March 94 - TEN TIPS FOR GAME DEVELOPERS
TEN TIPS FOR GAME DEVELOPERS
In this column I'll give some general tips that are targeted at game developers but can in fact benefit
any Macintosh application. Many of the tips are illustrated in the accompanying sample code
(CopyBits ColorKarma) on this issue's CD. If you're considering writing a game for the Macintosh,
or you want to improve your existing game or other application, these tips are for you. Here they are
at a glance:
- The Macintosh gaming market is wide open.
- Bypass QuickDraw wisely.
- Use CopyBits correctly.
- Scroll graphics smoothly.
- Don't synchronize with the VBL interrupt.
- Use Sound Manager 3.0.
- Learn when to use (or not use) Apple events.
- Use the Time Manager.
- Use the Memory Manager effectively.
- Use a compatible copy-protection scheme (if any).
THE TIPS IN DETAIL
1. The Macintosh gaming market is wide open.
The Macintosh has infiltrated the homes, offices, and schools of every continent on the planet, and it
has matured enough to be ready for entertainment software of all sorts. Hit Macintosh games have
sold over 60,000 copies, and users are clamoring for more. If you walk into a software store, though,
you'll notice that there isn't a very large selection of Macintosh game and entertainment software.
Now is the time to take advantage of the lack of competition and get into the entertainment market
with your games.
2. Bypass QuickDraw wisely.
Applications that bypass QuickDraw by accessing video memory directly may not work on future
Macintosh platforms. The Macintosh is evolving, and some of the changes may be in the bus
architecture, causing applications that write to video memory to break. We're not saying this is going
to happen any time soon, but it's a good idea to be ready for it now so that your product will last in
A good compromise is to draw with custom drawing code into an off-screen GWorld, and then use
CopyBits to transfer it to the screen. This avoids accessing hardware directly, and will always work.
If you must write directly to the screen, it's important to follow the guidelines set forth in "Graphical
Truffles: Writing Directly to the Screen" indevelop Issue 11, which states that you should always
have a QuickDraw version of your code. If your program uses QuickDraw (or QuickDraw GX), it
will always be compatible with every future Macintosh platform.
If you do bypass QuickDraw, your application should time the custom drawing code versus
QuickDraw at run time, and then choose the fastest routines. This way, the fastest code will be used
in cases where your code is running on a system that has an accelerated version of QuickDraw, or
perhaps a different CPU altogether.
3. Use CopyBits correctly.
I've heard many developers say that CopyBits is slow, that it can't achieve the frame rates needed to
do good games. If you use CopyBits correctly, however, youcan achieve a high animation frame rate.
Understanding all of the factors that affect CopyBits performance is critical to achieving high
animation frame rates and still having processor bandwidth left over for the rest of the game. The
following tips on CopyBits speed have been collated from many different sources, including
Technical Notes, sample code, and other tomes of QuickDraw knowledge. (See also tip 4 below.)
- CopyBits is more efficient with wider images than with tall ones.
- CopyBits is more efficient with rectangular transfers, with no mask region.
- CopyBits is more efficient when the source and destination have the same color table, and even
better when the ctSeeds of the color tables are the same. (The accompanying sample code shows
how to use the Palette Manager and how to set up the color tables in your application window and
- CopyBits with a mask region is faster than either CopyMask or CopyDeepMask. Convert your
masks to QuickDraw regions and then use CopyBits. (See the CopyBits vs. CopyMask snippet on
this issue's CD.)
- CopyBits is faster when the transfer source and destination are long-word aligned, especially on an
For more details on these principles, see the Tech Note "Of Time and Space and _CopyBits."
4. Scroll graphics smoothly.
This tip applies to games with scrolling maps, painting programs, and any application that needs to
scroll window content quickly and smoothly.
Many Macintosh applications suffer from flickering scrolling, caused by erasing the previous image
before drawing the new image. To reduce flicker, you should redraw only the parts of the screen that
change; don't erase anything first, unless absolutely necessary. When you're designing your scrolling
code or animation engine, the philosophy to adopt is that every pixel should be touched onlyonce .
