TweetFollow Us on Twitter

March 93 - MACINTOSH DEBUGGING: THE BELLY OF THE BEAST REVISITED

MACINTOSH DEBUGGING: THE BELLY OF THE BEAST REVISITED

FRED HUXHAM AND GREG MARRIOTT

ADAPTED FROM THEIR TALK AT THE WWDC BY DAVE JOHNSON

[IMAGE Huxham_Marriott_rev1.GIF]

This is a supplement to the article "Macintosh Debugging: A Weird Journey Into the Belly of the Beast" in Issue 8 of develop. It presents a few debugging tools that were discussed at Apple's Worldwide Developers Conference in May 1992. Like those discussed in the previous article, these tools are designed to help you force the nasty, subtle bugs in your code to show their hideous little faces immediately, rather than lying in wait and biting you when you least expect it.

People often ask us, "How can I be a totally awesome, godlike debugging stud [or studette] like you?" Unfortunately, the big truth from the Issue 8 debugging article is just as true now as it was then: debugging is hard. That's just the way it is. The only way to get better at it is to practice. Now that we've got that straight and before we get into describing the new debugging tools, here are three pearls of wisdom to guide you in your practice.

First of all, it helps to know a lot about the operating system. The better sense you have of how the Macintosh works, the better off you'll be trying to track down a nasty bug. Dare to delve into the bowels of the OS. Read and rereadInside Macintosh; take it with you to bed, to the bathroom, out to dinner, and on dates. (You might want to invest in a sturdy wheelbarrow, especially with the new Inside Macintosh volumes proliferating like rabbits.) For that matter, read every Macintosh programming book ever written (especially those listed at the end of this article) and every Technical Note, Snippet, piece of Sample Code, and issue ofdevelop, as well as every word on the AppleLink Discussion boards. Also, spend lots of time in debuggers, watching the system do its thing. If you're not dreaming in hex, you're not spending enough time in MacsBug.

Second, get slammed a lot. The people who are the best at debugging are usually the ones who've had to track down the most bugs and therefore have an encyclopedic knowledge of them. If you have a really nasty bug in your code that crashes the machine on a seemingly random basis and takes you three days to find and squash, then by jove you'll remember that bug the next time you see it. Simply put, the more bugs you find, the better you'll be at finding bugs.

Last, use good tools, and use them all. Reread the Issue 8 article. Turn on those tools and stress your code. Bend, fold, staple, and mutilate it. Show no mercy.

These things will help you on your way to becoming a primo bug stomper, but debugging is like any complex skill in that it can't really be taught past a certain point. You simply have to do it a lot, andover time you'll get better. Tools and techniques such as the ones presented here can help enormously, especially by forcing hidden bugs to the surface, but they can never do the whole job for you.

This time there are only four new tools to talk about -- Double Trouble, Dispose Resource, Blat, and Smart Friends -- so this article is much shorter than the last one. The tools are available on theDeveloper CD Seriesdisc, as well as on AppleLink and elsewhere. We're doing this backward from the last time: first we'll present a buggy code sample, then we'll talk about the tool that would find the bug.

DOUBLE TROUBLE

Can you find the bug in this code sample?
myHandle = NewHandle(100);
if (myHandle) {
    AddResource(myHandle, 'dumb', 10, "\p");
    if (resError()) HandleTheError();
    CloseResFile(outputFileRef);
    DisposeHandle(myHandle);
}

OK, time's up. This one's not too hard. The problem is that during CloseResFile the Resource Manager disposes of all the resources in memory. The DisposeHandle call afterward is unnecessary and is actually potentially disastrous. Normally you'll just get an error and DisposeHandle will do nothing, but occasionally the data structures in the Memory Manager will conspire to really screw you.

Here's how: Master pointers are allocated in clumps called master pointer blocks, which are nonrelocatable blocks in your application's heap. The master pointers that are currently free for use are kept in a linked list by the Memory Manager. The list is LIFO, like a stack: when you allocate a new handle, the Memory Manager uses the first master pointer in the free list, and when you dispose of a handle the freed master pointer is returned to the beginning of the list.

