TweetFollow Us on Twitter

December 95 - Kon & Bal's Puzzle Page: Zoning Out

Kon & Bal's Puzzle Page: Zoning Out

Konstantin Othmer and Bruce Leak

See if you can solve this programming puzzle, presented in the form of a dialog between Konstantin Othmer (KON) and Bruce Leak (BAL). The dialog gives clues to help you. Keep guessing until you're done; your score is the number to the left of the clue that gave you the correct answer. Even if you never run into the particular problems being solved here, you'll learn some valuable debugging techniques that will help you solve your own programming conundrums. And you'll also learn interesting Macintosh trivia.

BAL I've got a small problem I'd like you to help me with.

KON Who's paying the airfare this time?

BAL Nothing like that. It's really quite straightforward, and surprisingly reproducible. The problem is that sometimes when I'm using Microsoft Word 5.1a and I pull down a menu, when I let go of the menu there's garbage on the screen where the menu was.

KON That was a problem they were having in the beta release, but I think it's fixed in the final version of Windows 95.

BAL Actually, this is on a Power Macintosh 6100, and I haven't yet installed Windows 95 on top of my SoftPC, which runs on my 68000, which is being emulated by Gary's emulator.

KON Microsoft is still in the loop.

BAL Well, it's not just a Microsoft problem. I can't seem to make it happen with Word by itself. It only seems to happen if I run and quit cc:Mail before running Word.

KON That darn Justice Department! Without them you could just be running Microsoft mail, and you probably wouldn't have this problem.

Try running Word; then launch and quit cc:Mail. Does it still happen?

BAL Now Word is working fine. In fact, Word works in every case -- at least as far as this problem is concerned -- unless I launch and quit cc:Mail before launching and quitting Word. And the interesting thing is that it only happens with the Modern Memory Manager on.

KON Just run your machine with the classic Memory Manager. I have problems running THINK C's debugger when I use the Thread Manager and the Modern Memory Manager. There's just too many of these kinds of bugs to deal with!

BAL Not so fast, QuickDraw. The Modern Memory Manager gives you lots of great new features. First of all, your machine will run faster. In addition to being ported native, it also uses much more efficient algorithms. It keeps track of free blocks in a separate list, keeps track of heap zones to make RecoverHandle work better, and has a back pointer so that blocks can be walked either way, drastically decreasing heap-walking time and making things much more efficient -- especially when virtual memory is on. Also, the Modern Memory Manager was designed to be bus error proof, in that it returns from any internally generated exception by returning an error to its caller (though this was changed in the latest version of the Modern Memory Manager, as you may have read in the Balance of Power column in develop Issue 23). Finally, in the old Memory Manager moving the partition between the system and Process Manager heaps was a total nightmare; this problem was solved in the Modern Memory Manager.

KON Anytime you port something native you have two choices: rewrite the code directly, preserving internal algorithms and data structures, or rethink and reimplement, preserving only the top-level application interface. The first choice virtually guarantees compatibility but makes it difficult to maintain in the future, while the second gives you slightly less compatibility but a much better upgrade path, better maintainability, and a much more efficient system. It sounds like they went with the second choice, but at the obvious expense of some short-term compatibility problems. And it seems like that's what we're dealing with here.

BAL Thanks for the philosophy lesson. Are you going to solve the problem?

KON OK. Launch and quit cc:Mail and check all the heaps. Look for orphaned memory, locked blocks being left around, or any other signs of an application not properly cleaning up after itself.

BAL I need to install MacsBug to do that. I'll install version 6.5d11 because it has some new PowerPC features in case we need them.

KON I'm afraid we will.

BAL So after we quit cc:Mail, the system heap grew some, but all the heaps seem fine. We have an extra 128-byte pointer, and we have five extra handles for a total of almost 32K, but three of those (25K) are purgeable.

KON All this extra stuff lying around certainly explains why I have to reboot every couple of hours.

BAL Yeah, and those OS engineers really worked on that problem. On System 7.5 you get a pretty picture and a nice thermometer bar!

