TweetFollow Us on Twitter

March 93 - Reuse Abuse

Reuse Abuse

Jeff Alger and Eric Berdahle

Eric,

    Hmmm, I know it's here somewhere… aha! here on page 89 of the 1999 Sears catalog:

    Abstract Reasoning Class. Through suitable overloading and overriding, can be used to implement any reasoning process in your object-oriented program. One direct slot into which you can insert any information. Three polymorphic methods: Perceive, Cogitate, React. Defaults to no perception, no thinking, no reaction, making it useful as-is for applications such as plug-compatible movie critic replacement. Add $1.95 for next-minute shipping by electronic mail.

    C++ version:        $29.95  PN 975337-1
    Smalltalk version:  $29.95  PN 975337-2
    Lisp version:       ($ 29.95)   ('PN 975337-3)

    Sound absurd? Maybe, but the whole subject of software reuse has gotten out of hand, especially in the object-oriented community. Think about all the hype about "Software ICs," those orderable, plug-in class components of the future. Where's the evidence? What reasons are given, other than cult-like faith, for software engineering as we know it suddenly being reduced to choosing whether to buy from K-Mart or Nieman-Marcus? Have you personally ever talked to someone who has routinely achieved large-scale reuse of object-oriented software components? You wouldn't invest your kids' college fund with someone who used equally flimsy arguments for an investment scheme, and you shouldn't put any more faith in snake oil disguised as reusable ones and zeros.

    Here's the truth: object-oriented software is highly dependent on its context, and most innovative software is innovative precisely because it subtly changes the context.

    The only circumstances in which I have seen widespread reuse have been those in which the context is severely limited. For example, MacApp classes are somewhat reusable because they depend only on the Macintosh operating system, Toolbox, and user interface for context. Smalltalk even carries its context along with it through a portable kernel. This is why it is so easy to find class libraries for graphical user interfaces but not image recognition; data structures but not physical structures; reading and writing files but not parsing complex grammars. In each case, the OO community has rather sensibly gravitated toward the sorts of problems it is collectively well-equipped to solve: problems that are inherently bounded by external factors like operating systems and standards. Sensible, but limited. We cannot extrapolate from that to expect generalized reuse of Employee components from payroll to human resource management to games applications or from a Macintosh graphical user interface to a mainframe database.

    For all the talk about how "natural" the process of object-oriented analysis and design is supposed to be, we really make decisions about how to organize object-oriented programs based on artificial considerations: modularity, maintainability, extensibility, and a variety of other Itys. The process is roughly this: decide what behaviors your software needs to exhibit and what data it needs to contain, then distribute them in a modular fashion that would make your old Software Engineering professor proud. Finally, once the design has taken root, start using names that constitute good metaphors so that the design is easier to understand and explain. That Employee class is not the same as its real-world counterpart; we stole the real-world name "Employee" to leverage a basic human perceptual skill, metaphor. Change the context and the whole basis for the Itys has changed. Move most classes from one context to another and the result is poorly structured software.

    I expect reusability to grow wherever clever people can identify and clearly articulate narrow contexts and stick to them. This will take time, since it requires observing dozens or hundreds of individual cases before patterns emerge. That is where the object-oriented approach itself came from. However, most truly creative works produced by humankind involve deliberately taking things out of their original context, shuffling them together and then solving some new and outrageous problem with the combination. That's the way my kids play with their toys and I think it's true of truly leading-edge software as well. In fact, one might even hope that we don't take software ICs too seriously, since to do so is to constrain through implied contexts the very creative juices on which the industry thrives.

    A final question: who cares? I mean, about generalized software reuse? Programming as a percentage of lifecycle costs is about the size of the period at the end of this sentence and shrinking all the time. Most development costs are in planning, analysis and design, not programming, and most lifecycle costs are in maintenance, not development. If, through reuse, we reduce programming to plug-and-play, it still won't make more than a few percentage points difference in overall software costs. Reuse of analysis and design is, to me, a much more fruitful line of inquiry and one not constrained nearly as much by the peculiar technology we call OOP.