Now the plot thickens. If the first master pointer in the free list also happens to be the first master pointer in its master pointer block (so that the master pointer and the master pointer block have the same address) and then you dispose of a handle twice by mistake,very bad thingswill happen. On the first dispose, everything is fine: the Memory Manager frees the block the master pointer points to and returns the master pointer to the start of the free list. At this time, the master pointerstill points to a valid block of memory, but now it's the master pointer block itself! So on the second, unintentional dispose, when the Memory Manager dutifully frees the block for reuse, you're set up for disaster. Subsequent memory use will likely result in writing over many master pointers, which will of course trash you one way or another.

Figure 1 illustrates this scenario. On the left is the top part of a master pointer block that resides in the heap at address 80. The heap's free list is a standard linked list (each entry contains the next entry's address) beginning at hFstFree. Note that the first entry in the heap's free list is also the first master pointer in the block. This is the first step to trouble.

[IMAGE Huxham_Marriott_rev2.GIF]

Figure 1 How Disposing of the Same Handle Twice Can Spell Disaster

Now we call DisposeHandle on the master pointer at 81. DisposeHandle looks at the block pointed to by the master pointer (in this case the block at 144, not shown), determines that it is indeed a valid block, marks it as free for reuse, and adds the newly freed master pointer to the front of the free list. So far so good. Now the master pointer block looks like the one on the right in the figure.

Then we call DisposeHandle on 81 again by mistake. DisposeHandle looks at the block pointed to by the master pointer (now it's the block at 80, our master pointer block!), determines that it is indeed a valid block (uh oh), marks it as free for reuse (yikes!), and adds the newly freed master pointer to the front of the free list -- and the heap is now hosed for good. This Memory Manager bug is subtle and rare, but oh so nasty.

Even if you're lucky enough to avoid this particular sequence of events, a double disposal is definitely a bug. Double Trouble is a system extension that watches calls to DisposeHandle to make sure it's not being called on something in the free list. If it is, Double Trouble drops into the debugger with a suitable warning.

We'll be the first to admit that Double Trouble is far from perfect. It infers the existence of heap zones by watching InitZone and then trying to figure out when a heap isn't a heap anymore. The possibility exists that it will guess wrong and cause a bus error when trying to walk a free list that's no longer a free list. Furthermore, in some cases Double Trouble can noticeably slow down parts of the system. (After playing a long QuickTime movie, for instance, the machine may freeze for almost a minute.)

But despite Double Trouble's shortcomings, we do still recommend running it all the time. Just try to remember that it's running so you don't chase your tail trying to find the cause of occasional mysterious slowdowns.

DISPOSE RESOURCE

Here's the code. What's the bug?
myPicture = GetPicture(kPicID);
if (myPicture) {
    DrawPicture(myPicture, &myRect);
    DisposeHandle(myPicture);
}

That's right, you should never call DisposeHandle on a resource handle. If you do, the Memory Manager will free it just fine, but the Resource Manager has another reference to it, stored in the resource map, that will be left dangling. Later on, since the Resource Manager doesn't know the handle was disposed of, it may try some manipulation with the handle. The results may not crash you immediately, or at all -- it depends on what the operation is and what's in the handle -- but they're certainly not what was intended. Instead of DisposeHandle, you should always call ReleaseResource on resource handles. ReleaseResource will properly dispose of the handleandwill update the resource map. (Note that KillPicture won't do the right thing here either; it's intended for pictures created via OpenPicture, not for PICT resources.)

Dispose Resource is another extension a lot like Double Trouble. It also watches DisposeHandle calls, this time looking to see if the handle being disposed of is a resource handle. If so, you'll drop into the debugger with a suitable warning.

Dispose Resource has one idiosyncrasy you should know about: it's been known to indicate "false positives." Some parts of the system (we haven't been able to track down which ones yet) seem to save a resource handle's state, detach the resource, and then restore the state of the handle (restoring the resource bit!). Use Dispose Resource. It will ensure that you don't make the same mistake.

BLAT

This time the code's in assembler:
; Offset the rect by 128 pixels in each direction.
PEA         theRect(A6)
MOVE.W      $0080, -(SP)
MOVE.W      $0080, -(SP)
_OffsetRect

If you have "iron man" syndrome and insist on programming in assembly language, this can happen to you. We forgot to type a # in front of each $0080. As a result, instead of moving the number $0080 (128) onto the stack twice in preparation for the OffsetRect call, we're moving the contents of memory location $0080. Often this kind of bug is immediately obvious, but not always. If you're moving a Boolean, for instance, you have a fifty-fifty chance of getting the right value, even though you're getting it from some random spot in memory. It's those cases that will give you debugging headaches.