KON So try the patch dcmd. It will tell you what traps have been patched. Before you run cc:Mail, type

patch s
to grab a snapshot of all the traps. When you're in cc:Mail, just type
patch
and you'll get a list of all the traps that have been patched. It's a great way to find random skankiness.

BAL The only OS trap that they patch is _Rename, and they patch the Toolbox traps _Pack8, _UserDelay, _SysErr, _LoadSeg, _UnloadSeg, and _ExitToShell.

KON OK, and what's still patched after the application quits?

BAL Nothing. It seems to totally clean up.

KON Wonderful. What does Word patch?

BAL The OS traps _Rename and _CompactMem, and the Toolbox traps _Pack8, _UserDelay, _HiliteWindow, _FrontWindow, _SysError, _LoadSeg, and _ExitToShell.

KON There seems to be a lot of overlap. We should check a do-nothing generic application. I bet the system is magically patching some stuff when it runs an application.

BAL It turns out that all those traps except _HiliteWindow, _FrontWindow, _CompactMem, and _UnloadSeg are always getting patched.

KON It figures. Word is augmenting parts of the Memory Manager and getting in on some Window Manager action, and cc:Mail is playing games with the Segment Loader. Where's that book on Macintosh programming guidelines?

BAL I don't think they read that in Redmond. By the way, even though menu code is fairly boilerplate, this one's a mixed bag. Netscape, SimpleText, and FindFile work fine, but Word and THINK Reference fail consistently.

KON Boy, times have changed. I remember when you used to just dive right into MacsBug, disassemble a bunch of code, and get to the bottom of these problems. Now you're looking at what SimpleText does compared to Word!

BAL I'm not the one who's doing it. I don't even touch the computer anymore. It's one of my henchmen, Paul Young.

KON Anyway, there are two ways the bits behind the menus get redrawn. If plenty of memory is available, they get back-buffered and restored with CopyBits. If there's not much memory, an update event is generated.

BAL Since Word is the only application running at the time, we have plenty of memory.

KON Set a breakpoint on CopyBits and pull a menu down. The first break will be when the bits are being saved. Let's look at the address, step over the call, and make sure the right data was put there. When you let the menu up, you'll break on CopyBits again. Is the source data correct -- that is, is the source our previous destination?

BAL The base address when the bits are restored isn't the same as the base address when they get saved.

KON Where is the base address? Is it part of a handle that moved?

BAL The base address for the restore is $40810000.

KON Someone is dereferencing zero! It sounds like the bits are getting saved in a handle, and somehow the handle is getting trashed. Let's follow the handle from the save and see what happens to it.

BAL When the bits are being saved, the base address is part of a handle in MultiFinder temporary memory. The handle is $438 bytes long.

KON What happens to that memory on the restore?

BAL The memory still exists, and the data is fine. It's just that the PixMap doesn't point there anymore.

KON So we need to figure out where the Menu Manager is storing the PixMap and why that location is getting trashed.

BAL The Menu Manager uses SaveBits and RestoreBits, which allocate memory for the pixels using the offscreen buffer calls that return PixMaps. The PixMap base address does double duty: when it's unlocked it's a handle; when it's locked it's a pointer. There's a flag in rowBytes to indicate what state it's in. To go from the locked state to the unlocked state, the GWorld routines call RecoverHandle.

KON Let's break on RecoverHandle and see what we get back.

BAL It returns 0. But why?

KON It's kind of weird that this happens only with the Modern Memory Manager. In the old Memory Manager, you had to set the heap zone before calling RecoverHandle. The Modern Memory Manager relaxed this restriction and keeps a tree of valid heaps. When you call RecoverHandle, it walks the heap tree. If cc:Mail is somehow corrupting the tree, RecoverHandle will fail.

BAL Nice theory. How are you going to test that?

KON E.T.O. 17 has a debugging version of the native Memory Manager that will print out diagnostics anytime weird stuff happens. Let's install it and reboot.

BAL When you boot, you drop into MacsBug with the message "Bad pointer being passed to RecoverHandle 00030020." It looks like "PC Exchange" was loading.

KON Let's try booting with the extensions off. Use the Extensions Manager so that you can keep MacsBug, the Memory control panel (so that we're sure we're in the Modern Memory Manager), and the Debugging Memory Manager.