Jeff

Friend Jeff,

    I used to think that the software industry learned something from the Oat Bran Craze of the mid-80's, but recently I have come to realize that it is the other way around. Remember oat bran, the fiber health zealots proclaimed as the answer to life's greatest health mysteries? Every food product in existence found a way to work oat bran into their recipes so that, overnight, we started seeing advertisements for "Chocolate Coated Sugar Bombs-NOW with Oat Bran" as if that somehow made the most toxic food an instant nutritional success. Phooey.

    This mentality is not new to the computer industry. Every time a new language or methodology comes out, they proclaim that this solution provides better reuse than that solution, and the masses flock to the mount. Double phooey. Sure, the mythology of object software is that you get better code reuse, but let's take time to do a careful analysis and see what the reality looks like instead of blindly following the prophet.

    You make a good case for the position that object reuse is primarily due to recycled analysis. Surely, in terms of the software life cycle, analysis and design are the largest pieces of the pie. Thus, it makes sense that any attempt to make that effort recyclable will reap great benefits in terms of shortening subsequent development times. But I think you're being a little short-sighted when you casually push aside programming and development in favor of maintenance and design.

    You ask who cares? Did I fall asleep while the great Jeff Alger took a swan dive into the Twilight Zone? Surely software reuse is more than just a simple cocktail party discussion. In fact, how many developers using a good class library would claim that reuse ala class libraries does not affect time to market? Ask yourself, if you didn't use MacApp for the projects you've developed, would your time to market have been equivalent, longer, or shorter? The veterans of the object community can answer this in their sleep, indicating that there really is something to software reuse that we're not grasping here.

    Your answer to why MacApp classes are reusable is that their context is limited. While this is true, let's see what that really means. Yes, MacApp is a good abstraction of a Macintosh application, concepts that are fairly common to all applications. Yes, it is not a perfect abstraction. This is not an indictment of the concept of reuse, but of the assumptions that went into MacApp design.

    For example, remember the TDocument crisis of MacApp 2.x? In a nutshell, some developers had serious problems because TDocument had assumed that there was one file per document. Since many, but not all, applications had this model, many, but not all, applications lived happily with TDocument 2.x. This was a problem because the assumptions made by the MacApp 2.x design were violated by those multi-file per document apps, a classic case of what you yourself point out as the number one software problem: solving the wrong problem.

    In 3.x there is another problem. Sure, TFileBasedDocument is great for those developers who have 1:1 file:document mapping, but TDocument leaves a lot to be implemented those who don't. Again, this is not an indictment of reuse, but of the design. Essentially, TDocument was not provided with a full framework to support file handling. Instead, there are methods which the developer can use to tap into their own framework.

    But these examples are really edge cases. Overall, MacApp is an excellent example of the potential of object frameworks. Is it a set of software ICs? Of course not. Personally, I believe that the problem with software ICs is that the design of good object frameworks is still not understood as a general concept. Nonetheless, the examples we see each year get closer to the idyllic abstraction of the IC world.

    And what's this tripe about software ICs constraining creativity? I think that good software ICs will only enhance creativity by allowing the developer to concentrate on the very essence of their area of interest. The framework in which the IC lives should provide support all concepts outside the region of interest of the developer. This is the promise of object technology. Using MacApp examples again, MacApp provides quite a bit of support for underlying Macintosh guidelines, file system idiosyncrasies, startup hassles, and event management to name a few. While not nearly perfect, this is still the best thing we've seen yet.

    So where are we today? Reuse of object software isn't perfect, but we've already seen what its early incarnations can provide. And remember that that shrinking development time you quote may be due in large part to the effect of more and more software reuse.

    Don't worry, we'll get there someday.