Another technique is to buffer your graphics into an off-screen GWorld: make all changes in the
GWorld and then transfer the image to the screen with CopyBits. This can be slower, because the
image is drawn twice, but it results in an especially smooth update. An example of a game that uses
CopyBits in this way is MacPlay's Out of This World. This game draws into an off-screen GWorld
using custom polygon-rendering code (thus ensuring a high frame rate); then, when the image is
completely rendered, it's transferred to the screen with CopyBits (ensuring compatibility with future
video hardware). For more on this subject, see "Graphical Truffles: Animation at a Glance"
indevelop Issue 12 and "Drawing in GWorlds for Speed and Versatility" in Issue 10.
There's another method that isn't as smooth but uses less memory, and that is to use ScrollRect.
ScrollRect was changed in System 7: if you pass nil for the updateRgn parameter of ScrollRect, it
won't erase the area that has been uncovered, and you can then use CopyBits in a second step to copy
in the new bits. (In System 6, ScrollRect will erase the area you're scrolling out of, causing the screen
to flicker more.)The sample code demonstrates these techniques, showing the tradeoffs between memory footprint
and smoothness/apparent speed.
5. Don't synchronize with the VBL interrupt.
Many developers have wanted to synchronize animation with the vertical blanking (VBL) interrupt to
eliminate tears when the next frame of animation is drawn before the display hardware has completed
the previous frame. It's possible to eliminate tears from small-sized animations, but the overall
application will run more slowly because you'll be spending time waiting for the VBL period to start.
This results in a much lower animation frame rate, and the application also loses processing power
for the rest of the program. Note that QuickTime does not synchronize with the VBL interrupt.
Another headache to consider with respect to synchronizing with the VBL interrupt is that displays
have different refresh rates, and each one's actual VBL period has a different length. This means that
for your program to have accurate frame rates on different monitors, you'll have to time the refresh
rate of the display you're animating on.
To work around not being able to synchronize with
the VBL interrupt, you should try to interleave the animation processing so that you're never
updating too many objects at one time. The Time Manager will allow you to break the processing up
into separate tasks (see tip 8). If you're getting tears on objects, consider using fewer objects or
6. Use Sound Manager 3.0.
The Macintosh Sound Manager has recently been enhanced (version 3.0). It now can efficiently handle
as many sound channels as memory and processor bandwidth can take. This means four channels on
a Macintosh LC (which used to handle only one channel) and up to 16 or more on higher-end
platforms. As a result, your application can play sound and still have enough CPU bandwidth for
other animation and processing. The sample code demonstrates multiple sound channels playing
asynchronously while animating an image. Also see "Somewhere in QuickTime: What's New With
Sound Manager 3.0"
in develop Issue 16 and "The Asynchronous Sound Helper" in Issue 11.
Many bugs have been fixed in Sound Manager 3.0.
You can now open a sound channel at the start of your program and then continuously use SndPlay
to play sounds through it, without disposing of the channel between sounds. Previous versions of the
Sound Manager had problems playing sampled sounds like this, so many developers adopted the
technique of allocating and disposing of a new sound channel for each sound played.
On the AV Macintosh models, the Sound Manager uses the DSP. This requires the DSP Manager to
load a new component every time you open a new channel, and may require disk access. So if you're
running with Sound Manager 3.0 you shouldnot open and close a sound channel for each sound
played; doing so will cause your application to perform less than optimally, especially on the AV
See the source code file GameSounds.c, which is part of the CopyBits ColorKarma sample, for an
example of a unit that manages asynchronous sound. If Sound Manager 3.0 or later is present, the
code opens the sound channels at initialization and closes them when the program quits; otherwise it
opens and closes the channels as sounds are played.
Sound Manager 3.0 also adds a new routine, named GetSndHeaderOffset, that makes it easier to use
a bufferCmd to play sounds. Using a bufferCmd is faster than using SndPlay. See the sample code on
the CD for an example.