One easy (and recommended) way to avoid the problem in this example is to write in a higher-level language. But we realize that's not always possible, and besides, this is really a wholeclassof problems: reads and writes from places in memory you didn't intend. The best way to catch this wild memory reference kind of problem is, naturally, with memory protection, something that -- sadly -- the Macintosh normally lacks. In the last article we mentioned Jasik's implementation, but now there's something else you should know about. Bo3b Johnson has written a dcmd called Blat that uses the MMU to protect memory locations 0-255 from both reads and writes.

Blat has been tested and works well on the Macintosh IIfx, IIx, and SE/30. Because its operation is so hardware dependent, it's hard to predict whether it will work on a given machine. Some basic guidelines are that it requires an MMU and won't work with 68040 machines or with most configurations of machines with the IIci ROM (IIci, IIsi, LC). For further details, see the release notes and the source code, thoughtfully provided by Bo3b along with the dcmd itself.

SMART FRIENDS

This bug is subtle, so pay close attention:
#pragma parameter __d0 GetA0
Ptr GetA0(void) = {0x2008};  // MOVE.l A0,D0

void MyCompletionRoutine()
{
    long        saveA5;
    HooHahPtr   myHooHah;
    
    myHooHah = (HooHahPtr)GetA0();
    saveA5 = SetA5(myHooHah->myA5);
    gSomething[0].flag = true; // Set a flag in a global array. 
    SetA5(saveA5);
}

This code really tries hard to do everything right. As the name implies, it's a completion routine, so it could be called at interrupt time. First a pointer to the data is retrieved from A0, and then A5 is set to a previously saved value, thus allowing the routine to access its global variables. Once A5 is set up, the global reference can be made safely. Finally, A5 is restored to its previous value to clean up. Sounds great, right? The only problem is, it doesn't work.

Here's why: the MPW C compiler will actually set up the global referencebeforethe SetA5 call, so accessing the global accesses some unknown part of memory. This is legal compiler optimization behavior! If GetA0 and SetA5 were functions or traps, the bug would disappear, but since they're declared inline the compiler doesn't feel compelled to delay the evaluation of the global array reference. The solution is to set up A5, then call a different routine that does the global reference.

Now in this case, how do you think we -- the debugging gods -- figured out the bug? We tried the first few things we could think of; but then when we weren't making headway after a few probes, we didn't just sit there and suffer in silence, banging our heads against the proverbial wall. We called in some Smart Friends! The veil of illusion was torn from our eyes, and we were shown the heart of the truth (in other words, one of them had seen this bug before). The point is that in debugging, two (or more) heads are far, far better than one. Bugs are not like germs: when you share them, everyone benefits. Maybe your very own Smart Friends have had a similar bug before, so they'll recognize immediately what's going on. Or maybe they'll think of something different to try. At the very least, they'll temporarily divert you from your frustration, maybe make you feel less stupid, and then you can all go out for pie together.

THAT'S IT!

Add these tools to your arsenal of bug sprays and foggers. Use them all and use them well, and you, your code, and your customers will be far better off.

FURTHER READING

Bedside books for the serious student of debugging:

  • How to Write Macintosh Software, 3rd ed., by Scott Knaster and Keith Rollin (Addison-Wesley, 1992).
  • Macintosh Programming Secrets, 2nd ed., by Scott Knaster and Keith Rollin (Addison-Wesley, 1992).
  • Debugging Macintosh Software with MacsBug by Konstantin Othmer and Jim Straus (Addison-Wesley, 1991).
  • MC68000 Family Programmer's Reference Manual (Motorola, Inc.).

