TweetFollow Us on Twitter

January 92 - In Transit to MacApp 3

In Transit to MacApp 3

Howard Katz

I've been away from FrameWorks for a few months, but I haven't been away from the Mac and MacApp. I've made a move from Pascal to C in my own programming work-initially, with a lot of trepidation-and I've also done some playing around with beta versions of MacApp 3, pursuant to jumping into C++ with both feet. First, the news…

MacApp 3 final-getting close

According to Tom Chavez, MacApp's product manager at Apple, there are about 125 MacApp 3 beta sites out there, all merrily compiling away on beta number 3, digging up bugs galore. It saddens my heart to tell you this, but yes-there are bugs, though the number is diminishing with each successive beta release.

As I write, beta number 4 will soon go out to the seed list, a few short weeks before Christmas. If schedules hold, the final release of MacApp 3 should be finished and ready to go by the end of January-theoretically, about the time you're reading this. Tom says that even if that happens, though, it's unlikely that the documentation will keep pace with the software development, so you probably won't see a version that APDA can ship on the street before MADA's Orlando conference in February.

Ditto to Jesse

Jesse Feiler wrote a nice little piece for the last FrameWorks on his experiences in moving from MacApp 2 and Object Pascal to MacApp 3 and C++. I suspect the information that Jesse provided will be helpful for other developers who are going to be making the same move. It was for me.

In getting ready to move into C++, I've just made a similar though smaller transition of my own-from Pascal to C. I can strongly echo at least one of Jesse's sentiments-if you're going to make the language jump, dive right in. Stop reading about the language, just do it.

I had a lot of trepidation before making the move, and about one anxious week of trying to figure out what things weren't working and why. But that was it; it was relatively painless.

I spent four months on a C language programming project about four years ago, so this wasn't my first exposure to the language. But it didn't "take" very well the first time around. This time, for whatever reason, it did. I'm enjoying it.

Mostly bigger, hopefully better

I finally got a copy of MacApp 3 running on my system, though I haven't done anything serious with it yet. I'm still in the MacBrowse exploring stage. As it is, MacApp 3 grunts and wheezes and barely runs on my machine. I've an old, stock standard Mac II. I had to dig into the bank account to upgrade my RAM from 5 to 8 megs to get MacApp 3 to compile at all, and it complains bitterly at that. MacApp 3 development really requires 9 megs, or 8 megs and virtual memory, and that I don't have at the moment.

This seems pretty incredible to me. I can remember-though I'm not sure I want to-compiling MacApp applications on a Plus. Such a thing is no longer within the realm of possibility, even as a thought experiment. The main villain, I'm told, is CFront, which requires-this is no typo-5 megs to run. Great Caesar's ghost!

It seems that just about everything about MacApp 3 is bigger, and that doesn't necessarily mean better. Disk space requirements provide another example. I've got an external 40 meg drive hung off my machine that I use only for occasional programming projects, and amazingly enough, it's too small. I used to do everything on a 40-meg hard drive; now it's not even large enough for MacApp, let alone anything else.

It's easy to see why when you look at the numbers. My MPW folder, little changed from the way it arrived in the mail, is well over 12 meg, and my MacApp folder is over 21. The latter number, on your system, will depend on the number of different versions you need to compile MacApp in. There used to be just two: "Debug" and "NoDebug." There are now a minimum of four, when you factor in whether or not you're supporting System 7. Just my ".NoDebug Files" folder, created by MacApp, is well over 3 megs.

New idioms galore

RAM and disk requirements are a downer, and I haven't even talked about compile times yet. But everything else is peachy-keen. There are new idioms galore. How's the following for a good example of some of the potentially baffling and interesting new things in MacApp 3? This little gem is right out of TObject:
pascal void TObject::UpdateDependents(
                ChangeID theChange,
                TObject* changedObject,
                TObject* changedBy)
{
CDependentIterator iter(this);
for (   TObject* dependent = iter.FirstDependent(); iter.More();
        dependent = iter.NextDependent())
    {
        dependent->HandleUpdate( theChange, changedObject,
            changedBy);
    }
}

Coming into MacApp 3 from an MacApp 2 and Object Pascal background, I count at least five idioms here that are new to me. If you're new to C and object programming in particular, probably everything looks at least slightly bizarre. Even if you're an old and experienced C hand from way back, there are strange things happening here. The three clauses that determine the boundary-condition behavior of the "for" loop, for example, probably look somewhat, well, wrong. And yet, they do make sense-eventually.