Note that the sample code doesn't store the application's A5 register as part of the callback
command, so that the interrupt code can set the flag associated with the channel. Instead it just stores
a pointer to the flag. This allows the interrupt-time callback to be very small, since it doesn't have to
save, set up, and restore A5; it just dereferences the pointer and sets the flag directly. The sample
code gives an example of playing a sound asynchronously with a completion callback. I use thistechnique in just about any interrupt-time callback code I write, including VBL tasks, Time Manager
tasks, and Device Manager completion routines.
If you don't use the Sound Manager at all, you're taking an unnecessary compatibility risk. Apple has
always recommended against accessing the sound hardware directly. Applications that violate this rule
have broken in the past, and they will break again.
7. Learn when to use (or not use) Apple events.
Apple events have simplified interapplication communication, making it easy to add value to your
application. A game played against live human players is often more fun than a game played against a
computer. Just about every night you'll find some Apple engineers huddled over their computers
playing Bolo, Spaceward Ho!, or other network games.
Consider Velocity's Spectre, a network tank game that has been very successful. Spectre doesn't use
Apple events; it uses custom DDP (datagram delivery protocol) socket listeners at the lowest level of
AppleTalk to achieve high performance. But if your game doesn't require the same level of
performance, you may benefit from the ease of use of Apple events.
If you require more performance than Apple events
can provide, one option is to use the PPC Toolbox directly, which will allow you to still remain a
step removed from direct AppleTalk. See the PPC Toolbox chapter ofInside Macintosh Volume VI
for more information.
If you require even more performance, you can use AppleTalk Data Stream Protocol (ADSP)
directly, or one of the other AppleTalk protocols. ADSP is a higher-level protocol that will allow you
to do block transfers and not worry about losing packets and packet order.
It's hard to determine which networking protocol to use ahead of time. From my experience in using
Apple events to synchronize animation and events between two Macintosh computers, I would say
that if your game is a more than two-player, real-time arcade game, Apple events would probably not
be the best solution. If your game is a turn-based strategy-type game, like Spaceward Ho!,
RoboSport, Strategic Conquest, and many others, Apple events will work very well for you, no
matter how many players are in the game.
For a simple example of using Apple events as a game messaging system, see ZAM 1.a13 on the CD.
8. Use the Time Manager.
The Macintosh Time Manager is very useful for game developers. Animation code often needs a
heartbeat, to synchronize the timing and updates of every object.
The Time Manager lets you break down your code into discrete tasks that run at a steady rate. This
allows you to write modular code that updates smoothly.
One limitation of the Time Manager is that tasks fire at interrupt time, so they can't do much more
than set a flag to inform the regular event loop that it's time to do something. The sample code on
the CD shows how to place a wrapper around the Time Manager that allows you to execute tasks at
9. Use the Memory Manager effectively.
The Macintosh Memory Manager is very flexible, and a boon to most application programmers.
However, for the game programmer it can be a performance problem unless it's used wisely. In a
game, you should preallocate as much of your memory as possible. If you're using a dynamic object
allocation scheme, you should design one that preallocates the objects and keeps track of which ones
are in use or not. If you have many allocated blocks in a heap and then request a new one, you could
send the Memory Manager into thrashing mode where it will try to move many blocks around to
make space. This can cause your animation to be jerky or your whole game to freeze for an instant.
So the best thing to do when performance matters is to minimize your use of the Memory Manager.
To minimize Memory Manager use, you should not only allocate as much of your memory up front
as possible but also avoid using relocatable blocks unless absolutely necessary. This means avoiding
game architectures that rely on the Memory Manager for dynamic object allocation. Definitely
allocate your nonrelocatable blocks first, and allocate handles later. This prevents heap fragmentation
and avoids sending the Memory Manager into a tailspin.
Be aware that some parts of the Toolbox, like Apple events, expect Memory Manager structures.
However, if the rest of the program's memory is allocated wisely to prevent heap fragmentation, even
these allocations will happen quickly, with no impact on game performance.
10. Use a compatible copy-protection scheme (if any).
It's a matter of great controversy whether software should be copy-protected at all. No software
protection scheme on the Macintosh has ever survived the talented efforts of Macintosh hackers.
There's always someone who will defeat your copy protection, no matter how convoluted it may be.