FRED HUXHAM (AppleLink FRED) was born and raised in California. He used to be a tremendous athlete, know bazillions of babes, and go to wild parties in New York and California with people like Andy Warhol and Keith Haring. Now he's 15 pounds heavier, knows only one babe (his wife), and thinks a day spent sitting on his roof deck watching boats go through the Golden Gate is really exciting.*

GREG MARRIOTT (AppleLink GREG) is a SWM, 28, 6'0", 195 lbs., brown hair and eyes, sincere, hardworking, good sense of humor. Enjoys music, romantic walks, quiet evenings, and good books. Seeks nice woman for friendship and more. Send photo.*

In Bo3b's name, the "3" is silent. *

THANKS TO OUR TECHNICAL REVIEWERS Jim Reekes and Bryan Stearns*

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Apple iBooks Author 2.5 - Create and pub...
Apple iBooks Author helps you create and publish amazing Multi-Touch books for iPad. Now anyone can create stunning iBooks textbooks, cookbooks, history books, picture books, and more for iPad. All... Read more
TunnelBear 3.0.1 - Subscription-based pr...
TunnelBear is a subscription-based virtual private network (VPN) service and companion app, enabling you to browse the internet privately and securely. Features Browse privately - Secure your data... Read more
ExpanDrive 5.4.0 - Access cloud storage...
ExpanDrive builds cloud storage in every application, acts just like a USB drive plugged into your Mac. With ExpanDrive, you can securely access any remote file server directly from the Finder or... Read more
Opera 40.0.2308.62 - High-performance We...
Opera is a fast and secure browser trusted by millions of users. With the intuitive interface, Speed Dial and visual bookmarks for organizing favorite sites, news feature with fresh, relevant content... Read more
Apple iOS 10.0.2 - The latest version of...
iOS 10 is the biggest release of iOS ever. A massive update to Messages brings the power of the App Store to your conversations and makes messaging more personal than ever. Find your route with... Read more
Herald 7.0 - Notification plugin for Mai...
Note: Versions 2.1.3 (for OS X 10.7), 3.0.6 (for OS X 10.8), 4.0.8 (for OS X 10.9), 5.0.2 (for OS X 10.10), and 6.0.3 (for OS X 10.11) are no longer supported by the developer. Herald is a... Read more
Postbox 5.0.2 - Powerful and flexible em...
Postbox is a new email application that helps you organize your work life and get stuff done. It has all the elegance and simplicity of Apple Mail, but with more power and flexibility to manage even... Read more
Yummy FTP Pro 1.11.10 - $29.99
Yummy FTP Pro is an advanced Mac file transfer app which provides a full-featured professional toolkit combined with blazing speeds and impeccable reliability, so whether you want to transfer a few... Read more
Tidy Up 4.1.17 - $29.99
Tidy Up is a full-featured duplicate finder and disk-tidiness utility. Features With Tidy Up you can search for duplicate files and packages by the owner application, content, type, creator,... Read more
Logitech Control Center 3.9.5 - Keyboard...
Logitech Control Center (LCC) is designed to support OS X and allows you to take full advantage of your Logitech keyboard, mouse, or trackball. With the LCC you can: Browse the Internet using... Read more

How to build and care for your team in D...
Before you hit the trail and become a dog sledding legend, there’s actually a fair bit of prep work to be done. In Dog Sled Saga, you’re not only racing, you’re also building and caring for a team of furry friends. There’s a lot to consider—... | Read more »
How to win every race in Dog Sled Saga
If I had to guess, I’d say Dog Sled Saga is the most adorable racing game on the App Store right now. It’s a dog sled racing sim full of adorable, loyal puppies. Just look at those fluffy little tails wagging. Behind that cute, pixelated facade is... | Read more »
Let the war games commence in Gunship Ba...
Buzz Lightyear famously said, “This isn’t flying, this is falling – with style!” In the case of Gunship Battle: Second War, though, this really is flying - with style! The flight simulator app from Joycity puts you in control of 20 faithfully... | Read more »
How to get a high score in Fired Up
Fired Up is Noodlecake Games’ high score chasing, firefighting adventure. You take control of a wayward firefighter who propels himself up the side of a highrise with blasts of water. Sound silly? It is. It’s also pretty difficult. You can’t... | Read more »
NBA 2K17 (Games)
NBA 2K17 1.0 Device: iOS iPhone Category: Games Price: $7.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Following the record-breaking launch of NBA 2K16, the NBA 2K franchise continues to stake its claim as the most authentic sports video... | Read more »
Dog Sled Saga (Games)
Dog Sled Saga 1.0.1 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $3.99, Version: 1.0.1 (iTunes) Description: A game by Dan + Lisa As a rookie musher, foster a dogsledding team whose skills will grow if they're treated right. Week by... | Read more »
60 Seconds! Atomic Adventure (Games)
60 Seconds! Atomic Adventure 1.2 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $2.99, Version: 1.2 (iTunes) Description: 60 Seconds! is a dark comedy atomic adventure of scavenge and survival. Collect supplies and rescue your family... | Read more »
Tons of Bullets! (Games)
Tons of Bullets! 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $1.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: Tons of BulletsA retro 2D pixel platformer infused with tons of bullets and tons of features!Fight as Kenji the Ninja and... | Read more »
Sorcery! 4 (Games)
Sorcery! 4 1.0 Device: iOS Universal Category: Games Price: $4.99, Version: 1.0 (iTunes) Description: *** PLEASE NOTE: Sorcery! 4 requires a minimum of iPad 3 or iPhone 4 *** An epic adventure through a cursed citadel of monsters,... | Read more »
Building the perfect Animation Throwdown...
Animation Throwdown is a casual card game full of plenty of inside jokes from some of your favorite cartoons. It’s accessible as far as card games go, but that’s not to say that it hands your victories to you easily. There’s quite a bit that goes... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

