TweetFollow Us on Twitter

August 91 - Re: Segments from Outer Space

Re: Segments from Outer Space

Jeff Alger

Jeff Alger replies to Kent Sandvik's "Children of the DogCow-Segments from outer space", which appeared in the June 1991 issue of FrameWorks.

Kent,

I'm writing to take issue with two things said regarding segmentation vs. VM in your otherwise excellent article on segmentation in the June Frameworks. Just setting the record straight.

First, you mentioned Unix thrashing is due to page after page being loaded as a thread of function calls is followed. As someone who has worked with Unix systems for almost 15 years now, that is the least likely reason for a thrash-and when it does occur, it is a symptom, not the disease. In almost all Unix thrashing, the problem is simply that you are trying to run too many applications with too big a cumulative space requirement at once. If you were using a Mac, you couldn't even make the attempt, so it is poor sportsmanship to knock Unix for at least trying.

The Mac forces you to partition the memory space, with fixed-size allocations per process, while Unix allows the VM hardware to allocate memory across applications as demand shifts. A classic prescription for this kind of thrashing in Unix is to use shared libraries, something that segmentation actually discourages (jump tables are application-specific, as are the memory spaces used to load the segments). In short, Unix does thrash, but only after it has far surpassed the Mac scheme's ability to juggle the same load.

The second thing that I wanted to comment on is your claim that segmentation solves tight memory problems better than VM. If someone at Apple has been able to prove this with real numbers or some sort of statistical model-quick! nominate them for a Turing Award. Maybe he or she can next develop a generalized sorting algorithm with better than n*log(n) performance. If asked, I'll certainly back the nomination.

Humor aside, the only reasons that segmentation is a better strategy than VM for the Mac are backward software compatibility, compatibility with non-VM Macs, and the fact that a reliable VM kernel is more difficult to implement than simply forcing applications to do their own housekeeping.

Performance of a segmented system must be worse than a VM system for so many reasons, I don't know where to begin: segmentation results in less efficient allocation of memory across the whole machine, since process sizes are fixed, while VM automatically balances memory usage among competing processes; segmentation results in larger swaps than the standard 4K page size of VM; VM allows seldom-used data to be swapped, while segmentation deals only with code; segmentation is a software-only solution, while VM is implemented in low-level hardware (in on-chip hardware for 68030's and 040's); segmentation is not suited to interrupt-time swapping, or for that matter, interrupt-driven multitasking, since it only applies at the start of a function call, while VM allows swap-outs to happen any time without damage; segmentation leads to the need for larger reserves of space-worse, larger reserves for each process-since memory is used less efficiently and an entire segment must be loaded in order to recover from a fault; less efficient use of space also results in more swapping, fewer processes, or both; segmentation works against sharing code across applications and creating truly integrated object-oriented operating systems and applications, since it forces an application, rather than system, perspective on memory usage… I'm out of breath.

Kent, I'm not unloading on you personally, but I am getting tired of the lack of justification from Apple for segmentation vs. VM. At first, I sat back and waited for a good explanation, but none has come out in the couple of months this issue has been thrashed out (if you'll excuse the pun) on MacApp.Tech$. Just recycled potshots. Does anyone have any real numbers, or is this just a "let's trash Unix because we didn't invent it"-party?

Your article was great otherwise, and I learned a lot from it. Keep up the good work, in FrameWorks and in your responses to MacApp.Tech$. You're doing a good job of filling Keith's shoes.