Highest stirring regards,

Eric

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

RapidWeaver 6.0.8 - Create template-base...
RapidWeaver is a next-generation Web design application to help you easily create professional-looking Web sites in minutes. No knowledge of complex code is required, RapidWeaver will take care of... Read more
Artlantis Studio 5.1.2.7 - 3D rendering...
Artlantis Studio is a unique and ideal tool for performing very high resolution rendering easily and in real time. The new FastRadiosity engine now lets you compute images in radiosity-even in... Read more
MacUpdate Desktop 6.0.5 - Search and ins...
MacUpdate Desktop 6 brings seamless 1-click installs and version updates to your Mac. With a free MacUpdate account and MacUpdate Desktop 6, Mac users can now install almost any Mac app on macupdate.... Read more
BitTorrent Sync 2.0.82 - Sync files secu...
BitTorrent Sync allows you to sync unlimited files between your own devices, or share a folder with friends and family to automatically sync anything. File transfers are encrypted. Your information... Read more
Google Drive 1.20 - File backup and shar...
Google Drive is a place where you can create, share, collaborate, and keep all of your stuff. Whether you're working with a friend on a joint research project, planning a wedding with your fiancé, or... Read more
Simon 4.0.3 - Monitor changes and crashe...
Simon monitors websites and alerts you of crashes and changes. Select pages to monitor, choose your alert options, and customize your settings. Simon does the rest. Keep a watchful eye on your... Read more
Vitamin-R 2.23 - Personal productivity t...
Vitamin-R creates the optimal conditions for your brain to work at its best by structuring your work into short bursts of distraction-free, highly focused activity alternating with opportunities for... Read more
iDefrag 5.0.0 - Disk defragmentation and...
iDefrag helps defragment and optimize your disk for improved performance. Features include: Supports HFS and HFS+ (Mac OS Extended). Supports case sensitive and journaled filesystems. Supports... Read more
PCalc 4.2 - Full-featured scientific cal...
PCalc is a full-featured, scriptable scientific calculator with support for hexadecimal, octal, and binary calculations, as well as an RPN mode, programmable functions, and an extensive set of unit... Read more
FileZilla 3.10.2 - Fast and reliable FTP...
FileZilla (ported from Windows) is a fast and reliable FTP client and server with lots of useful features and an intuitive interface. Version 3.10.2: Note: Now requires a 64-bit Intel processor.... Read more

Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment A...
Warner Bros. has some exciting games coming down the pipe! | Read more »
GDC 2015 – Star Trek Timelines will Prob...
GDC 2015 – Star Trek Timelines will Probably Make Your Inner Trekkie Squeal With Glee Posted by Rob Rich on March 4th, 2015 [ permalink ] Any popular fictional universe has its fair share of fan fiction – where belo | Read more »
Protect Yourself from an Onslaught of Ca...
Surprise Attack Games has announced a Cat-astrophic new physics puzzler called Fort Meow! In the game, a young girl named Nia finds her grandfather’s journal which triggers an all mighty feline attack! Why do the cats want the journal? Who knows,... | Read more »
GDC 2015 – Jelly Reef will be Game Oven’...
GDC 2015 – Jelly Reef will be Game Oven’s Last Hurrah, and it Seems like a Good Note to Go Out on Posted by Rob Rich on March 4th, 2015 [ permalink ] It’s sad knowing that Game Oven ( | Read more »
daWindci Deluxe Review
daWindci Deluxe Review By Campbell Bird on March 4th, 2015 Our Rating: :: BLUSTERY PUZZLESUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad This updated puzzle game offers some creative gameplay and new mechanics, but still suffers from... | Read more »
Dungeon Hunter 5 Coming on March 12
Gameloft has excitedly announced that Dungeon Hunter 5 is on its way! Once again, you will adventure across the land of Valenthia exploring dungeons and fighting monsters. The game will have a new asynchronous multiplayer mode called Strongholds... | Read more »
GDC 2015 – The Sandbox 2 is Coming, and...
GDC 2015 – The Sandbox 2 is Coming, and Now it has Textures! | Read more »
Warner Bros. Interactive Announces Mort...
Mortal Kombat X, by Warner Bros. and NetherRealm Studios, will be a a free-to-play fighting/card-battle Mortal Kombat game. The game promises card collecting, multiplayer team combat, classic characters such as Scorpion, Sub-Zero and Raiden, and the... | Read more »
GDC 2015 – Piloteer is Whitaker Trebella...
GDC 2015 – Piloteer is Whitaker Trebella’s Latest Project, and it’s Definitely Something DIfferent Posted by Rob Rich on March 3rd, 2015 [ permalink ] You know | Read more »
PangoLand Review
PangoLand Review By Amy Solomon on March 3rd, 2015 Our Rating: :: COME VISIT PANGO AND FRIENDSUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad PangoLand is an open-ended world full of familiar characters, bright colors and interactive... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