BAL When I run the Extensions Manager, I break into MacsBug with the message "Bad handle; are you unlocking a fake handle?"

KON A complete treatise on all the memory crimes committed in the Macintosh is beyond the scope of this column.

BAL Without superfluous extensions, the problem at boot time goes away, but we still have the problem in Word.

KON Well, let's look at the zones and see if everything looks OK. Let's do an hz to list all the heap zones.

BAL OK. But hz doesn't use the heap tree, so if you want to check the heap tree you'll have to do it manually.

KON Great. I'll use the SmartFriends debugging trick and call Jeff to figure out how to do that.

Jeff The heap tree is part of the zone header. The system zone starts at $2800, and a pointer to the next zone starts at offset $20. $2820 contains $1672DF0.

KON That should be the Process Manager zone. But that number is really big. How could that be? How many fonts do you have installed?!

Jeff Since the system heap can grow, we put the Process Manager zone header at the end of the block, so we don't have to move the header every time the heap size changes.

BAL The next zone in the Process Manager is nil, since at the top level there are only two zones: the system zone and the Process Manager zone.

KON Let's look at the child zones inside the Process Manager.

Jeff The child zones are pointed to by offset $24 in the zone header.

BAL The first child zone is the Word zone, which corresponds to what we got from hz. And the Word zone header has no child zones.

KON So the world makes sense so far. Does the next zone pointer make sense?

BAL It's kind of wacky. It points inside the Word heap!

KON That's a problem. Does that zone header look reasonable, at least?

BAL No. It's trash. It looks like Word code.

KON What happens if you don't run cc:Mail before running Word? And how does the Memory Manager know how to update the zone headers? There's no call to explicitly destroy zones, only create them.

BAL I'll take the second question first. Zones are created by InitZone, and they're never explicitly destroyed. In the Modern Memory Manager, there's new logic in DisposeHandle that checks to see if the handle is a zone; if so, it assumes the zone is destroyed and updates the heap tree.

KON Will the skankiness ever end?

BAL If I run Word without first running cc:Mail, the heap tree is OK.

KON Now we just need to figure out why the heap tree is getting trashed. Even though the tree update algorithm is implicit, it seems pretty good at first blush. Let's go through the failing scenario and compare the heap zones to the tree and figure out when they diverge.

BAL When we run cc:Mail, hz doesn't agree with the zone structure we get by walking the heap tree. Here's what the two structures look like:

KON So the cc:Mail zone is smaller than the handle of the memory it's in. Someone limited the size of the application zone. In the heap tree view, it's clear why: another zone is being allocated; 32K is left between the zones, and that space is being used for the stack.

BAL The reason hz can't find the second zone is that before the Modern Memory Manager, no one kept explicit track of the zones. Basically, the hz command has to search for the zones. It does this by starting from the system zone, which is always pointed to by low memory (and is usually located after the trap tables at $2800). From the system heap zone header, it can find the zone trailer. Right after that block is the Process Manager zone header. It walks all the blocks in a zone and finds all the handles that look like other zones. It starts by assuming that the handle contains a zone, and then checks to see if the zone header points to a block that looks like a trailer and if the trailer points back to the zone header. When it looks for zones inside other zones, it assumes that they begin either at the start of the handle or right after another zone. Since cc:Mail has its stack space between the two zones, the hz command can't find it.

KON OK. Unfortunately we're not debugging the hz command. But that probably gives us a clue as to why the Modern Memory Manager is getting confused. It seems to keep pretty good track of the zones that are getting created, since that's easy by just watching InitZone. But it gets confused when the zones are being disposed of, since it does that by watching DisposeHandle.

BAL Exactly. The heap tree gets trashed when cc:Mail quits, since the Modern Memory Manager assumes that there's only one zone (and perhaps its children) in any handle. So when it sees the dispose, it throws away the first zone and all its children, but it doesn't throw away the second zone. It works fine with the old Memory Manager since no one ever explicitly keeps track of all the zones. But the Modern Memory Manager uses the heap tree for RecoverHandle, and the tree is trashed, so either the machine crashes or you get garbage.