There are many who consider such protection a puzzle and a challenge to break, so by putting it in
you may be inviting piracy.
But if you do decide you want some level of protection on your game, we strongly recommend
against a disk-based protection scheme, which is guaranteed to break your program. Instead, we
recommend using one (or a combination) of the methods described here.
One method is to use serial numbers: when the software is installed, ask the user to enter the serial
number from the disk label, and then imprint the software with the person's name. Another method
involves requiring the user to enter a password from the manual every once in a while. If you do this,
it's a nice touch to allow users who send you the registration card to disable the password dialog;
once you have the registration card, you can link the customer to a serial number.
Consider also making the following checks: At installation time, use Gestalt to determine the
characteristics of the machine you're installed on, and save these to your preferences file. Also, use
FindFolder to record the directory ID of the System Folder, which is the same until a new System
Folder is created. Every time your application starts up, make the same Gestalt and FindFolder calls
to check whether you're running on the same machine; if not, have the user reinstall the software and
reenter the serial number, or reenter the password from the manual.
These techniques are the most compatible way to both protect your sales and minimize the kind of
frustration customers experience with other password- or disk-based copy protection systems.
ARE YOU GAME?
That's not all! To help Macintosh game developers share tips, tricks, and information, Apple has set
up the Game Development Discussion folder on AppleLink (in Developer Support: Developer Talk).
This board is read by Macintosh game development companies, other developers, and Apple
engineers on a daily basis. Also, there's a folder on this issue's CD, called Game Development, that
contains special resources Apple has put together to aid all game developers.
So if you're tired of the scant choices on the Macintosh Entertainment shelf in your local software
store, do something about it: write some games!
- Macintosh Technical Note "Of Time and Space and _CopyBits" (QuickDraw 21).
- "Somewhere in QuickTime: What's New With Sound Manager 3.0" by Jim Reekes, develop Issue 16.
- "Graphical Truffles: Animation at a Glance" by Edgar Lee, develop Issue 12.
- "The Asynchronous Sound Helper" by Bryan K. ("Beaker") Ressler, and "Graphical Truffles: Writing
Directly to the Screen" by Brigham Stevens and Bill Guschwan, develop Issue 11.
- "Drawing in GWorlds for Speed and Versatility" by Konstantin Othmer and Mike Reed, develop Issue 10.
- Guide to Macintosh Family Hardware , 2nd ed. (Addison-Wesley, 1990).
- Snow Crash, by Neal Stephenson. A fast-paced book to keep you up late at night. Stephenson says this
book was inspired by the original Macintosh Human Interface Guidelines . (Imagine what he would have
done if he'd had the new improved edition!)
BRIGHAM STEVENS (Internet firstname.lastname@example.org) Since
you last saw Brigham here, he has spoken at the Worldwide Developers Conference on Macintosh game development,
moved to San Francisco, jumped out of a perfectly good airplane, become addicted to flight simulators, spent 150 hours
in a car with no stereo, tossed his cookies on the steps of the Smithsonian Air and Space Museum in Washington DC, quit
Apple to start a game development/consulting company in San Francisco, and become a vampire. You'll see some games
from him later on in 1994. *
For more on VBL interrupts, see the Guide to Macintosh Family Hardware, second edition.*
Sound Manager 3.0 is available for licensing, so you can distribute it with your products to ensure that your customers and
applications will receive its benefits. You can reach Apple's software licensing department at AppleLink SW.LICENSE. *
If you create a demo version of a game by commenting out code or imposing a time limit to game play, be aware that
these kinds of demos are often hacked into full-blown pirate applications. We strongly suggest that when you create a
demo version, you take out all nonessential pieces of code and sufficiently cripple the remaining software (so that a hacker
can't simply paste in missing resources to get a full, unprotected copy). *
Thanks to Konstantin Othmer, Jim Reekes, and John Wang for reviewing this column. And special thanks to the people
who contributed to the information in this column, including (but not limited to) C. K. Haun, Tony Myles, Craig Fryar, Mike
Schlachter, Bill Dugan of Interplay Productions, and the rest of the developers I've worked with over the past couple of