iPad: A More Positive Outlook – The ‘Book Mys...
It’s good to hear someone saying positive things about the iPad. I’ve been trying to bend my mind around how Apple’s tablet could have gone from zero to bestselling personal computing device on the... Read more
Mac Pros on sale for up to $279 off MSRP
Amazon has Mac Pros in stock and on sale for up to $279 off MSRP. Shipping is free: - 4-Core Mac Pro: $2725.87, $273 off MSRP (9%) - 6-Core Mac Pro: $3719.99, $279 off MSRP (7%) Read more
Sale! 13-inch Retina MacBook Pros for up to $...
B&H Photo has 13″ Retina MacBook Pros on sale for up to $205 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY sales tax only: - 13″ 2.6GHz/128GB Retina MacBook Pro: $1219.99 save $80 - 13″ 2.... Read more
Another Tranche Of IBM MobileFirst For iOS Ap...
IBM has announced the next expansion phase for  its IBM MobileFirst for iOS portfolio, with a troika of new apps to address key priorities for the Banking and Financial Services, Airline and Retail... Read more
Sale! 15-inch Retina MacBook Pros for up to $...
B&H Photo has the new 2014 15″ Retina MacBook Pros on sale for up to $250 off MSRP for a limited time. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY sales tax only: - 15″ 2.2GHz Retina MacBook Pro: $... Read more
WaterField Designs Introduces the Minimalist...
With Apple Pay gaining popularity, Android Pay coming in May 2015, and loyalty cards and receipts that can be accessed from smartphones, San Francisco’s WaterField Designs observes that it may be... Read more
Sale! 15-inch 2.2GHz Retina MacBook Pro for $...
 Best Buy has the 15″ 2.2GHz Retina MacBook Pro on sale for $1774.99 $1799.99, or $225 off MSRP. Choose free home shipping or free local store pickup (if available). Price valid for online orders... Read more
13-inch 2.5GHz MacBook Pro (refurbished) avai...
The Apple Store has Apple Certified Refurbished 13″ 2.5GHz MacBook Pros available for $170 off the cost of new models. Apple’s one-year warranty is standard, and shipping is free: - 13″ 2.5GHz... Read more
13-inch 2.5GHz MacBook Pro on sale for $100 o...
B&H Photo has the 13″ 2.5GHz MacBook Pro on sale for $999.99 including free shipping plus NY sales tax only. Their price is $100 off MSRP. Read more
27-inch 3.5GHz 5K iMac in stock today and on...
 B&H Photo has the 27″ 3.5GHz 5K iMac in stock today and on sale for $2299 including free shipping plus NY sales tax only. Their price is $200 off MSRP, and it’s the lowest price available for... Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
*Apple* Solutions Consultant - Retail Sales...
**Job Summary** As an Apple Solutions Consultant (ASC) you are the link between our customers and our products. Your role is to drive the Apple business in a retail Read more
Position Opening at *Apple* - Apple (United...
…Summary** As a Specialist, you help create the energy and excitement around Apple products, providing the right solutions and getting products into customers' hands. You Read more
Position Opening at *Apple* - Apple (United...
**Job Summary** The Apple Store is a retail environment like no other - uniquely focused on delivering amazing customer experiences. As an Expert, you introduce people Read more
*Apple* Solutions Consultant - Retail Sales...
**Job Summary** As an Apple Solutions Consultant (ASC) you are the link between our customers and our products. Your role is to drive the Apple business in a retail Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.