KON That's pretty interesting. In this case, neither cc:Mail nor Word did anything wrong. The way cc:Mail used the Memory Manager was nonstandard, and when the algorithms in the Modern Memory Manager changed, there were some interesting cases that fell through the cracks. I think the newer version of cc:Mail no longer allocates zones this way. And the Memory Manager will undoubtedly soon be smarter.

BAL Nasty.

KON Yeah.

KONSTANTIN OTHMER AND BRUCE LEAK

KON has been holding a steady job at Catapult Entertainment for many months now, but he spends more time playing soccer than working. BAL is at the front of the self-employment line and has finally moved out of his hotel and into a house. Rumor has it that behind the house there's a big archery field.

 
AAPL
$101.63
Apple Inc.
-0.03
MSFT
$46.24
Microsoft Corpora
-0.46
GOOG
$573.10
Google Inc.
-2.52

MacTech Search:
Community Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

OS X Yosemite 10.10 DP8 - Developer Prev...
Note: This is a Developer Preview. You must be a registered Apple Mac Developer to download this update. You can also sign up for the free OS X Beta Program to download and preview public beta... Read more
FotoMagico 4.5 - Powerful slideshow crea...
FotoMagico lets you create professional slideshows from your photos and music with just a few, simple mouse clicks. It sports a very clean and intuitive yet powerful user interface. High image... Read more
Screenshot Path 1.2.1 - Change the defau...
Screenshot Path lets you change the folder where OS X saves screenshots. Screenshots are saved by default to the user’s desktop. This is handy for the occasional screenshot but those looking to take... Read more
Fantastical 1.3.16 - Create calendar eve...
Fantastical is the Mac calendar you'll actually enjoy using. Creating an event with Fantastical is quick, easy, and fun: Open Fantastical with a single click or keystroke Type in your event details... Read more
GIMP 2.8.14 - Powerful, free image editi...
GIMP is a multi-platform photo manipulation tool. GIMP is an acronym for GNU Image Manipulation Program. The GIMP is suitable for a variety of image manipulation tasks, including photo retouching,... Read more
HoudahSpot 3.9.3 - Advanced front-end fo...
HoudahSpot is an advanced file search tool built upon MacOS X Spotlight. Spotlight unleashed Create detailed queries to locate the exact file you need Narrow down searches. Zero in on files Save... Read more
djay 4.2.3 - Transform your Mac into a f...
djay transforms your Mac into a full-fledged DJ system, allowing you to mix your iTunes music library on a hyper-realistic turntable interface. Perform live, record mixes on-the-go, or enable... Read more
iDefrag 2.2.8 - Disk defragmentation and...
iDefrag helps defragment and optimize your disk for improved performance. Features include: Supports HFS and HFS+ (Mac OS Extended). Supports case sensitive and journaled filesystems. Supports... Read more
Bookends 12.2.3 - Reference management a...
Bookends is a full-featured bibliography/reference and information-management system for students and professionals. Access the power of Bookends directly from Mellel, Nisus Writer Pro, or MS Word (... Read more
Copy 1.47.0410 - Cloud storage and file...
Note: You must first sign up to use Copy (get a 5GB sign-up bonus through our 'Download' link above). Copy lets you sync, protect, and share. Everywhere. Want to bring some files home? No problem!... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Vizzywig 4K (Photography)
Vizzywig 4K 1.0 Device: iOS iPhone Category: Photography Price: $999.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: REQUIRES: iOS 7 on iPhone 5S with 32GB or 64GB. (Do not use iOS 8)The world's FIRST mobile 4K video capture, editing and... | Read more »
The Sleeping Prince Review
The Sleeping Prince Review By Jennifer Allen on September 15th, 2014 Our Rating: :: RESTRICTIVE KINGDOM SAVINGUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad The Sleeping Prince looks and feels great to play, but its lack of peril and... | Read more »
It Came From Canada: Terra Battle
In some way or another, most Japanese RPGs owe something to Final Fantasy. But with Terra Battle, the now-common mix of Western medieval fantasy with Eastern anime aesthetic feels earned. After all, its developer, Mistwalker, was founded by the... | Read more »
Five Nights at Freddy’s Review
Five Nights at Freddy’s Review By Rob Thomas on September 15th, 2014 Our Rating: :: FIVE FRIGHTS AT FREDDY'SUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad Can you survive five nights as the new night watchman of Freddy Fazbear’s... | Read more »
Phantom Rift Review
Phantom Rift Review By Nadia Oxford on September 15th, 2014 Our Rating: :: FRIENDLY PHANTOMUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad Despite a snag here and there, Phantom Rift is a well-crafted and imaginative adventure RPG.   | Read more »
Phantom Rift – Tips, Tricks, Strategies,...
Hello, Wanderers: | Read more »
Meet the Newest Character for Temple Run...
Meet the Newest Character for Temple Run 2, from National Geographic Kids’ Action-Adventure Book Posted by Jessica Fisher on September 15th, 2014 [ | Read more »
Battle Riders Review
Battle Riders Review By Jordan Minor on September 15th, 2014 Our Rating: :: UNTWISTED METALUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad BattleRiders has cool car combat, but it could be crazier.   | Read more »
Rapture - World Conquest (Games)
Rapture - World Conquest 1.0.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $2.99, Version: 1.0.0 (iTunes) Description: The End is coming! Bombard the globe with devastating miracles and decimate the enemy civilizations. Guide your... | Read more »
Toonia Jelly: Music Review
Toonia Jelly: Music Review By Amy Solomon on September 15th, 2014 Our Rating: :: CUTE MUSICAL EXPLORATIONUniversal App - Designed for iPhone and iPad Toonia Jelly: Music is a charming exploratory app for young children with a... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

