processor Upgrade For The MacBook...
Now they tell me! Well, actually Apple hasn’t said anything official on the subject, but last week Bloomberg News’s Mark Gurman and Alex Webb cited unnamed “people familiar with the matter”... Read more
Kodak’s Camera-First Smartphone EKTRA Launche...
The Eastman Kodak Company and Bullitt Group have announced the availability of a U.S. GSM version of the KODAK EKTRA Smartphone. The U.S. launch coincides with a software update addressing requests... Read more
Apple Launches App Development Curriculum for...
Apple today launched a new app development curriculum designed for students who want to pursue careers in the fast-growing app economy. The curriculum is available as a free download today from Apple... Read more
Check Apple prices on any device with the iTr...
MacPrices is proud to offer readers a free iOS app (iPhones, iPads, & iPod touch) and Android app (Google Play and Amazon App Store) called iTracx, which allows you to glance at today’s lowest... Read more
9.7-inch 2017 iPad available for $298, save $...
Sams Club has 32GB 9.7″ Apple iPads available for $298 for Sams Club members. That’s $21 off MSRP. Order online and choose free local store pickup (if available) or free shipping. Read more
touchbyte Releases PhotoSync 3.2 for iOS With...
Hamburg, Germany based touchbyte has announced the release of PhotoSync 3.2 for iOS, a major upgrade to the versatile and powerful app to transfer, backup and share photos and videos over the air.... Read more
Emerson Adds Touchscreen Display and Apple Ho...
Emerson has announced the next evolution of its nationally recognized smart thermostat. The new Sensi Touch Wi-Fi Thermostat combines proven smarthome technology with a color touchscreen display and... Read more
SurfPro VPN for Mac Protects Data While Offer...
XwaveSoft has announced announce the release and immediate availability of SurfPro VPN 1.0, their secure VPN client for macOS. SurfPro VPN allows Mac users to protect their internet traffic from... Read more
13-inch Touch Bar MacBook Pros on sale for $1...
B&H Photo has 13″ MacBook Pros in stock today for up to $150 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY & NJ sales tax only: - 13″ 2.9GHz/512GB Touch Bar MacBook Pro Space Gray (... Read more
Tuesday deal: $200 off 27-inch Apple iMacs
Amazon has select 27″ iMacs on sale for $200 off MSRP, each including free shipping: - 27″ 3.3GHz iMac 5K: $2099 $200 off MSRP - 27″ 3.2GHz/1TB Fusion iMac 5K: $1799 $200 off MSRP Keep an eye on our... Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* Mobile Master - Best Buy (United Sta...
**508456BR** **Job Title:** Apple Mobile Master **Location Number:** 000040-Eau Claire-Store **Job Description:** **What does a Best Buy Apple Mobile Master Read more
Director *Apple* ERP Integration Lead - Ast...
…make a real difference. Come, shine with us! Astellas is announcing a Director Apple ERP Integration Lead opportunity in Northbrook, IL. Purpose & Scope: This role Read more
Director *Apple* Platform, IS Data Manageme...
…a real difference. Come, shine with us! Astellas is announcing a Director Apple Platform, IS Data Management Lead opportunity in Northbrook, IL. Purpose & Scope: Read more
Associate Director *Apple* Platform -- SAP...
…real difference. Come, shine with us! Astellas is announcing a Associate Director Apple Platform -- SAP Security, Risks and Controls Lead opportunity in Northbrook, Read more
*Apple* Media Products - Commerce Engineerin...
Apple Media Products - Commerce Engineering Manager Job Number: 57037480 Santa Clara Valley, California, United States Posted: Apr. 18, 2017 Weekly Hours: 40.00 Job Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.