Regards-Jeff

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

How to manage your time in Bakery Blitz
It can be tricky, especially when you risk burning your kitchen to the ground if you forget a cake in the oven, so make sure to use these time management tricks to keep your bakery running smoothly. Don’t collect the money right away [Read more] | Read more »
Model 15 (Music)
Model 15 1.0 Device: iOS iPhone Category: Music Price: $29.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: The Moog Model 15 App is the first Moog modular synthesizer and synthesis educational tool created exclusively for iPad, iPhone and... | Read more »
How to deal with wind in Angry Birds Act...
Angry Birds Action! is a physics-based puzzler in which you're tasked with dragging and launching birds around an obstacle-littered field to achieve a set objective. It's simple enough at first, but when wind gets introduced things can get pretty... | Read more »
How to get three stars in every level of...
Angry Birds Action! is, essentially, a pinball-style take on the pull-and-fling action of the original games. When you first boot it up, you'll likely be wondering exactly what it is you have to do to get a good score. Well, never fear as 148Apps... | Read more »
The beginner's guide to Warbits
Warbits is a turn-based strategy that's clearly inspired by Nintendo's Advance Wars series. Since turn-based strategy games can be kind of tricky to dive into, see below for a few tips to help you in the beginning. Positioning is crucial [Read... | Read more »
How to upgrade your character in Spellsp...
So you’ve mastered the basics of Spellspire. By which I mean you’ve realised it’s all about spelling things in a spire. What next? Well you’re going to need to figure out how to toughen up your character. It’s all well and good being able to spell... | Read more »
5 slither.io mash-ups we'd love to...
If there's one thing that slither.io has proved, it's that the addictive gameplay of Agar.io can be transplanted onto basically anything and it will still be good fun. It wouldn't be surprising if we saw other developers jumping on the bandwagon,... | Read more »
How to navigate the terrain in Sky Charm...
Sky Charms is a whimsical match-'em up adventure that uses creative level design to really ramp up the difficulty. [Read more] | Read more »
Victorious Knight (Games)
Victorious Knight 1.3 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $1.99, Version: 1.3 (iTunes) Description: New challenges awaits you! Experience fresh RPG experience with a unique combat mechanic, packed with high quality 3D... | Read more »
Agent Gumball - Roguelike Spy Game (Gam...
Agent Gumball - Roguelike Spy Game 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $2.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Someone’s been spying on Gumball. What the what?! Two can play at that game! GO UNDERCOVERSneak past enemy... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

13-inch 2.5GHz MacBook Pro on sale for $999,...
B&H Photo has the 13″ 2.5GHz MacBook Pro on sale for $999 including free shipping plus NY sales tax only. Their price is $100 off MSRP. Read more
Apple refurbished 2015 iMacs available for up...
Apple now has a full line of Certified Refurbished 2015 21″ & 27″ iMacs available for up to $350 off MSRP. Apple’s one-year warranty is standard, and shipping is free. The following models are... Read more
Indian Smartphone Market Grows Annually by 12...
India’s smartphone market grew by 12 percent year-over-year, with 24.4 million units shipping in Q1 2016. The top five vendors stayed the same, with Samsung in the lead, followed by Micromax, Intex... Read more
Get Notifications When Your Friend’s Phone Ba...
Calgary, Canada based Stonelight Pictures has announced the release of Battery Share 1.0.1, its new utility for iOS 9 supported devices. The company notes that people are spending more time on their... Read more
11-inch 1.6GHz/128GB MacBook Air on sale for...
Amazon has the current-generation 11″ 1.6GHz/128GB MacBook Air (sku MJVM2LL/A) on sale for $749.99 for a limited time. Their price is $150 off MSRP, and it’s the lowest price available for this model... Read more
Price drops on clearance 2015 13-inch MacBook...
B&H Photo has dropped prices on clearance 2015 13″ MacBook Airs by up to $250. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY sales tax only: - 13″ 1.6GHz/4GB/128GB MacBook Air (MJVE2LL/A): $799, $200... Read more
Mac minis on sale for up to $100 off MSRP
B&H Photo has Mac minis on sale for up to $100 off MSRP including free shipping plus NY sales tax only: - 1.4GHz Mac mini: $449 $50 off MSRP - 2.6GHz Mac mini: $649 $50 off MSRP - 2.8GHz Mac mini... Read more
13-inch Retina MacBook Pros on sale for up to...
B&H Photo has 13″ Retina MacBook Pros on sale for $130-$200 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY tax only: - 13″ 2.7GHz/128GB Retina MacBook Pro: $1169 $130 off MSRP - 13″ 2.7GHz/... Read more
Apple price trackers, updated continuously
Scan our Apple Price Trackers for the latest information on sales, bundles, and availability on systems from Apple’s authorized internet/catalog resellers. We update the trackers continuously: - 15″... Read more
SanDisk Half-Terabyte SSD Optimized for Every...
SanDisk Corporation has announced the SanDisk Z410 SSD, a cost-competitive, half-terabyte solid state drive (SSD) that enables manufacturers to design for a broad range of desktop PCs and laptops.... Read more

Jobs Board

Restaurant Manager (Neighborhood Captain) - A...
…in every aspect of daily operation WHY YOU LL LIKE IT You ll be the Big Apple You ll solve problems You ll get to show your ability to handle the stress and Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Job Description:SalesSpecialist - Retail Customer Service and SalesTransform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, Read more
Restaurant Manager (Neighborhood Captain) - A...
…in every aspect of daily operation. WHY YOU'LL LIKE IT: You'll be the Big Apple . You'll solve problems. You'll get to show your ability to handle the stress and Read more
*Apple* Subject Matter Expert - NTT Data, In...
…in Owings Mills, MD has a 6+ month contract position available for an Apple Subject Matter Expert. TITLE: Apple Subject Matter Expert LOCATION: Owings Mills, Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions - Apple,...
Job Description: Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.