10% off iPhone 6 and 6 Plus Otterbox cases
Get 10% off on popular Otterbox iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus cases at MacMall through September 19th. Use code OTTERBOX10 to see the discount. Read more
15-inch MacBook Pros on sale for up to $125 o...
Amazon has the new 2014 15″ Retina MacBook Pros on sale for up to $125 off MSRP including free shipping: - 15″ 2.2GHz Retina MacBook Pro: $1899.99 save $100 - 15″ 2.5GHz Retina MacBook Pro: $2374... Read more
27-inch 3.2GHz iMac on sale for $1698, $101 o...
Abt has the 27″ 3.2GHz iMac on sale for $1698 including free shipping. Their price is $101 off MSRP. Read more
More To Making A Larger iPad Than Expanded Sc...
CNET’s Ross Rubin has posted a thoughtful analysis of prospects for a larger display iPad Pro, noting that Microsoft and Samsung currently have the large-display touchscreen tablet category to... Read more
SwiftKey Keyboard Finally Coming To iPhone An...
At the TechCrunch Disrupt event in San Francisco, Swiftkey unveiled the first details about SwiftKey Keyboard for iPhone, iPad & iPod touch. SwiftKey’s philosophy is that you should be able to... Read more
Save $75 on the 16GB iPad mini with Retina Di...
Best Buy has the 16GB iPad mini with Retina Display on sale for $324.99 on their online store for a limited time. Their price is $75 off MSRP, and it’s the lowest price available for this mini.... Read more
21-inch 1.4GHz iMac on sale for $979, $120 of...
B&H Photo has the new 21″ 1.4GHz iMac on sale for $979.99 including free shipping plus NY sales tax only. Their price is $120 off MSRP. B&H will also include free copies of Parallels Desktop... Read more
Apple restocks refurbished 21-inch 1.4GHz iMa...
The Apple Store has restocked Apple Certified Refurbished 21″ 1.4GHz iMacs for $929 including free shipping plus Apple’s standard one-year warranty. Their price is $170 off the cost of new models,... Read more
13-inch 2.6GHz/256GB Retina MacBook Pro on sa...
Adorama has the 13″ 2.6GHz/256GB Retina MacBook Pro on sale for $1379 including free shipping plus NY & NJ sales tax only. Their price is $120 off MSRP, and it’s the lowest price available for... Read more
Macally iPhone 6 Cases
Macally has introduced a Line of Snap-On Shell Cases, Frame Bumper Cases and a Rugged Protective Case for iPhone 6 with 4.7inch Screen, such as the SNAP case in a variety of brilliant metallic... Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.