Duplicate Sweeper Free On Mac App Store For O...
To celebrate the launch of Apple’s latest macOS Sierra, Stafford, United Kingdom based Wide Angle Software has announced that its duplicate file finder software, Duplicate Sweeper, is now available... Read more
13-inch Retina MacBook Pros on sale for up to...
B&H Photo has 13″ Retina Apple MacBook Pros on sale for up to $150 off MSRP. Shipping is free, and B&H charges NY tax only: - 13″ 2.7GHz/128GB Retina MacBook Pro: $1174.99 $125 off MSRP - 13... Read more
Evidence Surfaces Pointing To New A10X Chip F...
Citing a job description for a Project Lead position at Apple’s Austin, Texas engineering labs, Motley Fool’s Ashraf Eassa deduces that development is progressing well on Apple’s next-generation in-... Read more
Check Print’R for macOS Allows Anyone to Easi...
Delaware-based Match Software has announced the release and immediate availability of Check Print’R 3.21, an important update to their easy-to-use check printing application for macOS. Check Print’R... Read more
Apple refurbished 11-inch MacBook Airs availa...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 11″ MacBook Airs (the latest models), available for up to $170 off the cost of new models. An Apple one-year warranty is included with each MacBook, and shipping is... Read more
Apple refurbished 15-inch Retina MacBook Pros...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 2015 15″ Retina MacBook Pros available for up to $380 off the cost of new models. An Apple one-year warranty is included with each model, and shipping is free: - 15″ 2... Read more
Major Version 5 Release Of Free myTuner Radio...
AppGeneration Software has announced the release of myTuner Radio 5.0.1, an important update to their live radio app for iOS and Android platforms. With myTuner Radio, you can listen to more than 30,... Read more
TheAppStore Searches And Filters iOS And macO...
Boston based InchWest has announced the official launch of TheAppStore, a free web based service that lets users search iOS and Mac apps on the web without iTunes or the App store. TheAppStore... Read more
2TB Time Capsule on sale for $199, save $100
Amazon has 2TB Apple Time Capsules on sale for $199 including free shipping. Their price is $100 off MSRP. Choose Amazon as the seller when making your purchase, rather than a third party seller. Read more
12-inch 1.2GHz Rose Gold Retina MacBook on sa...
Amazon.com has the 2016 12″ 1.2GHz Rose Gold Retina MacBook on sale for $1254.02 including free shipping. Their price is $345 off MSRP, and it’s the lowest price available for this model from any... Read more

Jobs Board

Senior *Apple* Administrator - Pratt Instit...
POSITION SUMMARY: Directs the coordination and standardization of campus-wide Apple systems, including planning, analysis and implementation of Apple -related Read more
Restaurant Manager (Neighborhood Captain) - A...
…in every aspect of daily operation. WHY YOU'LL LIKE IT: You'll be the Big Apple . You'll solve problems. You'll get to show your ability to handle the stress and Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions- Napervi...
Job Description: Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, Read more
US- *Apple* Store Leader Program - Apple (Un...
…Summary Learn and grow as you explore the art of leadership at the Apple Store. You'll master our retail business inside and out through training, hands-on Read more
*Apple* Retail - Multiple Positions (US) - A...
Sales Specialist - Retail Customer Service and Sales Transform Apple Store visitors into loyal Apple customers. When customers enter the store, you're also the Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.