How about the declaration "CDependentIterator iter(this)" in the above sample? That's worth at least a few minutes of silent contemplation the first time it's encountered in code. I know what a "T…" class is; what's a "C…" class? Can we all say "stack-based object" in unison? In other words, an object declaration where we really have the object itself, and not an indirect reference to one through either a pointer or a handle.

And what about the parameter the function takes-"this" in the above example? We've all been hearing about constructors; here's one in the flesh.

What else? What's a "CDependentIterator" anyway? Iterators are one thing; dependencies are something else again. The combination of the two is only slightly more potent than the nuclear-powered salsa that took my mouth out of action for two hours yesterday at lunch.

TObject, by the way, is quite a bit more beefed up than what I'm used to from earlier incarnations of MacApp. It's hard to believe this class once had a grand total of four-that's 4-methods, and that they were all we needed. By my count, TObject now has at least 36 methods. MacApp 3's new dependency-notification mechanism accounts for a good number of them.

References to the rescue

I had a few books open next to my machine as I MacBrowsed my way through the MacApp 3 source code. Occasionally I'd venture over to Harbison and Steele, the "official" C language reference manual. I'm told there's a C++ version out as well, but I haven't seen it yet.

Kernighan and Ritchie's "The C Programming Language" is also highly recommended. It's from Prentice Hall. Make sure you pick up the second edition when you go shopping.

I'll put in a plug for one other C++ language reference that I find myself dipping into and out of when I have a few moments to spare, and that's Dan Weston's Elements of C++ Macintosh Programming. Dan's discussion of C++ language features is based around a class library that he develops in the book. In many respects it looks like MacApp-two of the main classes are called "TApp" and "TDoc," respectively. Dan's a MacApp programmer from way back and makes the odd appearance at MacApp conferences. I've been enjoying the book and finding it useful.

I'll be picking up some of the other "great" C++ references over the next few weeks and will try and do some quick reviews in columns to come. In the meantime, I hope you had a good Christmas season and are looking forward to a sunny vacation in Orlando. Florida, watch out!

 
AAPL
$571.63
Apple Inc.
+10.35
MSFT
$29.67
Microsoft Corpora
-0.08
GOOG
$609.12
Google Inc.
-4.99
MacTech Search:
Community Search:

Edit Websites Right on the iPad With Gre...
Coda, the Mac OS X software by Panic for editing websites – and not just HTML code, but CSS and MySQL management, terminal support, and other features for truly managing a website – is coming to the iPad this Thursday along with Coda 2 for Mac. Diet... | Read more »
Avernum: Escape from the Pit HD Review
Avernum: Escape from the Pit HD Review By Kevin Stout on May 22nd, 2012 Our Rating: :: INSTANT CLASSICiPad Only App - Designed for the iPad Avernum: Escape from the Pit HD is a classic-style RPG with turn-based combat on tiles.   | Read more »
Sonos Subwoofer, the SONOSSUB, Revealed
Sonos is easily our favorite app enabled audio solution. And today they announce a new device to make it even better. Adding to the Sonos Play:3 and Play:5, we now have the SONOSSUB. As you may have guessed, a subwoofer. This booming beast looks... | Read more »
Domino! Review
Domino! Review By Jason Wadsworth on May 21st, 2012 Our Rating: :: CLASSIC WITH FRIENDSiPhone App - Designed for the iPhone, compatible with the iPad Play dominoes with friends online in this social gaming title.   Developer:... | Read more »
Juggernaut: Revenge of Sovering Review
Juggernaut: Revenge of Sovering Review By Kevin Stout on May 21st, 2012 Our Rating: :: MINI-GAME-FULUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad Juggernaut: Revenge of Sovering is an RPG with great graphics and Infinity Blade-like... | Read more »
Sheep Up! Review
Sheep Up! Review By Rob Rich on May 21st, 2012 Our Rating: :: BAA-BAA-BOUNCEUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad Who knew something as simple as a change in perspective could make such a big difference?   | Read more »
Uncover the Lost Levels in Where’s My Wa...
Fans of Disney Mobile’s hit game Where’s My Water - both the free and paid version – have a lot to be happy about. Disney just added iCloud support for cross-device game synching, and lots of new levels. | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

MacBook Pros bundled with discounted AppleCare, sa...
MacConnection has MacBook Pros bundled with discounted AppleCare Protection Plans yielding savings up to $180 off full MSRP: - 13″ 2.4GHz MacBook Pro w/AppleCare: $1378.99 MSRP $1448 - 13″ 2.8GHz... Read more
MacBooks up to $200 off at Apple Store for Educati...
Purchase a new MacBook Pro or MacBook Air at The Apple Store for Education and take up to $200 off MSRP. All teachers, students, and staff of any educational institution qualify for the discount.... Read more
AppleCare on sale for up to $105 off MSRP
B&H Photo has AppleCare Protection Plans for Macs on sale for up to $105 off MSRP including free shipping and NY sales tax only: - AppleCare Mac laptops 15″ and above: $244 MSRP $349 - AppleCare... Read more
27″ iMacs on sale for up to $130 off MSRP
  Apple resellers have 27″ iMacs on sale for up to $130 off MSRP. Each model below includes free shipping – B&H charges NY sales tax only, while Adorama charges sales tax in NY and NJ only: - 27... Read more
Apple offers 16GB iPad 2s for $399
The Apple Store is continuing to offer Black and White 16GB WiFi iPad 2s for $399 including free shipping. WiFi+3G models are available for $529. Each is $100 off their original MSRP and $100 less... Read more
Retina Display MacBooks Might Not Be The Best Idea
CNET’s Dan Ackerman suggests persistent rumors that the forthcoming new generation of Apple’s MacBook Pro laptops may fit in the be careful what you wish for category. Citing his CNET colleagues Josh... Read more
Keyboard The Key To iPad Productivity
Amitae blogger Graham K. Rogers says the iPad is a bit of a mystery to him in terms of it being promoted as a full-scale tool for productivity, noting that he tends to do most of his work on a... Read more
Ashton Kutcher Steve Jobs Movie Begins Filming in...
The film chronicling the life of Apple Inc. co-founder and charismatic master of innovation Steve Jobs begins principal photography in June, and in keeping with the project’s commitment to accuracy... Read more

Jobs Board

iOS Developer (iPhone and iPad) at Mahal...
Mahalo is on a mission to help the world quotLearn Anythingquot by creating high quality educational content available on mobile devices. Were looking to disrupt the education industry in a big way.... Read more
iPhone App at Elance.com (Plano, TX)
Create an iPhone App to do the following: 1. Take a picture at a default resolution 2. Identify the location street ... 5. email the picture, address, text notes and voice notes to an email address.... Read more
Iphone/Ipad App Development at Elance.co...
We are in need of an Iphone/Ipad app that will do the following: - Login and provide functionality to our Jomsocial 2.6 ... done ASAP. Job needs to be started quickly. Please provide time estimates... Read more
MAC Imaging/Packaging, Administration at...
Experience - 4 - 7 yrs Good experience in building MAC ( Apple Macintosh ) operating system images. OS imaging ... Knowledge on configuring the LAN and Wireless network on MAC note books Knowledge on... Read more
Mac/window Imaging/Packaging, Administra...
Experience - 4 - 7 yrs Very good experience in building MAC ( Apple Macintosh ) operating system images. OS imaging ... Requirements - 2 Working knowledge / experience on Apple / Mac OS imaging.... Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.